• City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.

    City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.

    Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.

    The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.

    If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -
    report.gif
    in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.

Seattle Underground

I assume you mean what remains of the old vaulted sidewalks before the streets were raised?

Short answer is that I highly, highly doubt it. By the time they were renovated to modern codes and standards for safety and handicap-accessibility, it wouldn't be worth the expense to reuse them. They are probably too narrow to handle any significant pedestrian volume given fire codes. And besides, the temperature in Seattle doesn't really get extreme enough to warrant massive investment in an underground walkway system downtown. There's a reason such networks are concentrated in cities like Montreal, Toronto, MSP, & Houston (the latter to the other extreme, of course). Put another way, Chicago kinda-sorta has the Pedway but even that is of marginal seriousness and completeness relative to the extensive Canadian networks. So in order to justify the system, the city should be at least as extreme as Chicago, which Seattle really isn't.
 
Also, they only exist where the land level was raised after the 1889 fire, which means they're only on the lowlands around Pioneer Square. That area isn't busy enough to warrant a second sidewalk system.
 
Also, they only exist where the land level was raised after the 1889 fire, which means they're only on the lowlands around Pioneer Square. That area isn't busy enough to warrant a second sidewalk system.

It seems to me there should be a better use for them than just an occasional tour group.
 
It seems to me there should be a better use for them than just an occasional tour group.

Have you been? Might have some potential as clubs, etc., but I don't think there's much demand for additional sidewalks.

Good place to encounter the ghosts of prostitutes, apparently.
 
I always wondered if they could reuse these places. I've never been, but an underground shopping center maybe?

But even if someone wanted to build something there, would the city allow it? I mean, who owns these areas? The city or building owners? And would the city allow remodeling these storefronts/sidewalks?
 
Why would they need "use"? Do you go to Rome and try to find commercial use for their ruins?

It's hard to imagine a feasible way to make it happen. The tunnels themselves would need massive work and new public access points including ADA. Of course they're (at least often) in public ROWs. It's hard to imagine that magnitude of public money being released. Neighboring buildings would need some economic reason to build major renovations in their basements. For the tunnels to be used, many if not most buildings would have to build useful destinations, probably simultaneously, which is highly unrealistic. One major hurdle would be the need for each building to renovate at least enough to provide walls and security past their property...some would fight the public ROW proposal to avoid this.

Seattle is also philosophically opposed to skybridges and underground walkways, because they take pedestrians off the streets. This idea would face major oppostion among Pioneer Square merchants even if many landlords, office tenants, residents, and tourist interests liked it.

The only potential I can see is for someone to decide to renovate a couple buildings, and use their own money to upgrade a small portion of the public walkway to connect them. Maybe neighboring buildings join them later. But this assumes that the costs for upgrading that tunnel portion are low enough. Maybe the ADA hurdle could be overcome if the buildings already have elevators to their basements that can be publicly accessible. Undoubtedly there are regulatory hurdles I'm not thinking of.
 
I took the tour way back in the 80's. All the older buildings, Smith Tower included, have at least two floor each in the underground. It would make a really great mall or something.
 
a little background information on this so called Seattle Underground would be much appreciated ty.
 
a little background information on this so called Seattle Underground would be much appreciated ty.

From Wikipedia:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seattle_Underground

Seattle's first buildings were wooden. In 1889, a cabinetmaker accidentally overturned and ignited a glue pot. An attempt to extinguish it with water spread the burning grease-based glue. The fire chief was out of town, and although the volunteer fire department responded they made the mistake of trying to use too many hoses at once. They never recovered from the subsequent drop in water pressure, and the Great Seattle Fire destroyed 25 city blocks.[1]

While a destructive fire was not unusual for the time, the response of the city leaders was. Instead of rebuilding the city as it was before, they made two strategic decisions: that all new buildings must be of stone or brick, insurance against a similar disaster in the future; and to regrade the streets one to two stories higher than the original street grade. Pioneer Square had originally been built mostly on filled-in tidelands and, as a consequence, it often flooded. The new street level also assisted in ensuring that gravity-assisted flush toilets that funneled into Elliott Bay did not back up at high tide.

For the regrade, the streets were lined with concrete walls that formed narrow alleyways between the walls and the buildings on both sides of the street, with a wide "alley" where the street was. The naturally steep hillsides were used, and through a series of sluices material was washed into the wide "alleys", raising the streets to the desired new level, generally 12 feet higher than before, in some places nearly 30 feet.

At first pedestrians climbed ladders to go between street level and the sidewalks in front of the building entrances. Brick archways, as seen in the image to the left, were constructed next to the road surface, above the submerged sidewalks. Skylights with small panes of clear glass (which later became amethyst-colored because of manganese in the glass) were installed, creating the area now called the Seattle Underground.

When they reconstructed their buildings, merchants and landlords knew that the ground floor would eventually be underground and the next floor up would be the new ground floor, so there is very little decoration on the doors and windows of the original ground floor, but extensive decoration on the new ground floor.

Once the new sidewalks were complete, building owners moved their businesses to the new ground floor, although merchants carried on business in the lowest floors of buildings that survived the fire, and pedestrians continued to use the underground sidewalks lit by the glass cubes (still seen on some streets) embedded in the grade-level sidewalk above.
In 1907 the city condemned the Underground for fear of pneumonic plague, two years before the 1909 World Fair in Seattle (Alaska-Yukon-Pacific Exposition). The basements were left to deteriorate or were used as storage. Some became illegal flophouses for the homeless, gambling halls, speakeasies, and opium dens.

Only a small portion of the Seattle Underground has been restored and made safe and accessible to the public on guided tours.
 
Why would they need "use"? Do you go to Rome and try to find commercial use for their ruins?

Why not?

The History Channel had a series not too long ago that showed the condition of some of Rome's underground tunnels. Many of them looked nearly brand new.

Why not modernize them and use them for something? Maybe an underground mall or subway station? Seems like a waste to just let them rot.

The Collesium could be restored and used as a modern day sports arena or concert hall.They held at least once concert there already.
 
I took the tour way back in the 80's. All the older buildings, Smith Tower included, have at least two floor each in the underground. It would make a really great mall or something.

How about something like a farmers market or swap meet? They could even turn it into a haunted house/maze for Halloween - maybe something like this? -http://www.scarefest.com/haunted_house_in_stlouis_missouri_thedarkness/home.cfm
 
Why not?

The History Channel had a series not too long ago that showed the condition of some of Rome's underground tunnels. Many of them looked nearly brand new.

Why not modernize them and use them for something? Maybe an underground mall or subway station? Seems like a waste to just let them rot.

The Collesium could be restored and used as a modern day sports arena or concert hall.They held at least once concert there already.

All completely unrealistic. Even if those ideas are technically possible, the cost and the destruction of history would make them unfeasible.
 
Why would they need "use"? Do you go to Rome and try to find commercial use for their ruins?

You got me completely wrong. I wasn't saying that we need to modernize the underground tunnels by adding a Sephora or an Abercrombie and Fitch. But yeah, I've always wanted to see it opened more to the public other than just tours. Seattle might not get as cold as Chicago or Montreal but seeing this area used as underground "sidewalks" would be nice.

If you ask me, the entire Pioneer Square area needs to be brought to it's old glory, including the underground tunnels. Converting the run down brick buildings into condo's would bring more people into the area that don't just wanna get fucked up after a Seahawks win. There's already a lot of galleries in the area, and nice coffee shops. The Art Walk sure helps Pioneer Square to not stay behind, but I think more people need to be brought in to be part of the community instead of extremely expensive condo's.

I think it'd be better to have people live in modernized buildings rather than building a fake complex in the Seahawks parking lot. I'm not really sure if it would work but it did save Pioneer Square when people began to move offices into some of these buildings. So why wouldn't having a community work as well? And yeah, I know we already have condo's there but more would be nice. I hate seeing those amazing brick buildings go to waste, and some are really run down or are completely boarded off.

Maybe this would even mean that more medium income units could be opened up if a complex is built in the seahawks parking lot. I say use what we already have!

These tunnels could be used by residents and we could also restore them. The tour doesn't have to be cancelled either, the tunnel could remain closed during the Summer for tours. Of course it wouldn't be the same so I'm not sure how many people would actually pay to see a remodeled version of it.

I feel like the advantages of opening up the tunnel and remodeling it to acceptable standards is better than a tour. I'm not an expert of course so I don't really know how that will affect the areas tourist industry.

And we can find better uses to these old buildings without getting rid of the history. We don't have to cover the bricks and completely pave over the old floor. I am against the destruction of these buildings or the gutting of them but it'd be nice to see them look good again.
 
Of course the buildings should be more fully used. Most are (aside from vacancies), but the rest should be as well.

As for the "north lot" project, that's crucial because it'll bring a volume of people that will help revitalize retail and other uses in those old buildings. It'll make the neighborhood more well-rounded.

Tunnels aren't necessary for reviving old buildings. In fact, trying to upgrade the tunnels would be a major cost to every building, whether updated or not, and therefore have the potential to hurt the neighborhood by making renovations more difficult, and making cost of ownership more difficult.

Close the tunnels in the summer? That would kill any sort of retail you want to build there.

Put retail in the tunnels? That would hurt retail at ground level. Also, since most buildings would be unlikely to convert their basements to retail either right away or anytime soon (even in a great economy), what's the point of going down there?
 
I always wondered if they could reuse these places. I've never been, but an underground shopping center maybe?

But even if someone wanted to build something there, would the city allow it? I mean, who owns these areas? The city or building owners? And would the city allow remodeling these storefronts/sidewalks?

Take a look at Underground Atlanta first. It has had 2 incarnations already, one in 1969 that started out very successfully but eventually went downhill and closed in 1980...and the 2nd in 1989 that started out wildly popular and eventually went downhill again. It's still fairly successful, depending on who you ask, but it's pretty much only tourists now. Locals don't have much use for it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Underground_Atlanta

What keeps Underground Atlanta going is it's historical significance. Most of the buildings were built during Civil War Reconstruction, and became underground when the viaducts were built one level above the street in order to cross over the many railroad tracks downtown. This viaduct system became the new street level and it left the ground level shops "underground". It sounds like something similar happened in Seattle.
 
Close the tunnels in the summer? That would kill any sort of retail you want to build there.

Put retail in the tunnels? That would hurt retail at ground level. Also, since most buildings would be unlikely to convert their basements to retail either right away or anytime soon (even in a great economy), what's the point of going down there?

No no no, to be able to close the tunnels in the summer there would have to be no retail down there whatsoever. That wouldn't be too profitable for building owners though, and cash runs these streets (well, tunnels). The tunnels would only remain open during the winter with deck-like walkways to prevent major deconstruction of the original ground.

I don't want to see retail down there, I just always wondered. However, I would like to see more use out of them.
 
Then the cost would be massive, with little or no money coming in to offset it. All for something that has little point.
 
Having been on the tour, I can't imagine that there would be any way for something to pencil out. It's not really in a busy enough area for there to be street level activity and below street level activity most of the time and the cost would be massive (and the politics involved would be extreme).
 


Back
Top