• City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.

    City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.

    Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.

    The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.

    If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -
    report.gif
    in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.

Religious Landscape Study

More religious nones than Catholics in Boston and Chicago.

As many or more nones as Christians in New Hampshire, Vermont, Oregon.

Most Christian states are Arkansas, Mississippi, South Carolina.
 
More religious nones than Catholics in Boston and Chicago.

I'm VERY much responsible for part of that.

Raised super-catholic, from old school Chicago Catholic stock going back generations on both my paternal (Irish) and maternal (German) sides, church every Sunday, K-12 Catholic schooling, the whole nine.

The only reason I ever set foot in a church these days is for other people's baptisms, weddings, and funerals.


I got no use for it.

Plus, they always want money.

Fuck that shit!!
 
Portland and Seattle have highest share of nones, with SF and Boston close behind. No shocker.

NYC has highest share of non-Christian affiliated, also no shocker.

People might be surprised that Detroit has average share of non-Christian affiliated, conflating large ME population with large Muslim population. Plenty of Muslims but most are Christian.
 
Looking back historically, mainline Protestants have collapsed, Catholic identity has been tapering off since the early 2000s (only partially held up by immigrants), evangelicals have held steady as a share of population.

How many mainline Protestants today compared to say 1960? Their grandchildren have become nones, evangelicals or married into other faith groups.
 
I'm amazed how many mainline Protestant churches somehow survive. You could be in, say, the Bronx, which hasn't had appreciable mainline demographics since WW2 or earlier, and you still see functioning, often quite large, Presbyterian and Episcopal churches.

The Bronx ethnic whites of long ago were all Jewish and Catholic, and the Latin and black successors were Evangelical, Catholic and AME. So how are these churches still operating?

Maybe they had large endowments and can still survive with a few dozen worshippers. Also the Caribbean diaspora might generate some members.
 
Liberal Protestantism is really dying out. The "WASPs" I know often have parents or grandparents that had their funerals in Anglican (Episcopalian) or United Church of Canada churches, but few under 70 seem to have religious connection/affiliation today.

And now cultural Catholics are becoming less of a thing too, though there's obviously a conservative-religious and immigrant component that keeps Catholicism in better shape.
 
I'm amazed how many mainline Protestant churches somehow survive. You could be in, say, the Bronx, which hasn't had appreciable mainline demographics since WW2 or earlier, and you still see functioning, often quite large, Presbyterian and Episcopal churches.

The Bronx ethnic whites of long ago were all Jewish and Catholic, and the Latin and black successors were Evangelical, Catholic and AME. So how are these churches still operating?

Maybe they had large endowments and can still survive with a few dozen worshippers. Also the Caribbean diaspora might generate some members.


you mean you're amazed in your notorious online researching.

when was the last time you actually set foot in the bronx, if ever?

much less observed active churches there. :rolleyes:
 
I'm amazed how many mainline Protestant churches somehow survive. You could be in, say, the Bronx, which hasn't had appreciable mainline demographics since WW2 or earlier, and you still see functioning, often quite large, Presbyterian and Episcopal churches.

The Bronx ethnic whites of long ago were all Jewish and Catholic, and the Latin and black successors were Evangelical, Catholic and AME. So how are these churches still operating?

Maybe they had large endowments and can still survive with a few dozen worshippers. Also the Caribbean diaspora might generate some members.

They probably do a lot of community outreach and to survive, they've evolved to be more of a charitable organization and shifted away from traditional roles as merely a church as congregations declined.
 
I don't know how common this is in New York, but in Seattle a number of churches have downsized into new facilities, or plan to, selling their big original properties to fund small new ones.

They do this because a huge old church costs a ton of money to maintain, heat, etc., and 1/4 the original congregation isn't enough to afford it. Historic churches can be demolished if they're in church ownership, avoiding historic protections (at least in WA).

An old church will occasionally be converted to something else, like a performance hall, a nightclub, or even housing, but generally that's a money-loser. The organization tends to get more money by selling the site for its land value.
 
I'm VERY much responsible for part of that.

Raised super-catholic, from old school Chicago Catholic stock going back generations on both my paternal (Irish) and maternal (German) sides, church every Sunday, K-12 Catholic schooling, the whole nine.

The only reason I ever set foot in a church these days is for other people's baptisms, weddings, and funerals.


I got no use for it.

Plus, they always want money.

Fuck that shit!!

Same here... I would add site seeing (Europe & South America) and/or Carnivals to the list of of setting foot in church now-a-days
 
Metro Honolulu is 6% Buddhist.

Not surprising, either. Going there, you see lots of Buddhist temples, many of them Japanese sects.

I find it interesting that percentage-wise, there are just as many Buddhists as Jews in Los Angeles (3% each). SF Bay Area is 4% Hindu.

Hawaii has the highest percentage of Buddhists of any US state (5% according to the link in the OP, 8% according to Wikipedia). California has the next highest at 2%, though in terms of sheer numbers, California has the most people who identify as Buddhist than any other state.
 
Looking at changes in Chicagoland over the past 10 years:

Religion | 2014 | 2024 | change

Catholic | 34% | 29% | -5 points
Evangelical | 16% | 10% | -6 points
Mainline | 11% | 9% | -2 points
H.Black | 8% | 8% | none
Other Chist. | 3% | 3% | none

Jewish | 3% | 2% | -1 point
Muslim | 2% | 3% | +1 point
Buddhist | 1% | 1% | none
Hindu | 1% | 1% | none
Other | 2% | 3% | +1 point

Nones | 22% | 32% | +10 points



A collective -12 point decline in Christians, exceeding the national decline of -9 points for that group.
 
Last edited:
Interesting. I would not guess more Muslims than Jews in Chicagoland.

Well, according to this survey's data, they just flip-flopped over the past 10 years.

But the numbers for both groups are so small that we're probably close to the margins of error.

Also, compared to a place like NYC, a shit ton of Chicago's Jews are not all the particularly religious, and thus they are easier to "lose" as they bleed into the nones.

Also also, some of the gigantic point swings make me a little suspect of this data overall. I mean, did evangelicals in Chicagoland really go from 16% down to 10% in just one decade? A 38% decline in just 10 years time? Really???

Seems kinda hard to believe, right?
 
Last edited:
It seemed to me that Dan was a little proud of the new pope being from Chicago, though. ;)
Often, the Catholics as the Jews are proud homers, just like myself and my Paris.
 
It seemed to me that Dan was a little proud of the new pope being from Chicago, though.

Oh, it's still totally hilarious that the new Pope is a Sox fan who grew up in Dolton. And most of the nonsense in that thread was just me pushing back hard against certain SSP New Yorkers who were trying to act like New Yorkers wouldn't have noticed or cared if the new Pope was a Yankees fan.

Yeah. Fucking. Right.

GtLXcLSXQAEZq7E

Source: https://x.com/whitesox/status/1932844089935831420



And I'll always be a cultural Catholic given my upbringing, even if I've personally chosen a different belief path apart from the orthodoxy of the Roman Catholic Church.
 
I'm VERY much responsible for part of that.

Raised super-catholic, from old school Chicago Catholic stock going back generations on both my paternal (Irish) and maternal (German) sides, church every Sunday, K-12 Catholic schooling, the whole nine.

The only reason I ever set foot in a church these days is for other people's baptisms, weddings, and funerals.


I got no use for it.

Plus, they always want money.

Fuck that shit!!


Agreed, but as far the money conundrum, it will carry on.

Walking in various neighbourhoods in Montreal, I notice more churches in disrepair as time goes. I'm always happy to see a church taken over by an immigrant community when the locals have gone AWOL on their pulpit-o-rama.

The thing to remember is that a lot of these beautiful properties will need upkeep, and if they don't become private properties for lack of religious use, they might become public infrastructure and the costs will be passed on to taxpayers, which brings us back to square one.
 


Back
Top