Population Depth (square roots)


Stryker

New member
Borrowing an idea from another thread. Where someone mentioned using sqr roots for calculating mp seats.



Its an interesting idea because its an approximate mix of density and gross population.

Anyway Ill start.

Toronto 2362.

St johns 443.

Halifax 624.

EDIT: Sorry my poor theory of mind makes me a horrid thread starter.

Im borrowing an idea from another thread, and suggesting its a far better representation of size.


Instead of a using population size as a measure of City, I'm suggesting an alternative which measures population depth.

If we can assume population is a suitable approximation for the area in which a city occupies( assumes urban densities are similar see link). Than Im suggesting we take the square root of this which approximates the distance from the corp or the radius of the city.



http://forum.skyscraperpage.com/showthread.php?t=138325

The thread shows that densities are relatively consistent for most Canadian cities. Downtown are dense, suburbs less, so but in general density doesn't matter much for most cities.
 
Last edited:
*shrug*

So one seat for every 100 foot-persons?

Edmonton

City: 901 (9 seats)

Metro: 1 077 (11 seats?)
 
*shrug*

So one seat for every 100 foot-persons?

Edmonton

City: 901 (9 seats)

Metro: 1 077 (11 seats?)

I was trying to imply that its an interesting way of comparing cities in Canada. The mp seats was a refers to someone elses post.


As city is generally spread on a north south and east west axis.

A place with 10000 homes isn't gonna be found on one rode running east to west. We live in grids.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure what you mean by "using square roots". What actually is the function that you're applying here? Is this literally just the root of the population of each city?
 
How would cities be oriented if not north-south and east-west?

And how does that impact whatever the calculation you're using is?

And what is that calculation?

Also, what's the number mean? Is that how many MPs we should have? 443? Because that's a bit too many.
 
How would cities be oriented if not north-south and east-west?

And how does that impact whatever the calculation you're using is?

And what is that calculation?

Also, what's the number mean? Is that how many MPs we should have? 443? Because that's a bit too many.

Its simply a way of comparing and contrasting the size of a city.

My point about the north south Is simply this.


Our attachment to metro populations is that its the easiest way to quantify the size of a city.

It allows us to ignore things like density and distribution and get to an objective estimate of how large a city is..

Toronto is clearly much larger than Calgary because of its overall population.

The problem is that this approximation correlates to the rough area a city covers, which can be misleading.

Which descriptor would be seem more relevant to you.

metropolis has a downtown of 400 square kilometers . Or the downtown of metropolis spans 20 kms from the center.

now maybe some might prefer the area, but I think most people would interpret distance from the corp to the edge to be far easier to understand.



But you get the just. Comparing square arts of population has the same effect, as calculating the distance from the downtown.
 
what about population multiplied by 6.02214129 ×10^23 (Avogadro Constant)? Personally, I prefer the natural log.
 
what about population multiplied by 6.02214129 ×10^23 (Avogadro Constant)? Personally, I prefer the natural log.

You'll want to divide by Avogadro constant to get moles of people. Which would be expressed as "[city] has [number] mol people".
 
what about population multiplied by 6.02214129 ×10^23 (Avogadro Constant)? Personally, I prefer the natural log.

I remember one of my old high school math teachers yelled at us that the 10-base logs were dumb and pointless in the real world, and that everything was about the natural log, but he had to teach them anyway.

He may have been on to something, natural logs are kinda sexy.
 
ln(Edmonton CMA) = power of the people of Edmonton is 14
lphi(Edmonton CMA) = whorl of the people of Edmonton is 29
 
ln(Edmonton CMA) = power of the people of Edmonton is 14
lphi(Edmonton CMA) = whorl of the people of Edmonton is 29

Fun fact: despite being an irrational base, all integers have a terminating representation in base-phi. One possible representation of Edmonton's CMA population is base phi is:

1159869(10) = 100000000010000010010001010000.000101000010001010001010101001(phi)
 
Ugh, I am way too sober for this right now. :uhh:

Do you honestly believe Toronto functionally offers 20 times as many options as a place like Moncton, stjohns, or regina.


We can all agree bigger cities will offer more, but a linear quantity isn't the best way to represent the increase in options.
 
That wasn't meant as an attack. I'm still not sure what this thread is about though. My bad, carry on.
 
I havent quite figured out the theory which this thread is about, but I have a number of theories about cities myself. Here's one; "All cities are thin at one end, much, much thicker in the middle, and then thin again at the far end." That is the theory that I have, and which is mine, and what it is too.
 


Back
Top