Some of this just hurts my brain. Their allegations are dangerous.
They think that just because neighborhoods are near a planned rail line, they will automatically become blighted and be surrendered to the city through eminent domain. In fact, the word is used so much in their argument it becomes loaded. If everything can be blight, as they allege, then we're all doomed.
In 1961, an architecture critic named Jane Jacobs fought an urban-renewal project that threatened to wipe out her neighborhood. Her book, The Death and Life of Great American Cities, compared urban planning to “the pseudoscience of bloodletting.”12 Many years later, The Economist wrote that Jacobs’ book “stopped America’s urban renewal movement in its tracks.”13 In fact, urban renewal is alive and well in Colorado.
How dare they twist Jane Jacobs for their freeway loving hogwash?
Despite the prevalence of such “blight,” Louisville was named one of the “five best cities to live” in the U.S. by Money magazine in 2005.7
According to Wikipedia, The median income for a household in the city was $69,945, and the median income for a family was
$81,512. This is their model?
Their methodology is utterly broken. According to them since Denver, the district, and the developer keeps some portion of the property and sales taxes on new developments, these developments "cost" the city in terms of how much the assessed value goes to subsequent bonds and what municipal services are shorted by some redirected financing.
The problem is,
nobody would have that money if the developments were
never built. You cannot have your cake, a thriving urban center, and eat the taxes from that development at the same time when you're dealing with blight. You need the externality of city government because the free market
failed. It failed because in the private sector not everybody can be rich and afford the tenets of what this center pushes everywhere. The low-end will always be somewhere. This happens
en masse in cities.
They grow or die. What do you expect?
Since everything is blight according to them, it's as if the cities have free reign to tear apart anything they want. It's not quite that easy.
Urban-renewal advocates point to revitalized areas, such as the 16th Avenue Mall in downtown Denver...
Way to do your research!
Redeveloped areas consume urban services, such as fire and police protection, sewers, and schools. Yet they make little contribution to such services while their taxes are used to repay bonds. This means that other taxpayers must either accept lower quality services or increased taxes to maintain services.
What? City financing doesnt work that way. It's not like Block X requires Y fulltime policemen and Z jail cells, etc. And they don't even talk about where the retail sales taxes are going either, again, things that would never happen unless the development came.
Some more gems:
As another study of 235 cities in the greater Chicago area confirmed, “cities, towns, and villages that had TIF districts actually grew more slowly than municipalities that did not use TIF.”
That's a lot of cities to compare. At that level, there are so many variables it's impossible to account for any one in particular and asking about TIF is pointless. But the cities don't need TIF districts if they're growing or nothing's wrong.
In general, growth pays for itself out of new taxes—but not if those new taxes are diverted into subsidizing that growth by paying costs that would otherwise be paid by developers.
Nice assumption.
They ignore that even with TIF, not everybody makes money. It's like the city makes it so that developing anywhere outside of a TIF district is impossible.
They complain that Denver has the highest housing prices of any state without a coastline. Everyone wants a window with an ocean view or whatever. If Denver can beat that, I take that as a sign they're doing something right--most of the midwest is only good for bread and corn. Functional cities can be expensive to live in, and most states without a coastline aren't attractive to the American ideal. That's the price you pay, our free market at work. Denver is also the largest city in an area the size of Western Europe, so yes, it's going to be expensive.
The arguments in favor of transit-oriented development are circular. One of the justifications for FasTracks was that it would enhance the value of transit-oriented developments then being planned. With regard to a transit-oriented development in Arvada, a pro-FasTracks report stated, “If new transit is not brought into the Ridge Home development, the development timeline and mix of uses [in the development] would likely need to be revised.”55 Now that FasTracks has been approved, RTD argues that more transit-oriented developments are needed to make FasTracks work.
Well, duh. I don't know what their argument is. The need for a enhanced transportation corridor is already there. You build the lines, they will take enough off the roads and be filled with people in the new developments that follow. The city grows better, everybody wins.
When completed, Stapleton will provide 12,000 homes and apartments, three million square feet of retail space, and ten million square feet of office space.
Cha-ching! Look at their kicker at the end:
But considering Denver’s high housing prices, it is inconceivable that developers would not have eagerly redeveloped Stapleton and Lowry without public subsidies. In all probability, such developments would have included homes with large yards, and they would have separated residential from retail and commercial uses. For the most part, they would not have been New Urban developments with tiny lots, excessive multi-family housing, and mixed uses. Urban renewal is no longer about fixing blight. It is about imposing planners’ utopian ideals on urban families.
This is honestly what they'd rather have? Less office space, less retail space, less of everything except the land they consume and the environment they destroy? Why would a city not want to maximise the amount of office, retail, and residential within its borders?
They talk about imposing ideals on where people want to live (which has no barometer really, nobody is
forced to live in a condo) but are completely against anything that isn't a single family home with two cars in the street-facing garage. There are enough suburbs to go around, and that will always be the problem.
West Jefferson County Metro Fire Protection District was “shocked” to realize that tax-increment financing would siphon more than $20 million from its tax revenues over the life of the project, including a cost of $108,000 the first year.
When you spin it like that, as if the development is outright TAKING the money, yeah, I guess I'd be shocked too.
For Louisville again ...
After hearing this testimony, the city council initially rejected the plan by a 4-to-3 vote in November, 2006. 70 However, after receiving a report from a consultant that claimed the project would produce a net increase in tax revenues to the city, the city council approved the plan by a 5-to-2 vote in December, 2006.71 Yet the study did not ask whether the net increase in taxes might be even greater if redevelopment took place without any subsidies.
Why do I doubt that?
People who are inclined to drive will not give up their cars just because they have been forced by high housing prices to live in New Urban developments.
Ow. Yes. It's the fault of New Urbanism for high land prices. Or something. I can't wrap my brain around it. They're idiots, and I'm on vicodin, which is only somewhat effective at putting me a level where I can comprehend the ridiculousness of their argument. You have to be high on something to believe their bull when it's written down like it is.
Who is asking anyone to give their car up? New developments will have plenty of parking. They're building to the maximum now because there are enough cars on the road now, and yes, new houses come with cars. For now. Many times that's the law, and to their credit the center is pushing for less regulation. But, storing cars is one thing, getting them on the roads is certainly another, and that's when the city foots the bill for how you choose to live. If you can do downstairs instead of driving 4 miles to buy a frickin six-pack you're going to drive less.
Sooner or later, you reach a certain threshold with continued NU zoning and developments that
less cars and less road hours are required for the people that are living there.
I will tear apart their conclusion questions now.
Why should cities become developers, that is, why should they take risks with taxpayers’ money that developers themselves might not take?
See my previous assessments about the free market failing where it does.
Why should some developers and property owners be favored with subsidies when their developments directly compete with unsubsidized retail, office, and housing projects?
Because they are going to an area where the free market has failed.
What happens to the people and businesses evicted by eminent domain?
They're taken care of, or at least they should be. In every project, someone will have a horror story. In AZ, the eminent domain argument is against completing the loop freeway. You can't have it both ways folks.
What happens when developers refuse to do any more developments unless they are all subsidized?
That's what happens when you buy into the bullshit this center is producing. Sprawl fails horribly.
Why should planners be allowed to socially engineer Coloradans so that they live in an environmentally-correct manner?
Huh? Social engineering? Mixed use zoning where it was
illegal before is social engineering? Do I have to have an answer for the environmentally correct part?
Why should Coloradans who want to live a New-Urban lifestyle be subsidized by those who do not?
One, you need them to sustain the tax revenue from the development as it is and sustain it through exurban development. Residential is ultimately an aside from the retail sales tax generators and the prestige of Class A office space. Sprawl is extremely vulnerable to its own devices, the next ring laying waste to the one prior.
Moreover, the urbanite's drain on city resources is far less than that of people in a single family lifestyle. Freeways and roads are expensive and finitely infinite--you reach a breaking point sooner or later where your city is a lost cause. Freeways for the next 100 years are more expensive than transit is now.
Will subsidized New Urban developments produce the benefits claimed for them, such as reductions in per-capita driving?
It's a start. In Lakewood, by the statistics that the center is producing, the new numbers beat the metro average for transit ridership. But the way they put it, it's an either-or.
New Urbanism is not perfect. There are things you have to watch for, and denser cities are harder to manage. But replace all the standard problems you have to watch for in new urbanism with the Center for the American Dream's requisite freeways and decay and you figure out which one you'd rather 'fix.'
What happens when cities saturate the limited demand for such communities?
If a city in space or any other infinite two-dimensional plain could sprawl evenly and infinitely, it can only survive economic death by having subsequent rings pay for the center-radiating decay of the ones previous, requiring infinitely increasing luxury. This is the bitter reality of what the Center for the American Dream pushes.
On earth, we run into boundaries that prevent further horizontal growth of cities. Since that luxury, aka desirability, is also finite, a sprawling city after a while becomes that magic word:
unsustainable. Sprawl stops eventually before moving to the next region. Cities in its wake become like Mesa, Arizona. Too big, too sprawling, and choking economically and environmentally. The worst part is that the voting public in that city is too dumb to tell.
You have to infill at a certain point if you are to keep growing. Again, grow or die. It's that simple.