City committee ignores experts, OKs lots on land with bad water
Patrick Dare The Ottawa Citizen
Thursday, February 28, 2008
Several of the city's most experienced planning staff members lined up in front of Ottawa's agricultural and rural affairs committee Thursday and implored members not to allow rural lots to be created on land with poor water. Their advice was not taken.
The staff members wanted the committee to support their appeal of a committee of adjustment decision to the Ontario Municipal Board. That committee had given a property owner the right to create three house lots on Stoneridge Road in West Carleton, even though the water on the property is too high in salt.
Grant Lindsay, a manager of development approvals with the city, told councillors the city's planning staff has tried to be flexible when looking at land-development proposals. But he said approving lot severances that are clearly in violation of the city's own official plan and provincial policy is going too far.
"What you see here today is an example where we feel we cannot go," said Mr. Lindsay. "This is not appropriate lot creation."
He said the city was approving construction on land that had substandard water when the number one concern of residents in the rural parts of Ottawa is water quality. And he said there's no need to be creating lots on substandard property because there's a big supply of such lots elsewhere in the city.
Michel Kearney, a hydrogeologist at the city, said that levels of salt and chloride got worse at the property as a test well kept pumping. He said the pumping didn't continue long enough to show where the levels would become stable. He said the deeper you drill for water in this part of the city, the higher the salt content in the water.
Mr. Kearney cautioned the councillors that the health of residents could be at risk and that provincial water guidelines should not be trumped. City officials also said high salt content can damage the water and sewage systems of a house.
City lawyer Christine Enta said provincial regulation requires that rural lots have wells generating water that is safe and aesthetically suitable for consumption.
Planner Terry MacHardy said there are seven developments in the western part of the city in the same general area that are on hold because of water problems. One couple in the Dunrobin area recently complained that their $300,000 house was worthless because their well was producing small quantities of heavily salted water.
Michael Wildman, manager of infrastructure approvals at the city, emphasized that the Ministry of Environment is on the record opposing building on lots where there is more than 200 milligrams of salt per litre of water. The Stoneridge property had 236 milligrams and the numbers appeared to be headed higher, but pumping was halted. Mr. Wildman said it is not possible to treat that level of water to eliminate the salt.
The lawyer for the landowner, Janet Bradley, argued to the committee that the provincial standards on water quality are guidelines, not requirements.
She said there's room for some flexibility in taking into account the local situation. She said in this case, there are 22 lots across the road that are approved for development even though they will have similar water. That development was approved before Ontario's new water standards were brought in during the 1990.
An engineer hired by the landowners said neighbours aren't having big problems with the water and he considers the salt level "acceptable."
A majority of the councillors at the meeting, Glenn Brooks, Doug Thompson and Eli El-Chantiry, agreed and voted not to support the staff. Mr.
El-Chantiry said this small property owner should not become the city's test case for well water. Councillors Rob Jellett and Gord Hunter supported the staff position.
Thursday's 3-2 decision is not reviewed by city council, so the lots will be developed and the planning staff's appeal to the municipal board withdrawn.
Mr. Lindsay served notice that there will be many more such cases that will be brought to the agricultural and rural affairs committee.
© The Ottawa Citizen 2008