Monorails


I mean less unsightly like this!!!!!!!!!!!



Waterloo.jpg
 
Monorail does fill a niche, particularly in dense areas, or alignments with substantial curves and grades. The cross-sections are substantially smaller as well, so they have an advantage over conventional elevated rail when shadows or aesthetics are a concern.

Tama Monorail (Tama Area, Western Tōkyō)


Source: nakajimalassie on Flickr


Source: motokiwaz on Flickr


Source: abuckingham on Flickr


Source: yoppy on Flickr

Shōnan Monorail (Shōnan Area, Southwest Tōkyō / Yokohama)


Source: petite-tomo on Flickr


Source: m1a9366b on Flickr

Tōkyō Monorail




Source: ykanazawa1999 on Flickr


Source: ykanazawa1999 on Flickr

Keep in mind, I'm not a huge fan of monorail (or other small-capacity systems like guideway transits), but they do have their place. To deny otherwise is simple prejudice and ignorance.
 
I think monorails could serve a purpose, but in VERY dense population centers where it could serve as kind of an "in neighborhood" people mover between large centers of employment, entertainment, etc. The benefits being that smaller cars could run every 3-5 minutes and because they are more nimble, they would be better equipped to meander through dense development. They're like street cars but have the benefit of not being confined to the streets and the traffic, lights, etc. that come with that.
 
Because of that Simpsons episode? lol

Maybe the lameness of the APM systems built in Jacksonville, Miami, Las Colinas, and Detroit lead to a negative image of these systems in general. I think Denver turned one down in the 1970's for its dubious value. To me they always screamed 1970's planning with dead office zones connected by walkways and trams to whisk riders to their parked cars, not their neighborhoods.

But your right, you do find monorails and their people mover kin in the weirdest places. Pealridge Mall in Honolulu has one, so does Huntsville, Alabama of all places

i think i can can outweird ya -- this one is the former king's island amusement park lion safari monorail -- it's being revived by the suburban jungle jim's grocery in suburban cincinnati. no kidding! :D

JungleMono_01.jpg


http://www.junglejims.com/


as far as airport monorails go, just for the record and because i was there last week here's the texas dfw airport version.
it's fine for the terminals, but it really needs to go out to the car rental sector!:

P1180960.jpg
 
I think monorails could serve a purpose, but in VERY dense population centers where it could serve as kind of an "in neighborhood" people mover between large centers of employment, entertainment, etc. The benefits being that smaller cars could run every 3-5 minutes and because they are more nimble, they would be better equipped to meander through dense development. They're like street cars but have the benefit of not being confined to the streets and the traffic, lights, etc. that come with that.

Just what I was thinking, in a major downtown to supplement the existing subway and bus system. And even enter the buildings themselves.
 
Just what I was thinking, in a major downtown to supplement the existing subway and bus system. And even enter the buildings themselves.

I could see it working in an area like downtown and/or Midtown Manhattan. A place where subway stops may not be frequent enough and streetcars/buses are less practical because of the traffic on the streets. I could see such a system connecting the WTC complex to Battery Park to Wall Street to various other high concentration centers.
 
As far as airport monorails go, just for the record and because i was there last week here's the texas dfw airport version.
It's fine for the terminals, but it really needs to go out to the car rental sector!:
P1180960.jpg

DFW Airport's is an elevated, automatic bus. It is not a monorail.
2707323915_8757a6ea2b.jpg


Neither were the photos I posted earlier, they were all light rail or heavy rail transit systems.

Most people post photos of monorails at remote locations, with no signs of the huge train stations 30 feet up in the air. That's where they become ugly.
At Harrah's
HarrahsStation040710A-buiter.jpg


At Sahara's
las-vegas-monorail7.jpg


Try squeezing the Sahara Station above a 4 lane city street in most central business districts in America. You would have to tear down at least one skyscraper on one side of the street to install a train station.

Here's how they did it in downtown Seattle.

045thave-pinestnw.jpg


How do you get to the platform so you can get on the train?
How would you like having the train 3 feet outside your office window?
The only reason the Seattle train station isn't as large as Las Vegas stations is because they don't have automatic operations and don't need glass doors at the boarding locations to prevent running over passengers. Seattle monorails acutally have human drivers/operators that can slam on the brakes.
 
Last edited:
This is more train station design as opposed to a monorail specific flaw. My guess is that the station could be as simple or complex, as beautiful or as monstrous as stations for steel-wheel trains.
 
Thats partly because the Monorail doesn't go from Downtown to the Strip to the Airport. It just goes from casino to casino.

It's because the distance it took to walk to and from the monorail was significant enough that it made more sense to walk between casino's rather than take the horribly inefficient monorail. . .

. . .
 
Last edited:
I was looking forward to riding the Vegas monorail just for fun. First I balked at the price tag. Then I realized that to get anywhere useful I'd have to walk the length of two casino floors and a good couple of miles of shops and hallways.

Seems great for convention goers, but that seems like a very specific niche.
 
I could see it working in an area like downtown and/or Midtown Manhattan. A place where subway stops may not be frequent enough and streetcars/buses are less practical because of the traffic on the streets. I could see such a system connecting the WTC complex to Battery Park to Wall Street to various other high concentration centers.
I vote for cable cars... They could also cross both rivers much more cheaply than any kind of rail.
 


Back
Top