Mobile Development Thread

Very good discussion and ideas about the architecture in the downtown area. Elb401 and buckett made some good points about the diversity of styles. This diversity adds to the texture of a downtown area. If we kept building everything in the same style of the original buildings of Mobile, would architecture ever advance?

So it is good to reflect back on the old and pay homage to it even if it may seem to be a knock-off. Every so often, a totally new style will emerge that has its roots in the older styles. In most instances, the architectural styles that are cherished today were not fully embraced in their time when they were new. As mentioned about the styles of the 60's and 70's, which tended to be bland and sterile, as long as the newer buildings put more emphasis on the details of the architecture that gives the building character, I think we will be alright.
 
WEMO : When I first read the new plans I believe that the city had an Atlantic Stataion type of development around the North of downtown.

buckett: This guy is one of the best when it comes to architecture.

Van Antwerp: Im very upset with the city about that building .The building is also the first skyscraper in the southeast.They should have tooken better care of that building than that. It would be sad to see history lost like that.


Alabama Motor Sports Park: I was reading in the PR the other day about the track so I assume that it is still in the running.Does anybody know of anything ??

There is nothing wrong with having new architecture in a historic setting as long as it complimints the area.
It seems that the Van Antwerp Blldg. isn't really in danger of collapsing, but can be a hazard obviously. It seems that it was just some brick or detail work that fell. Again, enough to race a safety concern, but not enough to cause the building to collapse. The owner is stressing to the city to help with renovating the building.

http://www.local15tv.com/news/local...f-History/ZGJi7x5ey0OUv_dQhEHaNQ.cspx?rss=217
 
Faux Architecture doesn't age well and in 10-20 years looks very cartoonish. The old Spanish Style is cherished so much because it is original and rare to both New Orleans and Mobile. To go around and recreate these old styles is a slap in the face to the ingenuity of Mobilan's to actually develop an identity for their historic core. Those "historic" styles were at one time cutting edge and in vogue. Copying historic architecture devalues the original buildings and recreates a faux place to be, then actually spending time developing new ideas of what architecture could be in mobile.

For example, the two new hotels in downtown Mobile look terrible IMO. Rather then just admit they are a new structure, and be designed that way, the developer pretended to mimic the styles of the old in a contemporary way, and cover it with stucco... Mobile could have done so much better.

To sum it up, buildings can no longer be constructed in the old historic styles for cost and craft reasons and will always look fake. If you want to see a perfect example of why not, please visit Perkins Rowe in Baton Rouge and you will get the picture.:)

How about a combination of the architectural elements of a Florida cracker home & and an Alabama redneck cabin? :haha:
 
The Van Antwerp Building

It seems that the Van Antwerp Blldg. isn't really in danger of collapsing, but can be a hazard obviously. It seems that it was just some brick or detail work that fell. Again, enough to race a safety concern, but not enough to cause the building to collapse. The owner is stressing to the city to help with renovating the building.

http://www.local15tv.com/news/local...f-History/ZGJi7x5ey0OUv_dQhEHaNQ.cspx?rss=217

I got a good look at the building tonight and you can see where the facade is peeling off. Not really a hazard to fall but you might want to walk briskly on the Royal Street sidewalk when it reopens.:) This building screams "help me". If I were the city I would come down on the owner to either renovate or sell it to someone who will renovate. I had not heard that the building owner wants the city to help....yea, we'll help you alright...fix this, fix that! I think the Van Antwerp has just moved to the front burner of our downtown revitalization and that is very good news.
 
Yesterday's Press-Register

Auburn graduate students try to help downtown Mobile with green projects

MOBILE, Ala. -- An open-air market next to Bienville Square. Walls of plants that hide vacant lots. Dauphin Street as a pedestrian-only promenade.

Those are among several so-called green projects that an Auburn graduate student class planned for downtown Mobile.

Landscape architecture professor Charlene LeBleu is now seeking funding to put some of the class project into practice.

"We're hoping that it's a revitalization of downtown, something that helps green the downtown and create a more pedestrian city," LeBleu said.

The 14 students focused on Mobile because of the ongoing downtown renovation, the high annual rainfall and its proximity to Mobile Bay.

"There are so many good things about Mobile that it just makes an excellent studio space," LeBleu said with a laugh.

LeBleu got a grant from the Mississippi-Alabama Sea Grant Consortium and received help from the Downtown Mobile Alliance, Envision Coastal Alabama and the Mobile Area Chamber of Commerce.

Green Downtown 2.JPGView full size(Courtesy Auburn University)Auburn graduate student Tyler Smithson envisions an outdoor market along Bienville Square that would¤also collect rainwater for the park's fountain.¤Smithson and other Auburn students designed projects to¤help retain stormwater and enhance the quality of life in the downtown area. The students were supposed to design projects that help retain stormwater and enhance the quality of life in the downtown area.

LeBleu and the students organized a meeting in August with downtown residents and business owners to brainstorm ideas and then spent the rest of the semester putting together their proposals.

LeBleu said she has a January meeting with the consortium to present the ideas and try to get funding to implement one of them as a demonstration site.

Among the ideas are:

• Erecting planted walls -- vertical soil plots with grass and other flora growing out of it -- in front of vacant lots on Dauphin Street.

• Retrofitting downtown roofs with cisterns to collect rainwater that the city workers can use to water plants and clean streets.

• Closing Dauphin Street to cars between Jackson and Conception streets and putting outdoor cafes and pocket parks in vacant lots.

• Building an outdoor market on St. Joseph Street next to Bienville Square that would also collect rainwater for the park's fountain.

• Planting lawns and gardens on the flat rooftops of downtown buildings.

Al Stokes, the city's chief of staff, said many of the students' proposals parallel ideas put forth in a downtown plan presented to city officials last year, although some of the details might have to be adjusted.

For example, he said, the city likes the idea of outdoor markets, but the students' proposed location on St. Joseph Street is already dedicated to becoming a bus station

http://blog.al.com/live/2009/12/auburn_graduate_students_try_t.html
 
I would approach a ped-only paseo with caution, especially since, while busy, the foot traffic isn't grand. I don't mind them trying it out say for Sunday or after certain times or something, just not a plunge into full time. Also, how many pocket parks do we really need? I would rather see those empty lots developed.

Between proposed zoning changes and a proposed car-free Dauphin St. (which sounds good in theory, but isn't always so great in practice), I'm a little worried about what some of these knuckle-heads are doing.

But I'm all for green roofs and storm water retention.
 
I would approach a ped-only paseo with caution, especially since, while busy, the foot traffic isn't grand. I don't mind them trying it out say for Sunday or after certain times or something, just not a plunge into full time.

Completely agree...while in theory it sounds like a very intriguing place but when you study how others have been created and executed they're not all that spectacular. Even Bourbon Street is pedestrian only at night!
 
I got a good look at the building tonight and you can see where the facade is peeling off. Not really a hazard to fall but you might want to walk briskly on the Royal Street sidewalk when it reopens.:) This building screams "help me". If I were the city I would come down on the owner to either renovate or sell it to someone who will renovate. I had not heard that the building owner wants the city to help....yea, we'll help you alright...fix this, fix that! I think the Van Antwerp has just moved to the front burner of our downtown revitalization and that is very good news.
Yes, ironically good news, because the situation put it in the spotlight:)
 
About the Van Antwerp building situation, something BETTER be done FAST! It's such an important piece of Mobile's architectural history. :whip:

As for the Auburn University's landscape architecture class's proposal to create vertical soil plots, that's not really a practical endeavor. That sounds costly and requires too much maintenance for a public location. Trellises with vines are much cheaper and easier to maintain and will do the job beautifully if the right vines are selected and there are many vines to use that will thrive in Mobile's high-rainfall, humid subtropical climate. Besides, walling off a vacant lot doesn't exactly sound attractive. Trellises, if spaced apart, could provide enough screening to distract from the empty lot without being forbidding.

(edit)
Oh, I didn't see the picture. Well, that does look good, but the above idea is something to consider if the funding is limited.
 
Last edited:
The Green Wall Facade used to conceal vacant lots or to create an entrance to a pocket park made for a compelling rendering. The Green wall idea is great, but I don't believe that is the best application.

Pocket Parks are usually only successful in areas with high density and a lot of foot traffic. Mobile can't even activate their current two downtown parks so I doubt adding more parks is a practical solution. Another issue is that without lots of pedestrian traffic, the pockets become concealed places for vandalism to easily take place.

I also find it ironic that Auburn chose the use the French Market in New Orleans as a photomontage example of what a market could look like in mobile. I felt it was ironic because of the "jealousy and distaste" often said within this thread about New Orleans. Auburn students are unaware of this rivalry when creating their rendering using the French Market and was an interesting composition, not because of the poor photoshopping, but because of the juxtaposition of opinions.
 
The Green Wall Facade used to conceal vacant lots or to create an entrance to a pocket park made for a compelling rendering. The Green wall idea is great, but I don't believe that is the best application.

Pocket Parks are usually only successful in areas with high density and a lot of foot traffic. Mobile can't even activate their current two downtown parks so I doubt adding more parks is a practical solution. Another issue is that without lots of pedestrian traffic, the pockets become concealed places for vandalism to easily take place.

I also find it ironic that Auburn chose the use the French Market in New Orleans as a photomontage example of what a market could look like in mobile. I felt it was ironic because of the "jealousy and distaste" often said within this thread about New Orleans. Auburn students are unaware of this rivalry when creating their rendering using the French Market and was an interesting composition, not because of the poor photoshopping, but because of the juxtaposition of opinions.



Mobilians could really care less about a comparison to New Orleans.. IMO.. Most Mobilians have went with the approach, we were here before so make the best of it and forget about the neighbor that is next door. N.O. is a cool place, but it is N.O. in really, it stinks down there and it is very nasty and I do not want my home town to be that way.. Nashville, Atlanta and even Philly are much cleaner than N.O. so try to be your own. Do not mean to rain down on what your are saying, but I want Mobile to stand out better than New Orleans. I would like Mobile to attract a different crowd that would mesh well.
 
Mobilians could really care less about a comparison to New Orleans.. IMO.. Most Mobilians have went with the approach, we were here before so make the best of it and forget about the neighbor that is next door. N.O. is a cool place, but it is N.O. in really, it stinks down there and it is very nasty and I do not want my home town to be that way.. Nashville, Atlanta and even Philly are much cleaner than N.O. so try to be your own. Do not mean to rain down on what your are saying, but I want Mobile to stand out better than New Orleans. I would like Mobile to attract a different crowd that would mesh well.

Tim,

Thank you for proving my point ;)

"N.O. is a cool place, but it is N.O. in really, it stinks down there and it is very nasty and I do not want my home town to be that way"
 
Tim, ?????????
Thank you for proving my point ;)

"N.O. is a cool place, but it is N.O. in really, it stinks down there and it is very nasty and I do not want my home town to be that way"

I said that I like the idea, but for the most part they should think of another way to better assist pedestrians in that area with a design that is better looking.
 
From Smart Coast

Parents and children continue to enjoy the monthly walks to school at three schools in Fairhope.
If you would like to introduce Smart Walks in your childs school, contact Smart Coast for a presentation to school officials or parents organizations.

The National Center for Bicycling and Walking came to the coastal region in October and made presentations about the benefits of Complete Streets to local elected officials and planners. After their site visit, The City of Fairhope took the initiative to adopt the first Complete streets policy in Alabama. Within two weeks, the City of Daphne adopted a similar policy and also committed to adding it to their comprehensive plan and codes.

In November, the City of Chickasaw became the first City in Mobile County to adopt the policy and adding it to their comprehensive plan.

Congratulations to these cities who decided to consider all their citizens as they build and redesign streets in their city.


I guess Mobile wasn't interested.
 
I have a few midtown,downtown, and Conde pics that will be posting soon.


I passed by the Kress building Saturday and I noticed that there are interior renovations going on that building. Does anyone know what will be in the building ? I hope retail !



I read an article on this forum a couple of years ago about Mobile being Walt Disney`s first choice before Orlando. Does anyone have that Link and I forgot the forumer who posted that link ?
 
Cathedral Basilica of the immaculate Conception downtown Mobile.

Cathedral Basilica

4243614225


Ceiling of the Basilica

photostream


Pulpit of the Basilica

photostream


photostream


photostream


Organ

photostream


photostream



I never knew that there was an underground mausoleum that held all of the Archdiocese in the Basilica.

photostream


photostream




More downtown and midtown pics will be coming soon !!!!!
 


Back
Top