nouveau_Mauvilla
amateur urbanite
Yeah, British Park is a cool little jem.
A few observations of mine. Sure, I think they should redevelop the Civic Center parking lot as a mixed-use kinda thing. But look at the pic. 3-4 stories, fine whatever. At grade parking enclosed behind the units, not great but I guess ok. But hold on, what's with the faux-historical pitched roof ye old condos look? C'mon we can do better than that. Also, this "mixed use" looks like the condos (or apts) and then disconnected 1 maybe 2 story shops at the bottom of the pic. That isn't exactly "mixed use." And don't even get me started on all those roads and intersections running directly through the whole thing completely cutting the two halves off.
Also, rezoning? What? That could be disastrous, and they just causaly mention it. :koko:
Your thoughts?
"...the city is now mired in a deep financial slump."
I was under the impression that Mobile was faring better than most cities ?
It probably is, but it would be nearly impossible for any city to not be in a financial slump right now.
As for the mixed use architecture, I would like to see the historic New Orleans and Mobile architecture. You know, the ones that you see with the second story balconies and porches on each building. A lot of the downtown buildings in Tuscaloosa have embraced this and some are even adding them to the buildings.
Faux Architecture doesn't age well and in 10-20 years looks very cartoonish. The old Spanish Style is cherished so much because it is original and rare to both New Orleans and Mobile. To go around and recreate these old styles is a slap in the face to the ingenuity of Mobilan's to actually develop an identity for their historic core. Those "historic" styles were at one time cutting edge and in vogue. Copying historic architecture devalues the original buildings and recreates a faux place to be, then actually spending time developing new ideas of what architecture could be in mobile.
For example, the two new hotels in downtown Mobile look terrible IMO. Rather then just admit they are a new structure, and be designed that way, the developer pretended to mimic the styles of the old in a contemporary way, and cover it with stucco... Mobile could have done so much better.
To sum it up, buildings can no longer be constructed in the old historic styles for cost and craft reasons and will always look fake. If you want to see a perfect example of why not, please visit Perkins Rowe in Baton Rouge and you will get the picture.![]()
The old architecture was "cutting edge" when it was new, because, well, it was new, just like any kind of architecture from any era. The point being is that because something is new in style doesn't make it better, look at the 60's and 70's for example:haha: :yuck: So it's not the age that matters, it is the style, because things are going to age no matter what, again, look at the 60's and 70's for example:haha: :yuck: So why not build a style that looks good, and fits, as long as it can be done right ? After all, you won't please everyone, no matter what, because some will bash any new style because "it doesn't fit", and others will bash a traditional style because, "it is phoney, just mimicing the "real" style, or it's "non progressive". In short, just rebuild Mobile back in the original style, a style that looks good, and a style that fits, and just be done with it.
Faux Architecture doesn't age well and in 10-20 years looks very cartoonish. The old Spanish Style is cherished so much because it is original and rare to both New Orleans and Mobile. To go around and recreate these old styles is a slap in the face to the ingenuity of Mobilan's to actually develop an identity for their historic core. Those "historic" styles were at one time cutting edge and in vogue. Copying historic architecture devalues the original buildings and recreates a faux place to be, then actually spending time developing new ideas of what architecture could be in mobile.
For example, the two new hotels in downtown Mobile look terrible IMO. Rather then just admit they are a new structure, and be designed that way, the developer pretended to mimic the styles of the old in a contemporary way, and cover it with stucco... Mobile could have done so much better.
To sum it up, buildings can no longer be constructed in the old historic styles for cost and craft reasons and will always look fake. If you want to see a perfect example of why not, please visit Perkins Rowe in Baton Rouge and you will get the picture.![]()
Well thats what I think, but I drink the Andreas Duany Kool-Aid everyday I go to work.
I just read this on my homepage and came here to see if somebody already posted it. It would be a massive shame to lose this highrise. Maybe when some engineers look at it the report might show that some detail work just fell and that some are over reacting to how bad the shape of the building is.Streets around Van Antwerp Building closed; 'building not safe right now,' says police spokesman
http://blog.al.com/live/2009/12/streets_around_van_antwerp_bui.html
While details are sketchy, police spokesman officer Ron Wallace said there appears there may be questions about the building's structural integrity.
"The building is not safe right now," said Wallace.
The Van Antwerp is Mobile's first skyscraper, built at Dauphin and Royal St. circa 1907.