PR article on the parking shortage/issues downtown from the parking study done by the downtown alliance. If you read the study nothing new, but for those who haven't, here ya go.
Report: Parking shortage possible
Study, citing lack of supervision over enforcement, calls for centralized management Monday, July 23, 2007By JEFF AMYStaff Reporter
A new report on downtown parking in Mobile warns that parts of the city core near the RSA Tower and Riverview Plaza may soon face a parking shortage.
It also says the city has a bad deal with Central Parking Corp. and needs centralized management to replace a system in which no one's in charge.
The report was commissioned by the Downtown Mobile Alliance, a group that promotes downtown and will be discussed at a public meeting at 8:30 a.m. Tuesday at the alliance offices at 261 Dauphin St.
It comes just before the city's contract with Central Parking, based in Nashville, Tenn., expires, and is likely to stir up one of the city's most politically sensitive subjects -- how heavy-handed downtown parking enforcement should be.
That question flamed into a near-revolt in 2003, when Central Parking briefly handled ticket-writing, and brought howls from downtown business owners because the company's yellow-jacketed "parking diplomats" were handing out nearly 100 tickets every weekday.
Then-Mayor Mike Dow reacted by hiring retired police officers to write tickets, and giving them unofficial marching orders to not work as hard as the diplomats.
But it turns out that no one's really in charge of the officers.
"It appears the enforcement personnel operate with very little internal policy direction or supervision; and the Central Parking local manager made it clear that he has absolutely no authority over the enforcement personnel," the consultants wrote. "Police representatives also stated that they had little if any authority over enforcement personnel."
That means that the officers have been allowed to manage themselves. The consultants found that they've responded by focusing on writing expensive tickets for parking in handicapped and other illegal zones, not regular parking tickets.
"What this translates to on the ground is a situation we have defined as 'convenient enforcement,'" the report states. "There are no foot patrols; metered areas get second priority; free parking areas get last priority; enforcement personnel zero in on low effort/high cost violations."
Mobile police Chief Phillip Garrett said he hopes to take the ticket writers fully into the Police Department once Central Parking's contract expires in September.
"Who's their boss?" he asked. "That's been an issue that's plagued us since I've been chief."
Elizabeth Sanders, executive director of the Downtown Mobile Alliance, also wants a reform. She said parking needs to be structured to promote downtown shopping, living and work.
"Nobody comes downtown to park," Sanders said. "Parking is a piece of the infrastructure that supports other reasons why people come downtown."
The report supports her call for a manager and suggests that the city either create an in-house parking chief, a parking authority or hire the alliance to run both on-street and off-street parking.
"There's got to be consistent management," said Steve Gibson, the California consultant who helped prepare the report.
The report also says that because of how the city renegotiated its deal with Central Parking after the diplomat fiasco, the city's revenue is declining while the company's is increasing.
"We believe the on-street contract as currently structured is not in the best interest of the city or downtown," the report states. "Since the contract amendment in 2005, Central Parking is effectively getting paid more to do less."
David Buchanan, Central Parking's local manager, declined to comment on the report.
The consultants said Central Parking's off-street lots are mainly used by office workers and said new signs and physical improvements might make them a more attractive part of an overall parking system.
"Consideration should be given to the establishment of (zoning) requirements that will force grandfathered, non-conforming lots to be improved over time with the proper paving, screening and landscaping," the report states.
The study also said some areas around the RSA Tower and Riverview Plaza may soon be short of parking. Gibson said it can take five years to build a parking garage, so the city should study the situation now, before problems develop.
During the 2003 dispute, Sanders called for the city to pull up all of its 500-plus parking meters. When asked if she still favored that move, she said the alliance has yet to reach any conclusions. However, she said, free parking would be "attractive" to customers and said that at the very least, enforcement should be quite lenient.
"You never want a consumer worried about time," Sanders said. "The minute they start worrying about time, they stop spending money."
But without enforcement, spaces will be clogged up all day, warn the consultants. The study found that 27 percent of vehicles in the Dauphin Street free parking area were in the same spot all day, and 43 percent for four or more hours. A Central Parking analysis in 2006 found 69 percent of vehicles parked for more than four hours.
"If dedicated and sustained enforcement of free parking areas is not maintained, then the removal of parking meters could backfire and have a detrimental effect on downtown."
Gibson said that in places with relatively weak downtowns, parking tends to be a "scapegoat," with customers using it as a reason not to shop there, and merchants blaming the cost of parking for their problems.