I hope they do not let this gas station happen. They are dropping a small fortune on redeveloping that area and this would not contribute a thing to the neighborhood. I also didn't realize that the "Bring Back Broad" deal was only south of Goverment. That is the portion of Broad I NEVER drive. I guess I will have an excuse to go that way. I wish they could also do the more visible portion of broad from Goverment north. Maybe someday.
Gasoline station fueling dispute
Saturday, July 14, 2007By JEFF AMYStaff Reporter
People who may be trying to build a gas station on Broad Street, south of downtown, appear to be in a footrace against efforts to expand the boundaries of the Oakleigh Garden Historic District.
Most of the lot is outside the existing city-protected Oakleigh boundary, and developers are seeking approval from the Mobile Planning Commission on Thursday to divide out a small portion that city officials said is inside the district.
But the Mobile City Council could vote Wednesday to approve an expansion of the Oakleigh district that would take in all the property at Broad and Elmira, as well as a much broader swath of land, mainly along Broad and Texas streets. That expansion has been under discussion for months.
Marvin Hewitt Enterprises of Lawrenceville, Ga., had announced plans to build a convenience store at Broad and Elmira last year, but put those plans on the shelf after widespread neighborhood opposition.
Justin Smith, a real estate broker with Saad & Vallas Realty Group, who represents the company's other six Mobile County sites, now
refuses to say who his client is on Broad Street or what the client's intended use is.
"The customer has asked me not to make any comments about it," Smith said.
Neighbors and City Councilman William Carroll, though, believe that a gas station is still the intended use.
"We are opposing the gas station being put on the corner," said Stony Chavers, the president of the Oakleigh Garden District Society, a neighborhood association.
The land in question is zoned for commercial use, and outside a city-protected historic district, a property owner could build a wide range of structures.
Inside the district, a property owner would have to get approval from the Architectural Review Board, which regulates the exterior appearance of structures in an effort to maintain the historic nature of the areas.
The council's vote could void any effort to escape architectural review. City Council attorney Jim Rossler said it was his opinion that the property would come under historic regulation, although the proposed ordinance wouldn't formally take effect until after it was advertised.
Carroll, who lives nearby on Broad, said that the Wednesday vote was not scheduled as an effort to hamper the development proposal.
"It is purely coincidental," he said. "I had no idea."
There's been little organized opposition to the Oakleigh expansion. Residents at an April public hearing were cautious, mainly asking questions.
It's not clear that the review board would block the plans or require them to be significantly altered. Though some neighbors would like for the land to become residential, the board can't regulate use.
Earlier this year, the board approved plans for another gas station, owned by Marvin Hewitt Enterprises, near the corner of Spring Hill Avenue and Catherine Street. Several years ago, the review board approved plans for a gas station complex at Five Points, on the southeast corner of Spring Hill Avenue and Ann Street.
Both the Spring Hill Avenue sites are in the Old Dauphinway Historic District. That neighborhood's association did not oppose the development that was approved earlier this year, and only a few neighbors fought those recent plans.
The Oakleigh site could be different, though. Broad Street corridor is also the focus of a federally funded improvement plan, called Bring Back Broad.
Right now, planners want to spend $2 million to narrow Broad south of Government Street and install landscaping, new lights and better sidewalks, in an effort to make it more attractive.
Palmer Hamilton, a lawyer who has helped renovate a number of houses in Oakleigh, was a key player in getting the federal money.
"I cannot tell you how depressed I would be after all the effort on Bring Back Broad to have this happen," Hamilton said. "Putting a gas station that probably wants to sell cheap alcohol is not going to improve the quality of life."
Chavers said that many longtime Oakleigh residents had trouble with a convenience store on Government Street and fear that it will attract crime.