Well to clarify, smaller 6-20 floor buildings with appropriate setbacks and streetfront retail are much more human-scaled. Quite honestly, I compare Midtown Atlanta and Brickell a lot - both are elongated, both have replaced adjacent downtowns as premier office submarkets, and both have seen a considerable amount of residential construction over the past 20 years, Miami that much more. While I detest the overall architecture of the resi buildings in Midtown Atlanta and the podium or standalone garages there, I think Midtown Atlanta has promoted a much more pedestrian friendly environment with a better mix of uses and overall better "design" (not better architecture on the resi front). Nothing is larger than life - it's all pretty human-scaled there. I feel like the neighborhood is legitimate, and I never get the sense that anything about Miami is legitimate in anyway whatsoever.
It is my opinion that Genting's proposals, that Miami World, perhaps even Brickell City Centre are just too immense. They are not human-scaled. The podiums I have seen for many of these large-scale master-planned projects are scary large, hulking structures. It's hard for anyone to care one bit about what goes on on the sidewalks in Miami's CBD when the towers are all so tall and there's nothing bringing people down to street level, when the retail is in a way closed in on itself as in many of the proposals, when the podium is its own universe that shuts out the outside world, when every project is designed only to appeal to rich Latins and Europeans and not necessarily the typical "young professional", Creative Class member, working class, or even visitors.
The reason I feel a connection to San Francisco, for instance, is that I feel like "we're all in it together", meaning the homeless, the billionaires, the young professionals, the artists, the construction workers, etc. Everyone is forced to encounter everyone else and we're all better for it. When I go to Miami, the sense I get is that the DT/Brickell/waterfront areas try their best to isolate themselves from anyone who isn't someone who can afford some overpriced high rise condo or waterfront mansion. Mary Brickell Village has some higher priced chains, and all of the hotels exude luxury, all of the shopping east of 95 screams Visa Black cardholders, the middle class seems forgotten and relegated to west of 95 (it's no wonder the whole Sofla market plays keeping up with the Jones).
NYC scares me now how uniformly wealthy it is, but at the same time it's stil bustling with all walks of life, there's still a good "dose of reality" left on every corner and in every submarket (window air conditioners in rich peoples' 1920s coops for instance), grunge and city smells here and there, and of course a diverse and wide range of jobs for just about everyone (there aren't that many "jobs" in Miami's CBD like most cities' CBDs...it's mostly luxury high-priced residential, which just weirds me out).
And then the question I always have is: what the hell is the economic driver besides flight money, trade, real estate (tied to flight money) and tourism? The question of the century that I've heard countless people ask.