MIAMI
Miami commission will seal Vizcaya skyline's fate
Vizcaya supporters have battled a high-rise condo proposal that would change the gardens' view. City commissioners vote on the issue today.
BY MICHAEL VASQUEZ
[email protected]
One of South Florida's most influential developers will go head-to-head today with Miami's only National Historic Landmark, Vizcaya Museum and Gardens.
The outcome of that battle, to be decided by a final vote of Miami city commissioners, could forever alter the view from Vizcaya, which draws roughly 185,000 visitors annually and is a popular location for wedding parties and quinceañera photo shoots.
Less than 2,000 feet away from Vizcaya's famed gardens, Jorge Perez's Related Group development company wants to build three luxury condo towers. Miami city commissioners in January tentatively approved the condo proposal by a 3-2 vote, despite objections from District 2 Commissioner Marc Sarnoff, who represents the area and calls the project outsized.
''I expect each of my commissioners to respect what the District 2 Commissioner has to say in his neighborhood,'' Sarnoff said Monday.
Related Group executive Bill Thompson, meanwhile, has tried to reassure the public that the condos' impact on Vizcaya would be minimal.
In recent days, the company has offered to significantly reduce the height of its condos to try to appease the museum. Until now, the tallest tower was set to be 410 feet. Now all three towers would be roughly 318 feet tall. The number of units -- previously chopped from 1000 to 300 -- would fall further to 270.
But the height reductions have not swayed opponents.
The developer also promised to add trees to the museum land that would screen some -- but not all -- of its project, known as 300 Grove Bay Residences.
''Over time things change, and the old blends with the new,'' Thompson said. ``We are trying to make our best effort to blend the new with Vizcaya.''
Museum visitors would still see the towers, but Thompson notes that tall buildings are part of life in the big city. An example: New York City's leafy Central Park, surrounded on all sides by skyscrapers.
One Vizcaya backer, landscape architect Laurie Olin, wrote in a letter to the museum that comparing the museum to Central Park is ``a foolish and ignorant statement.''
Olin, who co-authored the 2006 book Vizcaya, An American Villa and its Makers, wrote that Vizcaya was not built to be a public park, but rather a private ``tropical refuge.''
''Vizcaya now provides visitors an opportunity to transport themselves back in time and to another place,'' said Vizcaya Executive Director Joel Hoffman. Stick condos smack in the middle of Vizcaya's views, he said, and those time-travel days are over.
A recent study by Miami-Dade County, which owns the museum, also criticized the proposed condos. County leaders are expected to visit City Hall today to oppose the development.