Ideal density for cities


RWin

of Canada
What would be the ideal density for our cities? Is there a such thing as overcrowding (to much density)? I'm pretty sure we all agree that you can have too little.

What percentage should be single family houses? How big should they be? When all the infill is used up is it okay to build at the edge of the city?

What about row houses? Duplexes? Should single family houses be replaced by this?

Should employment be somewhat central? Or are multiple business centres better?
 
My ideal residential density would be Montreal's three-floor rowhouses. It's familiar to me, given the typically St. John's rowhouse neighbourhoods here, but it's also meatier and more urban.

My ideal commercial density would be a large city's downtown core - I'm leaning, again, toward Montreal. Or Boston. I definitely need an old street grid. I could never love NYC, for example, the way I love Boston. The grid street pattern just... drains my enjoyment of a city. It feels so sanitized, so... Anywhere. I know all cities have it to some degree, but I prefer those that do their best not to - like Boston.

My ideal transition from urban to suburban to rural is probably London, in realistic terms, or Sarajevo, in ideal terms. The latter fades from the old town core, through the modern downtown, into residential highrise neighbourhoods, and finally (and VERY quickly) to rural farmsteads. Dubrovnik is another great example. It's dense and urban within its city walls, and almost instantly suburban outside them (and that quickly fades into more spread-out, rural homes).

I like mostly urban, a little suburban for the wealthiest families who can afford it (not in the North American sense of passing the cost of maintaining this shit on to future generations either), and then rural.

St. John's was very much like this until the 1950s-60s. We started copying the North American style outside of Empire Avenue. And now we have sprawl for days. But up until that point, St. John's was a city that ended on a sharp line. The rowhouses stopped, and then it was farmland.
 
I don't think there's such a thing as one ideal density. Different people value different things and they should be able to choose housing that best suits their lifestyle, provided that they are paying for the real social cost of that choice.

That being said, I've always thought that a lot of neighbourhoods in Canada no longer work properly because they have slowly lost population due to declining household sizes and NIMBY development policies. An average neighbourhood of detached houses in Canada can't really support a good mix of local amenities like shops, schools kids can easily walk to, etc. Some neighbourhoods have avoided this fate, but most have just become suburbs where residents mostly get around by driving.

Montreal's inner neighbourhoods seem like an exception to this. A lot of them haven't seen much modern infill but they were dense enough to begin with that they have aged pretty well. Toronto and Vancouver also have some areas of detached housing that are in such high demand that many new housing units have been added in existing buildings (this is not allowed in some neighbourhoods though). Many smaller cities on the other hand don't have any urban neighbourhoods at all, or they just have a small pocket of urban housing in their downtown area. The worst cities are just a 70's-style CBD surrounded by suburbs.
 
My ideal density :

idealdensity.jpg
 
Last edited:
For me the ideal density would be a level that could support enough quality transit so as everyone is within 10 minutes walk to a station, no matter where you live. I would include true BRT and traffic segregated LRT, as well as of course a metro line. I think if Vancity population hits 1 million, this could be achieved.

Another somewhat recent advantage realized through density is car sharing. As long as you have good transit, car sharing is a viable alternative to owning a vehicle, probly taking more cars off the road and getting people out walking more often.
 
A mixture of everything. Some sections extreme density (i.e. Hong Kong or Manhattan) with quiet park sections (i.e. Rosedale).
 
A mixture is good. But I think Toronto's inner city is an excellent example of the perfect density that does not scare away families.

Toronto's inner city is considered the second densest between Canada and the USA. Yet it still allows the majority of families to live in single or semi-detached homes, with small yards.

I believe this is one of the reasons that families never really fled the inner city. People can still have their house, but also walk places and have good transit.
And of course there are apartments, condos, etc mixed in.

In contrast, when talking with a planner in Montreal. She was telling me that while the duplex housing is cool, they have a hard time keeping families with kids in inner Montreal. Families keep moving further and further out, because they want a house, and not a duplex.
So it is an interesting thing to consider.
 
Yes indeed, hence you also have to consider that the region of Montreal is an archipelago.

My point is that our ''borders'' are stronger or much well know,then you exactly know when you get it or get out of Montreal.

So,it looks harder to keep peoples ON the island because, suddently the houses prices are different compared to the other shore (Ex. laval)

Meanwhile in Toronto, ( at least to me ), their suburbs, looks like to come in a full one big ''package''... and the difference seems to never drop that much.
 
A good portion of Montreal Island is suburban (post 1950s neighbourhoods). I always wondered why someone leaving Kirkland for, say old Longueuil, not far from the Metro, was treated the same way as someone moving from the Plateau to Blainville.
 
I agree with Mike - I really appreciate Toronto's level of density in the city directly surrounding downtown (inner city I guess?). It's very green and with yards that accommodate families, yet most of the houses are still multi-unit. Main streets with a solid streewall of retail are are always nearby. I know several people who live in an apartment in a house where there is a family in the main unit. I live in a 3 story detached house with 2 apartments housing 7 people - some houses on my street are similar and others are single family. It's interesting.

Most of my coworkers with kids actually decided to stay in the inner city as well and never want to move to the suburbs. And these are professionals who make a fair amount of money - their houses are expensive and they could buy something much larger further out. I like that.
 
this family-retention thing is unfortunate. i don't enjoy single-family housing in the city, except maybe a few hilly mansion districts like rosedale or westmount.

i prefer a four-to-five-storey streetwall. the plateau is a bit airy, but it's the best that canada has to offer.
 
I guess one could say most of inner Toronto is "streetcar suburban". But it just works.

And it is getting denser with the new condos, etc.

While talking about density, I would also like to point out that Toronto's inner suburbs (built under the Metro government) also have pretty good density. My house in Scarborough is on a big lot, etc. However with the mixing of single family, townhomes, condos, and apartments. My area has a density of 12,000-14,000 people per sq mile. That is actually approaching inner city level densities for some cities.

Toronto both in the inner city and inner suburbs has done a great job of giving people all kinds of housing choices, while at the same time providing the density to support quality public transit, while not being overbearing.

My street
3599635000_449e0144df_z.jpg


At the end of my street is this.
3598792491_650251be46_b.jpg
 
Downtown density of 1-5 sq km at 30,000+/sq km

Parisian density in the core (~20,000/sq km)

691px-Blv-haussmann-lafayette.jpg


Brooklyn density in first suburbs (~14,000/sq km)

block-of-brownstone-residences-in-park-slope-brooklyn.jpg


Toronto density in second suburbs (~7,000/sq km)

800px-Toronto_Row_Houses.jpg



Anything above 25,000/sq km really becomes difficult to maintain. We lose the economic advantage of density and run into tons of infrastructure problems. I also tend to believe that 25,000+ densities are harder for Westerners to adjust to.
 


Back
Top