Hydrogen Highway


Nutterbug

New member
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/british-columbia/story/2004/03/31/bc_hydrogen20040331.html

'Hydrogen highway' touted by premier
Last Updated: Wednesday, March 31, 2004 | 7:56 PM PT
CBC News

Premier Gordon Campbell has announced plans for a series of hydrogen-fuelling stations between Vancouver, Victoria and Whistler.

Speaking at the Globe conference on business and the environment, Campbell said it's part of a plan to make the 2010 Winter Olympics the most sustainable games in history.

"You could arrive at the Vancouver airport, you could be transferred to a hydrogen-driven bus that would take you up to Whistler.

"You could be re-fuelled in Whistler and come back and there would be absolutely no impact on the environment whatsoever," says the premier.

Another report suggests the hydrogen highway could even stretch all the way to Los Angeles by the 2010 Games.

Campbell says he wants to use the Olympics to promote hydrogen energy. And he has called on other countries hosting international events to follow suit.

"If we take that critical mass of global events that bring people together, and show them the new uses of this new energy source in transportation and moving people around, I think we may find the critical mass of activity that breaks that technology through."

Campbell also says there are plans to build an environmentally-sustainable Olympic athletes village.

Just wondering, how practically useful and effective to combatting pollution is it to run buses on hydrogen? Where is the energy used to produce the hydrogen (presumably from water molecules) obtained from?

Is it just a way to score political PR points?
 
it's a we have to look like we're doing something kind of program

It's probably cheap though, so it could be worse
 
I'm no expert on hydrogen fuel but I think it requires electricity and water. The electricity takes the water and processes the hydrogen out and then the hydrogen is used by the car. I dont remember how the car processes hydrogen, but I think it's zero emissions and water is a byproduct or something. Whoever suggested this must concider hydrogen a realistic replacement for gas in terms of mass consumption. I think if people, such as myself, understood how it works better, there would be stronger support.
 
They won't get hydrogen from electrolysis of water. They'll reform methane or methanol.
 
Unless you are using green electricity this is just as bad as having the cars run on oil. Still as more green power comes on line there is the potential for this to be ok.
 
This is just a dumb idea--hello electric car? Why do we need some kind of fuel at all. Building an entirely new infrastructure just seems like a waste to me.
 
You need lots of renewable green power to do the mass electrolysis of water to get the hydrogen. If you must burn Fossil Fuels to get the electricity required, all you are doing is transferring the pollution from the cities to the power plants. The amount that goes into the atmosphere is still the same.

Hydrogen powered cars only make sense in places where the vast majority of power production is green.
 
True about power plants. But that pollution can be better controlled at relatively few exit points (as new pollution/legislation comes into effect) in comparison to the millions of collective exit points known as the Vehicular Exhaust Pipe.
 
^grat point...
^^BC, the place where its being planed has something like 80% of its electricty coming from hydro power aka green power.

*But yes everyone is right that unless the power used to create the hydrogen is coming from green/renewabel energy than there is no short term benefit to curbing polution. Also there is the whole danger of excess hydrogen being expelled in to the atmosphere(by accident), though I beleive that studies have shown that the negative effects of this would be minimal.
Also fuel cell technology is not there yet and more work/research is needed, though most experts say that by 2020 it should take off.
In the end though oil canot be clean but only cleaner, though hydrogen can be 100% clean but doesnt have to be 100% clean.

*** Someone mentioned electric cars, well a fuel cell car is in a way a electric car but instead of storing its energy in a inefficient battery it stores it in hydrogen and in the end the original energy for both cars comes from the same power source...the power plant. Electric cars are nice in theory but to date we have not produced a battery capabel of storing energy as efficently as other natural meethods such as fossil fuels/hydrogen etc.
also im not all there right now sos sorry if im hard to understand
 
Last edited:
True about power plants. But that pollution can be better controlled at relatively few exit points (as new pollution/legislation comes into effect) in comparison to the millions of collective exit points known as the Vehicular Exhaust Pipe.

Yea, but unless you sequester ALL of the CO2 from the coal-fired power plants, of which you'd probably need at at least an additional 1,000 for the US alone, you'll still be causing climate change due to the greenhouse gas emissions, and 25 meter + sea level increases, largely eliminating most large coastal cities on the planet. This kind of makes it a moot point... :(

*** Someone mentioned electric cars, well a fuel cell car is in a way a electric car but instead of storing its energy in a inefficient battery it stores it in hydrogen and in the end the original energy for both cars comes from the same power source...the power plant. Electric cars are nice in theory but to date we have not produced a battery capable of storing energy as efficiently as other natural methods such as fossil fuels/hydrogen etc.
also im not all there right now sos sorry if I'm hard to understand

Storing hydrogen is even less efficient... and you cannot even due it with today's technology: there are no tanks in existence that are inexpensive and can store liquefied H2 without the gas boiling away and damaging the tank.

Furthermore, we've had electric car technology for 40+ years, and current hybrid cars can be modified to plug in to an outlet at your home or office to recharge: this is VERY real technology. Coupled with, say, photovoltaic panels on your roof, you can charge your car's battery with ZERO input from fossil fuels.

Additionally, car manufacturers have already implemented Lithium-Ion batteries that allow 200+ miles on a single charge.


And did somebody mention biodiesel yet?
 
Last edited:
^^^Actually electric cars have been out even longer than that. The Pierce-
Arrow museum in Buffalo has an all electric car from 1911. We've actually gone backward technologically with the automobile in the last 90 years.
 
I'm no expert on hydrogen fuel but I think it requires electricity and water. The electricity takes the water and processes the hydrogen out and then the hydrogen is used by the car. I dont remember how the car processes hydrogen, but I think it's zero emissions and water is a byproduct or something. Whoever suggested this must concider hydrogen a realistic replacement for gas in terms of mass consumption. I think if people, such as myself, understood how it works better, there would be stronger support.

Your right, all you need is purified water and electricity. The means of getting both cheaply and cleanly is the point of contention for distribution.

They won't get hydrogen from electrolysis of water. They'll reform methane or methanol.

Is they referring to this initiative or the industry in general? You can get hydrogen from electrolysis of water and it can even be done remotely by a self contained solar powered machines, of which are already designed and past the experimental phase (a pump about the size of a gas pump).


This is just a dumb idea--hello electric car? Why do we need some kind of fuel at all. Building an entirely new infrastructure just seems like a waste to me.

Well hydrogen cars ARE electric cars. So if you have a hydrogen car there is really no reason why a simple "plug in" conversion could be added in addition to the hydrogen system. This is also why hybrids now are important because manufacturers are becoming much more knowledgeable about mass production of electric vehicles. With the switch to hydrogen from gas, the only thing that would be "new" to manufacturers is the energy production mechanism, while the rest of the propulsion system and electric storage system will be mastered

You need lots of renewable green power to do the mass electrolysis of water to get the hydrogen. If you must burn Fossil Fuels to get the electricity required, all you are doing is transferring the pollution from the cities to the power plants. The amount that goes into the atmosphere is still the same.

Hydrogen powered cars only make sense in places where the vast majority of power production is green.

Very true, but addressing the cost, implementation, technology, and myriad of other issues are more easily dealt with on the large scale then dealing with each independent driver.

And I would not say "the amount is the same" because production of energy on the grid level is more efficient per unit than individual vehicles. But it is an major issue non the less.
 
Last edited:
they'll reform methane or methanol because it takes less energy. it's actually not terribly inefficient, which is why this isn't totally without merit. storage isn't such a pain in the ass either
 
Your right, all you need is purified water and electricity. The means of getting both cheaply and cleanly is the point of contention for distribution.

Is they referring to this initiative or the industry in general? You can get hydrogen from electrolysis of water and it can even be done remotely by a self contained solar powered machines, of which are already designed and past the experimental phase (a pump about the size of a gas pump).

Well hydrogen cars ARE electric cars. So if you have a hydrogen car there is really no reason why a simple "plug in" conversion could be added in addition to the hydrogen system. This is also why hybrids now are important because manufacturers are becoming much more knowledgeable about mass production of electric vehicles. With the switch to hydrogen from gas, the only thing that would be "new" to manufacturers is the energy production mechanism, while the rest of the propulsion system and electric storage system will be mastered

Very true, but addressing the cost, implementation, technology, and myriad of other issues are more easily dealt with on the large scale then dealing with each independent driver.

And I would not say "the amount is the same" because production of energy on the grid level is more efficient per unit than individual vehicles. But it is an major issue non the less.

I still don't understand why we need to develop some kind of new fuel at all when we should be concentrating resources on advanced batteries that can supply enough charge for long distances, last for longer periods in between charges, and charge quickly. My point is that we simply shouldn't need to make any kind of fuel except for electricity itself for standard automobiles.
 
Because, battery technology seems to be at an impasse. Barring significant, pretty much revolutionary, advances in battery technology there are only going to be refinements in lithium ion batteries with incremental advances. So what is more cost effective, developing fuel cells or nanotechnology batteries?

(It's a little bit of a exaggeration, but still relevant. Batteries are at an impasse until new technologies come to maturation and it's still debatable if they will match the performance of a hydrogen fuel cell)
 
i think this is just campbell/falcon getting some good publicity and only solidifies the fact that they have an inability to prioritize and properly plan. "look at what we have world, oh, but don't go to our cities cause you won't be able to get around them without building a new school or hospital in alberta."

funding for skytrain down broadway and to the NE sector would do so much more for the environment than making a handfull of buses during the olympics "green".
 


Back
Top