Mike K.
New member
As this article illustrates, neither builders, policy makers or scientists are sure what the benefits or dis-benefits green roofs may present.
Green roofs strike a chord with designers, builders
Garden-topped buildings are suddenly in vogue, but experts disagree as to whether they are worth the expense
DEBORAH JONES
Special to The Globe and Mail
VANCOUVER -- As fear of climate change turns most public policy decisions shades of green, the roof colour of buildings is taking on a murky hue.
Green roofs have existed since the Hanging Gardens of Babylon were built around 600 BC, and have long been common in Europe.
There are a couple in British Columbia, including at the country market in Coombs on Vancouver Island, where goats munch grass on the rooftop, and the ambrosial park atop the Law Courts in Vancouver, a perennial favourite with the downtown lunch crowd. But they haven't really caught on in the province - until now.
"Green roofs," seen as one solution to climate change, are now sprouting everywhere, despite concerns ranging from the costs and benefits to fear of more leaky condos.
There are two kinds of green roofs: membranes covered with a few inches of soil and vegetation that cannot be walked on, for example, the roof on the downtown Vancouver Public Library, and extensions of indoor living space to outside, for example the terrace on the Coast Hotel on Denman Street in Vancouver.
Fewer than 1 per cent of roofs in B.C. are "green roofs," estimates Jim Watson, technical manager of the Roofing Contractors Association of B.C. Most, he said, are on large buildings, and are designed and maintained by professionals.
"What's different now is there's a movement to put rooftop gardens on wood-frame condos," Mr. Watson said. "They're moving into the mainstream, and unfortunately, the people building them value the [professional engineers and architects] out of it. They're going to build as least expensively as they can, and the oversight is a question mark."
Everyone agrees that green roofs are lovely additions to dense urban areas. It's the environmental benefits - and cost - that designers and builders dispute.
Covering buildings with soil and vegetation can help reduce rainwater runoff into sewers, insulate buildings from heat and cold, protect the waterproof covering from degradation caused by the sun, reduce air pollution and cool city temperatures, advocates say.
Critics counter that green roofs are for the birds, arguing that the only beneficiaries are the warblers that alight on them to rest.
Seeds of public controversy were sown after several B.C. municipalities encouraged or required green roofs on certain new buildings. The bloom came off that idea early this year when three insurance companies refused to insure green roofs in the province.
"We're nearing a collision point," said Jan Calkins, spokesperson for the provincial Homeowner Protection Office. To get building permits, she said, developers are required under the Homeowner Protection Act to have warranty insurance, which insurers are refusing to provide. The agency has called a conference on May 29 for insurers, builders, designers and scientists to hash out the problems.
While green roofs are common in Europe, "in a climate similar to our own, there's not a huge track record," said Karen Liu, an engineer and research scientist with the Centre for the Advancement of Green Roof Technology at the B.C. Institute of Technology, which is testing three types of roof structures.
Architect Freda Pagani, the recently retired head of the sustainability office at the University of British Columbia, is a green-roof skeptic.
"People concerned about the environment have taken up green roofs as a cause célèbre. But I don't think they automatically make sense," Ms. Pagani said. "I am concerned that the touted benefits are not that compelling."
In very hot cities such as Houston, Tex., all agree that green roofs would be helpful. The research at BCIT has shown that summer temperatures on traditional roofs can reach more than 65 C, while the same roof with a layer of vegetation reaches just 30.
But in Vancouver's temperate zone, Ms. Pagani said, "you'd be much better, from a cost point of view, to add regular insulation to the roof. To put a green roof on, you have to beef up the structure, and it's much more expensive."
Soil on roofs can help retain water during heavy rainfalls, she acknowledged, but only until it is saturated. In B.C., which has lately endured deluges lasting weeks, cities "might be better to put in a separate storm system compared to the cost of all the additional green roofs."
More cost-efficient ways of tackling climate change, she suggested, might be investment in renewable energy, including microhydro projects, and designing buildings to use passive solar energy.
Green roofs are "two to three times the costs of conventional roofs," Mr. Watson said. "The additional upfront cost factor would take the lifetime of the roof to get close to being any kind of a payback."
But Mr. Watson believes green roofs have their place. "The real benefit to humanity is just providing more green space for people in big centres. ... As we move toward a denser population, why not create some green spaces?"
Ms. Pagani agreed that livability is the best reason to install green roofs, but said the cost-effectiveness has not been proved.
"We have to get a lot more thoughtful and smart," Ms. Pagani said. "People think there are easy answers to a set of complex problems that require much more profound responses than just adding green roofs."
Green roofs strike a chord with designers, builders
Garden-topped buildings are suddenly in vogue, but experts disagree as to whether they are worth the expense
DEBORAH JONES
Special to The Globe and Mail
VANCOUVER -- As fear of climate change turns most public policy decisions shades of green, the roof colour of buildings is taking on a murky hue.
Green roofs have existed since the Hanging Gardens of Babylon were built around 600 BC, and have long been common in Europe.
There are a couple in British Columbia, including at the country market in Coombs on Vancouver Island, where goats munch grass on the rooftop, and the ambrosial park atop the Law Courts in Vancouver, a perennial favourite with the downtown lunch crowd. But they haven't really caught on in the province - until now.
"Green roofs," seen as one solution to climate change, are now sprouting everywhere, despite concerns ranging from the costs and benefits to fear of more leaky condos.
There are two kinds of green roofs: membranes covered with a few inches of soil and vegetation that cannot be walked on, for example, the roof on the downtown Vancouver Public Library, and extensions of indoor living space to outside, for example the terrace on the Coast Hotel on Denman Street in Vancouver.
Fewer than 1 per cent of roofs in B.C. are "green roofs," estimates Jim Watson, technical manager of the Roofing Contractors Association of B.C. Most, he said, are on large buildings, and are designed and maintained by professionals.
"What's different now is there's a movement to put rooftop gardens on wood-frame condos," Mr. Watson said. "They're moving into the mainstream, and unfortunately, the people building them value the [professional engineers and architects] out of it. They're going to build as least expensively as they can, and the oversight is a question mark."
Everyone agrees that green roofs are lovely additions to dense urban areas. It's the environmental benefits - and cost - that designers and builders dispute.
Covering buildings with soil and vegetation can help reduce rainwater runoff into sewers, insulate buildings from heat and cold, protect the waterproof covering from degradation caused by the sun, reduce air pollution and cool city temperatures, advocates say.
Critics counter that green roofs are for the birds, arguing that the only beneficiaries are the warblers that alight on them to rest.
Seeds of public controversy were sown after several B.C. municipalities encouraged or required green roofs on certain new buildings. The bloom came off that idea early this year when three insurance companies refused to insure green roofs in the province.
"We're nearing a collision point," said Jan Calkins, spokesperson for the provincial Homeowner Protection Office. To get building permits, she said, developers are required under the Homeowner Protection Act to have warranty insurance, which insurers are refusing to provide. The agency has called a conference on May 29 for insurers, builders, designers and scientists to hash out the problems.
While green roofs are common in Europe, "in a climate similar to our own, there's not a huge track record," said Karen Liu, an engineer and research scientist with the Centre for the Advancement of Green Roof Technology at the B.C. Institute of Technology, which is testing three types of roof structures.
Architect Freda Pagani, the recently retired head of the sustainability office at the University of British Columbia, is a green-roof skeptic.
"People concerned about the environment have taken up green roofs as a cause célèbre. But I don't think they automatically make sense," Ms. Pagani said. "I am concerned that the touted benefits are not that compelling."
In very hot cities such as Houston, Tex., all agree that green roofs would be helpful. The research at BCIT has shown that summer temperatures on traditional roofs can reach more than 65 C, while the same roof with a layer of vegetation reaches just 30.
But in Vancouver's temperate zone, Ms. Pagani said, "you'd be much better, from a cost point of view, to add regular insulation to the roof. To put a green roof on, you have to beef up the structure, and it's much more expensive."
Soil on roofs can help retain water during heavy rainfalls, she acknowledged, but only until it is saturated. In B.C., which has lately endured deluges lasting weeks, cities "might be better to put in a separate storm system compared to the cost of all the additional green roofs."
More cost-efficient ways of tackling climate change, she suggested, might be investment in renewable energy, including microhydro projects, and designing buildings to use passive solar energy.
Green roofs are "two to three times the costs of conventional roofs," Mr. Watson said. "The additional upfront cost factor would take the lifetime of the roof to get close to being any kind of a payback."
But Mr. Watson believes green roofs have their place. "The real benefit to humanity is just providing more green space for people in big centres. ... As we move toward a denser population, why not create some green spaces?"
Ms. Pagani agreed that livability is the best reason to install green roofs, but said the cost-effectiveness has not been proved.
"We have to get a lot more thoughtful and smart," Ms. Pagani said. "People think there are easy answers to a set of complex problems that require much more profound responses than just adding green roofs."