The problem with destroying the Gardiner is one of goods being shipped to downtown Toronto. Downtown Toronto needs a ton of product brought in to support all of its activities. Where are all these distribution centres that store office supplies, food for workers, etc? In the suburbs and beyond. You cannot ship all of these things by rail. Even if you could, sometimes it is not economically feasible when deliveries are small. And from wherever the rail depot would be, they still have to get to the buildings. I'd love to see Toronto connect with its waterfront, but we have to be realistic as well. Look at how our municipalites are being treated by the province today. There's no way the province would fund something like the viaduct shown above.