Fantasy/Speculative Infrastructure Projects


MolsonExport

Touching grass everyday.
Staff member
What fantasy or speculative infrastructure projects are near and dear to your heart, even if they are financially (or otherwise) unfeasible?

Doug Ford's tunneled highway under the 401? (at a cost of 45343.4 quadrillion dollars)?
66f578d00cbe1.image.jpg


A bridge or tunnel over/under the Strait of Belle Isle, connecting the Island of Newfoundland to Quebec or Labrador?

Sobi.jpg


A bridge/tunnel oover/under the Strait of Georgia, connecting Vancouver Island to the Mainland? (why it will never happen: https://www.capitaldaily.ca/news/bridge-fixed-link-vancouver-island-salish-sea)
5dea678abb83abfbad03456f_a447bbc520682f76f1fe0b0c6a7c26d27cc3c38ed09caaf68b573e0ef4212ed2.jpg
5dea6542bb83ab3c6b03308a_vancouver_island_proposed_fixed_link.jpg


A second International Airport for Toronto (e.g., Pickering)? Pickering Airport lands:
1024px-PickeringAirportLands.jpg


Damming James Bay to create a vast freshwater reservoir, with water to be exported? (Great Recycling and Northern Development Canal: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Recycling_and_Northern_Development_Canal)
GRAND_Canal_proposal_%28James_Bay_to_Lake_Huron%29.jpg


The grey line Montreal metro extension, linking Senneville to Senneterre?
:youmad:
 
High Speed Rail from Toronto to Montreal?

I mean Dougie's 401 tunnel, while definitely aggressive, is also not without precedent globally.

A fun one - In 2013 during MTO's "Niagara to GTA" study looking at long term capacity solutions for the Western GTA and Niagara, briefly studied a "cross-lake corridor", a ~30 kilometre underground tunnel between Eastern Hamilton and Mississauga. The tunnel would have had 6 lanes and been constructed along the shoreline with "drop into place" tunnel segments. They even went as far as drawing up preliminary interchange designs on either end.

Luckily, saner heads prevailed and MTO resolved to instead widen the QEW and put into place long-term plans to "quadruple" the Burlington Skyway.

1v0tKD7.png


4jhvjw2.png


bPAciwz.png


The study looked at a variety of other "big ideas" as well, like a Cambridge-Ancaster Freeway and a collector-express system on the QEW through Oakville and Burlington. None survived, other than a potential Cambridge - Brantford freeway.
 
High Speed Rail from Toronto to Montreal?

I mean Dougie's 401 tunnel, while definitely aggressive, is also not without precedent globally.

A fun one - In 2013 during MTO's "Niagara to GTA" study looking at long term capacity solutions for the Western GTA and Niagara, briefly studied a "cross-lake corridor", a ~30 kilometre underground tunnel between Eastern Hamilton and Mississauga. The tunnel would have had 6 lanes and been constructed along the shoreline with "drop into place" tunnel segments. They even went as far as drawing up preliminary interchange designs on either end.

Luckily, saner heads prevailed and MTO resolved to instead widen the QEW and put into place long-term plans to "quadruple" the Burlington Skyway.

1v0tKD7.png


4jhvjw2.png


bPAciwz.png


The study looked at a variety of other "big ideas" as well, like a Cambridge-Ancaster Freeway and a collector-express system on the QEW through Oakville and Burlington. None survived, other than a potential Cambridge - Brantford freeway.

Christ, I remember that one!
 
Interesting timing. Pickering airport officially died just a few a days ago. Most of the site is being transferred to the Rouge National Park.


East coast spaceport for heavy rockets. The global billionaire's are going to destroy the planet with their global launch cadences and 100,000 satellites so may as well join the fun in watching those things fly from here.
 
I'd love to see passenger rail from downtown Calgary to Canmore, and Banff.
I don't think Calgary itself would benefit enough if the line bypassed the urban area going from the airport to the mountains. Having a few ways to connect to that line via LRT would be nice. Would be so great for tourism, and locals alike.
If there were no limits to my fantasy, a high speed rail connection from downtown Calgary to Edmonton with stops at the two airports would be pretty rad. I know I'm not one of the first few thousand people to say something like this though.
 
Replacing AIM scrapyard/ offices in Saint John, NB with a mixed use high rise

AIM’s seaside scrapyard is a blight on Canada’s oldest incorporated city, and has even led to the death of multiple workers.


lqJ9Q4s.png




Would be amazing to see the Port of Saint John (one of the fastest growing container ports in Canada, and second largest port in Canada by gross tonnage) take over the scrapyard for their container operations… and even more amazing to see a mixed use high rises go up on top of where AIM’s offices currently exist. Not only could it help provide a lot of housing, such a building could be useful for the port’s offices, and more crucially, a port control centre at the top to aid in logistics, operations, and navigation.

Jpheayr.png


The PM wanted to build housing on federally owned port lands, and supposedly PP came up with this idea first. I think it would both look cool as hell, and be an interesting place to live with a birds eye view of the ships coming into the port everyday. Some posters on the Atlantic sub felt losing 3 acres of land to would somehow cripple the port… but I just don’t see how that could be the case.

*** And yes, that’s a Halifax class frigate near the dry docks in the second photo. Most of them were built in Saint John, NB, and I think it would be amazing to get one of the ships back when they are decommissioned, as a Museum ship.
 
I would love to see an expanded Sunshine Coast Fixed Link project that runs all the way up and around to Campbell River on Vancouver Island. It is obviously much less efficient than a bridge/tunnel structure between Vancouver and Victoria, but I think this is the most technically feasible way to link the island to the rest of the country.

BC has punted the Sunshine Coast Fixed Link project to the trash can for now, but I would like to see it resurrected someday. Its biggest shortfall is the sheer number of bridges that would be required.
 
If I had Bezos-level money and some sort of large-scale enterprise generating it, I think I might literally colonize Saint John and build it into the Boston-tier city it was made to be.
 
Interesting timing. Pickering airport officially died just a few a days ago. Most of the site is being transferred to the Rouge National Park.


East coast spaceport for heavy rockets. The global billionaire's are going to destroy the planet with their global launch cadences and 100,000 satellites so may as well join the fun in watching those things fly from here.

A nice pre-election gift to Durham Region from Ford. Unless you're a plane geek.
 
This is a fantasy proposal I posted as a youtube comment in response to a video update of the line 1 extension into Richmond Hill. While I'm generally enthusiastic about the extension, I think this is an even better option:

I generally like the project but what I'd like even better is if instead of extending the subway, they made it a GO line. The tunnel would run all the way from Union up to Finch underneath the current subway providing express service and relieving congestion similar to London's Crossrail or Paris RER, then extend to where the planned subway extension is supposed to end in Richmond Hill where it would emerge and run along the RH line rail corridor. Then another tunnel would run approximately 3km north west from near Elgin Mills Rd to Bathurst near Shaftsbury Ave where it would emerge onto a new surface corridor that extends north to meet the Barrie line. The new route would serve the part of the Barrie line north of Bloomington Rd. along with the RH line to Bloomington. Then the part of the Barrie line to the south of that would be it's own separate service called the King City GO. The trains would be 6-car, 156m long EMUs where the core of the route would be served by as many as 32 trains per hour (tph) with stops at Union, Queen, Bloor, Eglinton, and Sheppard where people could transfer onto the subway for local service to other subway stops.
.
There would be multiple benefits including:
  • The Barrie and RH lines could be much more frequent (with some additional capacity work including some double tracking on the northerly parts of those routes)
  • Eliminate the flood risk that threatens the current RH route when the Don is high
  • Shortens each route by about 8km and 10km per trip respectively by making them straighter and more direct
  • Allow the trains to run at higher speed due to routes being straighter
  • Provides numerous transfer opportunities between every subway line and GO (Ont line at Queen, line 2 at Yonge-Bloor, line 5 at Eglinton, and line 4 at Sheppard. And line 1 at all aforementioned stops
  • Makes GO symmetrical since there would no longer be more services to the west than the east as some western services would thru-run onto the Yonge corridor rather than terminate at Union
  • Provides extra capacity for line 1 which has experienced crowding at times
  • Gives areas north of Finch as faster "express" connection to key parts of town compared to the much slower subway which has 17 stops from Finch to Union vs 5
  • Would have more comfortable trains better suited to the longer distances
  • Offer a backup option for the Yonge branch of line 1 when it's closed for maintenance or emergency (replacement buses would only need to travel to the nearest GO stop)
  • Allow the King City line (Barrie line south of King City) to have more stops serving people in town since it wouldn't be serving people going long distances to Newmarket and Barrie
  • Increase capacity at Union with a new set of underground platforms
What made me think of it is Doug's stupid idea to build a highway tunnel under the 401. If the government is willing to spend enough money for something like that with so few benefits, just think what that money could accomplish if spent intelligently. A tunnel under the 401 from the 427 to McCowan would be about 30km, while the rail route would only have about 25km of tunnels. But it would also require much smaller tunnels with less expensive ventilation due to not needing to accommodate cars.

The peak period service pattern could look something like:

  • 8 tph through running from the King City line to Newmarket via Union
  • 8 tph (peak only) through running from the King City line to a new Elgin Mills Rd station
  • 4 tph from Hamilton Centre running express past many local Lakeshore stops to Newmarket
  • 4 tph from KWC to Barrie (2 from Kitchener and 2 using a new spur to originate from Cambridge)
  • 4 tph from a new Bolton/Woodbridge service to Bloomington via Union
  • 4 tph from Mount Pleasant to Aurora via Union

There are two stops on the current RH line that wouldn't be served (Old Cummer and Oriole). But they don't have high ridership and could perhaps be served by an extension to the Ontario line in the future. There could be an additional stop at Finch which could serve a crosstown version of this route. Trains could run on the hyrdo corridor with stops every 2-3 km making it faster than the subway which has an average of 1 stop per km.
 
As for Vancouver Island Connector, you probably want to go the northern route, connecting Powell River and Campbell River through Cortes Island → Read Island → Quadra Island. Much shorter spans. Not quite directly Vancouver to Victoria but you also avoid the US border and the Salt Spring Islands.
 
My fantasy speculative infrastructure project right now would be a border wall between Canada and the US, and the US will pay for it of course. Otherwise, we may need a good stimulus project anyway. I'm not sure if the 5,525 mile border length figure includes the Great Lakes or not, but we can use nets there.
 
A third bridge crossing the Saint John River in Fredericton. I'm not shooting for the moon haha. Passengers trains come back to Fredericton and Saint John.
 
For the hundred billion Doug wants to spend improving traffic in the GTA by minutes that same amount spent in Ontario over what is currently planned on infrastructure, would get:

1) Full HSR from Windsor to Ottawa. $30B
2) Full build-out of GO as a regional rail system with every single line fully electrified. Right now I believe three quarters will be electrified. $10B
3) Every subway extension Toronto is currently dreaming of, including Sheppard East, Bloor to Sherway and Ontario Line to Sheppard.$20B
4) Every LRT or extension currently on the plans by any municipality in Ontario including Ottawa Stage 3, Hamilton BLAST, Waterloo Stage 2, London's original LRT proposal. $20B
5) Full electrification of all transit and school buses in Ontario over a decade. $10B

$10B to spare.

Such a vision would be absolutely transformative for Ontario. Instead, dude wants to tunnel under the 401, so people can get stuck in traffic elsewhere in Toronto faster.
 
For the hundred billion Doug wants to spend improving traffic in the GTA by minutes that same amount spent in Ontario over what is currently planned on infrastructure, would get:

1) Full HSR from Windsor to Ottawa. $30B
2) Full build-out of GO as a regional rail system with every single line fully electrified. Right now I believe three quarters will be electrified. $10B
3) Every subway extension Toronto is currently dreaming of, including Sheppard East, Bloor to Sherway and Ontario Line to Sheppard.$20B
4) Every LRT or extension currently on the plans by any municipality in Ontario including Ottawa Stage 3, Hamilton BLAST, Waterloo Stage 2, London's original LRT proposal. $20B
5) Full electrification of all transit and school buses in Ontario over a decade. $10B

$10B to spare.

Such a vision would be absolutely transformative for Ontario. Instead, dude wants to tunnel under the 401, so people can get stuck in traffic elsewhere in Toronto faster.

You are way low on #1. $75Billion, minimum.
 
Regional HFR for the Maritimes.

- Mainline would be the Halifax/Moncton/Saint John corridor with extensive double tracking. Perhaps 4-5 departures daily in both direction.

Feeder lines would include
- Halifax to the northern Annapolis Valley (resurrecting old line), several times daily service in both directions.
- Moncton to Miramichi/Bathurst/Campbellton (current VIA corridor), daily service in both directions.
- Moncton to Grand Falls/Edmundston (current CNR mainline), daily service both directions in addition to VIA Ocean
- Saint John to Fredericton (new construction), two times daily service in both directions.

Upgraded VIA Ocean from Halifax/Moncton to Montreal rerouted to the CNR mainline through central NB. Return to daily service.

Urban LRT Network

- Extensive in HRM, concentrating on the Halifax/Bedford/Sackville corridor, with lesser frequency to Windsor and to East Hants/YHZ. Branch line service to Dartmouth including Dartmouth Crossing/Burnside Industrial Park, and to Dartmouth Downtown/Eastern Passage.
- Eventually in Moncton (mainline Salisbury/Moncton/Sackville with a resurrected branch line to Shediac and a new line to Northwest Moncton/Magnetic Hill).
- Eventually in Saint John, along the corridor from Saint John to Rothesay/Quispamsis/Hampton, and possibly a branch line to Grand Bay/Westfield.
 
Be nice if winnipeg had a freeway. Just one road that moved traffic and allowed you get across the city without stopping a hundred times. I’d kill for a fraction of the highway system that Quebec has.

As we approach a million people we have to be one of the worst cities in the world for lacking transportation infrastructure. We don’t even have rapid transit.

Our TransCanada highway is a death trap. random lights in the middle of nowhere because there’s no money for proper safe interchanges. Just all around pathetic transportation infrastructure in manitoba.

Be nice if the feds could invest in Manitobas port too. We are a maritime province. But they’ll probably build that canal to James bay through ontario before helping us out.
 


Back
Top