Wayyyy back when Southwest Properties demolished the original buildings it was stipulated that the Vault be preserved with consideration to being incorporated into the new building. I guess things have now changed over time and it has been deemed not feasible to do so. The heritage committee has approved the removal of the Vault so I guess they have been convinced it can't be saved.I thought an earlier story said Alt would incorporate the vault.
"The upper storeys of the building will consist of modular units ready for assembly on the site"...that should be interesting to see during the construction phase.
Vaguely related, there is a nice write-up from O'Dea's Realty about the Tobin Building across the street from the burned down law office ( http://www.odea.ca/214duckworth/214duckworth.htm ). James Tobin built the house in 1894 and sold liquor, tobacco, and groceries from the first floor. Tobin also owned the bonded warehouse across the street, which became the ill-fated law office. The house continued to be operated as a liquor store until 1953. Amazingly, it was vacant from 1953 to 1984. Since then, it has been used by Hayward Interiors, Hutton's Music, and most recently Pollyanna Antiques. For $799,000, it's a steal. Of course, why pay $799,000 for four historic storeys on Duckworth overlooking the war memorial, harbour, and narrows, when you can pay over a million for a vinyl castle by the airport?
It's not an unreasonable tone to take. "Where to live" is not the simple or neutral choice it seems. There are tons (literally, when talking carbon emissions) of negative externalities inherent in the choice to live in a new-build outside the city. There are unique circumstances like a well-designed home for someone who works from home, but even then there are utilities, etc. to worry about. Sure, someone may have a simple preference for a big yard/lot and vinyl, but it's loaded with our cultural conditioning (which is pretty atrocious in terms of sustainability and history) and we should actively be trying to change some of these attitudes. Great city planning, which I think most people here are interested in, is not an exercise in "to each their own," but in ensuring density of development, deliverability of services, healthy/happy citizens, etc., very few of which are furthered by a "vinyl castle by the airport."
jthetzel didn't say they were "better people." I'm saying they are probably better for the city and environment, and the choice should be encouraged rather than presented as equal to all other options.Just saying that if you have $800,000 and buy a house on Duckworth Street doesnt make you any better a person than the same person who decides downtown living is not for them and prefers suburbia instead. (and the vinyl).
jthetzel didn't say they were "better people." I'm saying they are probably better for the city and environment, and the choice should be encouraged rather than presented as equal to all other options.

There's no way that'll ever get approved for demolition. A designated heritage structure that seems to still be in good shape? The city would be making a huge mistake allowing demolition of that. Hopefully they don't slip up on this.