Development Rumours


Maybe for now. Main St. is expected to be improved over the next several years with low to mid rise housing expected to take over a lot of the current run down retail locations.


Don't hold your breath. It will remain a heavily trafficked street given that it is one of the main routes to suburbia and as such will never be a bucolic neighborhood of people walking their digs and frolicking in their front yards.
 
Don't hold your breath. It will remain a heavily trafficked street given that it is one of the main routes to suburbia and as such will never be a bucolic neighborhood of people walking their digs and frolicking in their front yards.

It will be fine once all traffic converts to cyclists quietly pedaling along on their way home...
stirthepot.gif
 
It will be fine once all traffic converts to cyclists quietly pedaling along on their way home...
stirthepot.gif
I finally figured out why so many people in continental Europe cycle to work - after paying the rent/mortgage, the power and heat they have no money left.
A family of 3 in Germany has an average annual electricity bill of $1,500 not including heat.
In Denmark the cost of 95 octane gasoline is $2.30 a litre
 
I finally figured out why so many people in continental Europe cycle to work - after paying the rent/mortgage, the power and heat they have no money left.
A family of 3 in Germany has an average annual electricity bill of $1,500 not including heat.
In Denmark the cost of 95 octane gasoline is $2.30 a litre

Makes me thankful to live in Canada! ;)
 
Should be noted the parking lot behind the Agricola Street NSLC has closed and construction fencing has been installed. If it is for an as-of-right building it would have frontage on Maynard Street.
 
Here's a proposal for the big "hole" on Young Avenue:

young.jpg


Discussion: http://wayemason.ca/2019/11/28/important-update-on-young-avenue/

I'm not sure what to think about the arguments. I wish there were a clearer distinction made between heritage preservation and preservation of low densities; the two things are not the same. I am also a bit skeptical about timeline-based arguments that rely on plans being enacted 10 months in the future. 10 months can easily turn into multiple years, so I understand why developers do not want to wait for upcoming rules to be put into place. I am sympathetic toward the idea that one-off deals undermine development incentives like bonus density for heritage preservation or affordable housing.
 
It's a strange narrative, one councilor complaining about another councilor's motion on social media.

I do not know why this has been brought forward, the Councillor who made the motion has not spoken to me about, other than when I approached him having heard of his intentions, and asked him to delay any such motion until I was actually going to be at Council, which he did.

I'm not sure which 'big hole' is being filled by this. I guess as long as none of the old landmark mansions are destroyed, then density is density. May as well go higher, though - 20 storeys? 30? Oh... right... the Centre plan...
 
Someone thought, hey! lets plop a suburban design in the middle of one of the few historic boulevards left in the city.
This is going to be a disaster.
 
Someone thought, hey! lets plop a suburban design in the middle of one of the few historic boulevards left in the city.
This is going to be a disaster.

Yeah, but what about your statement (said sarcastically) in the other thread?
Yeah, don't think about the 1.2% vacancy rate allowing the few units in the city be priced out of people's price range, we need to protect the people that already have homes. Let's go back to the good old days when the population shrank so low we could keep traffic down and avoided having to make major investments.

We've added 20,000 people over three years, if each of those families wanted a half acre lot that's 5000 acres never mind the cost of running services to the 50 new suburbs that would spring up overnight, we'll make those silly urban dwellers pay for that. We won't think about the next 20,000 people either, they don't exist yet.

Pick a philosophy and stick with it. Let's put up a 30-storey apartment building to house some of those 20,000 new residents!

;)
 
Yeah, but what about your statement (said sarcastically) in the other thread?


Pick a philosophy and stick with it. Let's put up a 30-storey apartment building to house some of those 20,000 new residents!

;)

Though more pointed at the people in the article from the OP which is why you weren't quoted, I can't stop you from taking it personally. This is a page dedicated to Skyscrapers, not to say that this is a safe space for people that agree that skyscrapers have there place in a modern city but it is. It's very similar to a support group kind of like Skyscrapers Anonymous. :D

Beyond the great information provided by people across the industry on planning issues as well as your own greatly appreciated contributions.
It should be a given that on a site named Skyscraperpage that this debate has been settled.:cheers:
I understand your position on the lost quality of life a single detached home can provide after the uses start to change in a community even a four story one which effected your neighborhood can cause the same feeling as one much taller. I'm not recommending high-rises for Lower Sackville (which are already banned, just in case) or other suburban street corners. I'm suggesting in the right places like the CBD or transit nodes, we should be stretching up not out. On this particular project, there is nothing that can be done to repair the damage to the streetscape and overall trust of the community. Something has to go there now because its an empty lot, but this is not the best option IMO. The Wedding Cake house will be missed it was one of my favorites poking out from the trees, these can't be replaced easily.

I don't wish a world of skyscrapers but if a building is well designed and well executed it can be a beautiful living art piece, that thousands of people can use in many different ways on a day to day basis.
A big word tossed around lately as well is sustainability, to save habitats and environmental degradation, we do have to start thinking up. Having studied urban planning though not my chosen profession at the moment, there is no one blanket answer to how we should build a city. What I can say with certainty is Halifax struggles with building heights and has handicapped itself by restricting the most efficient way humans have learned to live with each other.
We could build twenty seven 5 story buildings or three 45 story buildings, which would go a long way in helping make the city affordable again. The problem is when we run out of green and brownfield sites on the peninsula, heritage buildings like these two will be in the cross-hairs. Three more heritage properties were torn down on Barrington St. recently to make way for one of those 5 story buildings we need plus the four 4 story on this site. Fighting market forces is pointless in a boom, especially when the plan is to restrict height all over the core because of sentiments like this.:shrug:

Also it is a bit odd for Streatch to propose this in Waye's district, the developer seems to know he doesn't have many friends left in the area.:lynchmob:
 
It's a strange narrative, one councilor complaining about another councilor's motion on social media.



I'm not sure which 'big hole' is being filled by this. I guess as long as none of the old landmark mansions are destroyed, then density is density. May as well go higher, though - 20 storeys? 30? Oh... right... the Centre plan...


The developer bought and then tore down several of what used to be old mansions which sadly had been converted into multi-unit rentals. There may have been another couple of tear-downs on buildings that were not rentals - I have not followed recent developments there closely - but which required significant upgrading. The owners cashed out and moved on as per the market at work. In any event there is now a large empty area as shown.

The bickering at Council is interesting. Mason of course has been an opponent of virtually all private residential development having any density in his district, the battles on Wellington St being the most notable but not the only ones. He is the poster child for what @someone123 and others have been talking about here, the fight to keep single-family areas remaining that way and fighting against density on one hand while decrying "sprawl" on the other. He panders to the moneyed south-end property owners and of course also pushed through anti-vehicle traffic measures on a number of streets including the one he lives on.

He refuses to deal in a rational manner with this developer, similar to his protege Austin with the Prince Albert Rd hotel development in Dartmouth, and so another channel was opened up. Interestingly Mason had gone to ground in the online world over the last few months as his advisors apparently made him realize his superior, smug, arrogant and combative online persona might be harmful to his aspirations to be Mayor, but this has smoked him out of his hidey-hole. I have minimal sympathy for this developer, but he was forced to find someone else on Council to bring forward his proposal since the one for the area in which he owns property has been actively working against him.

As for the sketch shown, it looks like a tarted-up Highfield Park special and something better needs to be proposed. But the reality is that there is a big chunk of empty property there and building new single-family McMansions on it is unlikely to make sense for anyone. Waiting for yet another HRM Planning vision of the area which would likely take years to come forward with no assurance that it would be sensible or viable (especially with Mason being a wannabe planner with an axe to grind whispering in the ears of the planning staff) is not a reasonable response.
 
Last edited:
As Keith says above, the developer did tear down several buildings. They weren't heritage-registered, but virtually everyone decried it and it definitely damaged Young's unique aesthetic.

I don't have much sympathy for the idea that any street should be "protected" from multi-unit buildings, and that includes Young. In this case though, the developer has acted with extreme shiftiness, and has shown total disregard for the area's heritage. (He's also torn down historic buildings in Bedford and elsewhere--he seems to get a kick out of it.)

In this case, I don't think it makes any sense to build single-family houses on these lots. However, I also don't think the developer should be rewarded for bad behavioour, and for trying to continually bend the rules to his own interests. I have no doubt that if allowed to do this he'll just buy up and demolish more of Young. I also have no doubt that this proposal would end up looking goofy and faux historic.

What we really need is heritage designation that prohibits demolition, not this 36-month waiting period stuff. Then establish a Young HCD which actually protects the historic buildings on the street while allowing modest intensification of other areas, including small multi-unit buildings. I don't think we want towers here, but a four-storey walk-up? Fine. We shouldn't rely on ultra-restrictive zoning to protect heritage.
 
Though more pointed at the people in the article from the OP which is why you weren't quoted, I can't stop you from taking it personally. This is a page dedicated to Skyscrapers, not to say that this is a safe space for people that agree that skyscrapers have there place in a modern city but it is. It's very similar to a support group kind of like Skyscrapers Anonymous. :D

Beyond the great information provided by people across the industry on planning issues as well as your own greatly appreciated contributions.
It should be a given that on a site named Skyscraperpage that this debate has been settled.:cheers:
I understand your position on the lost quality of life a single detached home can provide after the uses start to change in a community even a four story one which effected your neighborhood can cause the same feeling as one much taller. I'm not recommending high-rises for Lower Sackville (which are already banned, just in case) or other suburban street corners. I'm suggesting in the right places like the CBD or transit nodes, we should be stretching up not out. On this particular project, there is nothing that can be done to repair the damage to the streetscape and overall trust of the community. Something has to go there now because its an empty lot, but this is not the best option IMO. The Wedding Cake house will be missed it was one of my favorites poking out from the trees, these can't be replaced easily.

I don't wish a world of skyscrapers but if a building is well designed and well executed it can be a beautiful living art piece, that thousands of people can use in many different ways on a day to day basis.
A big word tossed around lately as well is sustainability, to save habitats and environmental degradation, we do have to start thinking up. Having studied urban planning though not my chosen profession at the moment, there is no one blanket answer to how we should build a city. What I can say with certainty is Halifax struggles with building heights and has handicapped itself by restricting the most efficient way humans have learned to live with each other.
We could build twenty seven 5 story buildings or three 45 story buildings, which would go a long way in helping make the city affordable again. The problem is when we run out of green and brownfield sites on the peninsula, heritage buildings like these two will be in the cross-hairs. Three more heritage properties were torn down on Barrington St. recently to make way for one of those 5 story buildings we need plus the four 4 story on this site. Fighting market forces is pointless in a boom, especially when the plan is to restrict height all over the core because of sentiments like this.:shrug:

Also it is a bit odd for Streatch to propose this in Waye's district, the developer seems to know he doesn't have many friends left in the area.:lynchmob:

Well said, and I agree with your points. I also agree with your previous assertion that this will be a mess.

FWIW, the ;) was a hint that I was just yanking your chain a little... I sometimes have this habit of tossing little jabs out there, but believe me it's meant to be in good humour. Conversely, if I really don't agree with something, I try to be honest to my convictions (while still trying to keep an open mind) - sometimes I may state it a little too directly, though. :cheers:
 
Thanks Keith and Drybrain for your comments. This clears up a lot for me as I haven't followed it since those major vintage mansion demolitions a couple of years ago.

I agree that this looks like it's going to be a bad development, and can't help but feel derision towards the developer in the way that it was done. While I don't condone special treatment for the wealthy, Young Avenue has long been a special street in the minds of many Haligonians and there seems to be an underlying plot to erase this somehow... maybe it's not that dubious as it might just be about making some cash, but either way I feel a good chunk of Halifax's character and history is being removed, for little to no payback to the city.

That said, the antics in council appear to indicate that there is something concerning going on below the surface, and it is making me doubt the competency of at least a few of them. I guess we'll see what happens from here...
 
As Keith says above, the developer did tear down several buildings. They weren't heritage-registered, but virtually everyone decried it and it definitely damaged Young's unique aesthetic.

I don't have much sympathy for the idea that any street should be "protected" from multi-unit buildings, and that includes Young. In this case though, the developer has acted with extreme shiftiness, and has shown total disregard for the area's heritage. (He's also torn down historic buildings in Bedford and elsewhere--he seems to get a kick out of it.)

In this case, I don't think it makes any sense to build single-family houses on these lots. However, I also don't think the developer should be rewarded for bad behavioour, and for trying to continually bend the rules to his own interests. I have no doubt that if allowed to do this he'll just buy up and demolish more of Young. I also have no doubt that this proposal would end up looking goofy and faux historic.

What we really need is heritage designation that prohibits demolition, not this 36-month waiting period stuff. Then establish a Young HCD which actually protects the historic buildings on the street while allowing modest intensification of other areas, including small multi-unit buildings. I don't think we want towers here, but a four-storey walk-up? Fine. We shouldn't rely on ultra-restrictive zoning to protect heritage.

My concern i that these type of measures aren't really successful on their own. If restrictions are placed on a building for the purpose of heritage preservation and this prevents it from being demolished or fundamentally altered, then depending on the economic context we can see things like the building owner allowing it to deteriorate to the point of being condemned so that the site can be re-developed. Heritage designation does come with certain financial incentives such as grants to allow maintenance, but they may not be enough and I don't believe it's even mandatory for owners to accept them.

Also, as it stands, heritage designation isn't something forced upon a building but rather something a property owner applies for. It would be hard to change this, especially if heritage designation came bundled with implications for the property's finances or how the property can be used/altered. It would almost have to be treated as something similar to eminent domain seizure in that the owner would need to be compensated. The big issue imo isn't one of regulation but one of finances. If heritage buildings aren't valued by the market or by their individual owners but are valued by the city or wider community, the city and community simply need to accept the financial implications of this.

The city either needs to buy the structures, or needs to ensure that there's a more robust funding mechanism in place. Not just to physically maintain them, but to maintain their presence in the market. If an old building isn't suitable for the type of uses that an area has transitioned into (such as residential to commercial) causing potential tenants to prefer newer structures, perhaps there needs to be subsidies provided to attract them. This stuff may be expensive, but if the city genuinely feels there's a net benefit in heritage preservation, then we gotta just start paying.
 
I don't necessarily think only allowing single unit dwellings will preserve the streetscape of Young Avenue; take a gander at 518 Young if you're ever in the area (not up on Street View yet). That being said, allowing Tsimiklis' proposal would be making a mockery of the planning process.
 
I wonder when there will be news on the Dennis Building? This was in a news story from back in April:

According to the rules set out by the province, the development must receive approval from Halifax Regional Municipality within 18 months, and construction must be completed within 42 months of that approval, for the lease agreement to remain valid.

https://www.thechronicleherald.ca/b...-properties-in-halifaxs-downtown-core-306114/

There were a couple of articles out last week about the Dennis Building being added to the Heritage Registry, which the Province had decided against previously. Hopefully that's a sign that it's being taken seriously that something needs to be done with the property. My worry, as in all cases like this, is that it will continue to deteriorate while it sits awaiting some kind of action on the government's part.

https://signalhfx.ca/dennis-building-to-be-added-to-hrms-heritage-registry/

https://www.thecoast.ca/halifax/heritage-status-granted-to-dennis-building/Content?oid=19554775
 
Here's a proposal for the big "hole" on Young Avenue:

young.jpg


Discussion: http://wayemason.ca/2019/11/28/important-update-on-young-avenue/

I'm not sure what to think about the arguments. I wish there were a clearer distinction made between heritage preservation and preservation of low densities; the two things are not the same. I am also a bit skeptical about timeline-based arguments that rely on plans being enacted 10 months in the future. 10 months can easily turn into multiple years, so I understand why developers do not want to wait for upcoming rules to be put into place. I am sympathetic toward the idea that one-off deals undermine development incentives like bonus density for heritage preservation or affordable housing.

This one has fizzled out, for now:

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/young-ave-development-proposal-dead-before-debate-halifax-1.5382836
 


Back
Top