Though more pointed at the people in the article from the OP which is why you weren't quoted, I can't stop you from taking it personally. This is a page dedicated to Skyscrapers, not to say that this is a safe space for people that agree that skyscrapers have there place in a modern city but it is. It's very similar to a support group kind of like Skyscrapers Anonymous.
Beyond the great information provided by people across the industry on planning issues as well as your own greatly appreciated contributions.
It should be a given that on a site named Skyscraperpage that this debate has been settled.:cheers:
I understand your position on the lost quality of life a single detached home can provide after the uses start to change in a community even a four story one which effected your neighborhood can cause the same feeling as one much taller. I'm not recommending high-rises for Lower Sackville (which are already banned, just in case) or other suburban street corners. I'm suggesting in the right places like the CBD or transit nodes, we should be stretching up not out. On this particular project, there is nothing that can be done to repair the damage to the streetscape and overall trust of the community. Something has to go there now because its an empty lot, but this is not the best option IMO. The Wedding Cake house will be missed it was one of my favorites poking out from the trees, these can't be replaced easily.
I don't wish a world of skyscrapers but if a building is well designed and well executed it can be a beautiful living art piece, that thousands of people can use in many different ways on a day to day basis.
A big word tossed around lately as well is sustainability, to save habitats and environmental degradation, we do have to start thinking up. Having studied urban planning though not my chosen profession at the moment, there is no one blanket answer to how we should build a city. What I can say with certainty is Halifax struggles with building heights and has handicapped itself by restricting the most efficient way humans have learned to live with each other.
We could build twenty seven 5 story buildings or three 45 story buildings, which would go a long way in helping make the city affordable again. The problem is when we run out of green and brownfield sites on the peninsula, heritage buildings like these two will be in the cross-hairs. Three more heritage properties were torn down on Barrington St. recently to make way for one of those 5 story buildings we need plus the four 4 story on this site. Fighting market forces is pointless in a boom, especially when the plan is to restrict height all over the core because of sentiments like this.:shrug:
Also it is a bit odd for Streatch to propose this in Waye's district, the developer seems to know he doesn't have many friends left in the area.:lynchmob: