Development Rumours


Demolition permits were submitted this week for the HALIFAX ALEHOUSE and HFX SPORTS BAR & GRILL buildings. The permit also includes the PID next to it which includes the former BUCK UGLY'S and the still open Keg Restaurant. The two PID are the southern half of the Brunswick-Prince-Market-Carmichael block

Who ended up buying the Alehouse property?
 
Demolition permits were submitted this week for the HALIFAX ALEHOUSE and HFX SPORTS BAR & GRILL buildings. The permit also includes the PID next to it which includes the former BUCK UGLY'S and the still open Keg Restaurant. The two PID are the southern half of the Brunswick-Prince-Market-Carmichael block

Who ended up buying the Alehouse property?

From here: "The Halifax Alehouse and HFX Sports Bar properties were bought by a company owned by George Ramia on Dec. 20, according to records on the province's land registry."

Most of the block is strictly tear-down-worthy, but demolishing the Alehouse building would be an act of absolute disregard for the city. This is one of the unprotected downtown buildings council tried to designate as heritage in 2019, until a coalition of property owners lost their heads over the whole plan and the mayor rallied against it.

A lot of the buildings discussed then (like some of the particularly rickety wooden ones at Pizza Corner) I think were probably not worthy of protection. The Alehouse clearly is; this is some of the most disappointing news re: built heritage in this city in a long time, particularly since there have been so many successed recently (the Elmwood, the Green Lantern, the Waverly, though that's in limbo at the moment).

I can only hope there's some other play at work here besides a full demolition. Facadism wouldn't really be suitable for this building, but better than nothing.
 
Last edited:
Demolition permits were submitted this week for the HALIFAX ALEHOUSE and HFX SPORTS BAR & GRILL buildings. The permit also includes the PID next to it which includes the former BUCK UGLY'S and the still open Keg Restaurant. The two PID are the southern half of the Brunswick-Prince-Market-Carmichael block

Who ended up buying the Alehouse property?

What a shame to hear about the Alehouse being demolished. I know it needs some work, but what a character-full building for the city to loose. This is sad news.
 
Demolition permits were submitted this week for the HALIFAX ALEHOUSE and HFX SPORTS BAR & GRILL buildings. The permit also includes the PID next to it which includes the former BUCK UGLY'S and the still open Keg Restaurant. The two PID are the southern half of the Brunswick-Prince-Market-Carmichael block.

Do the permits specify when the demolition(s) are to be completed?
 
The ale house is a building that Haritage advocates and the pro development crowd could both get behind to save. And all we hear is crickets…….l

I agree that the building deserves to survive if only because so much of the fabric of that historic neighbourhood has been lost over the years. That said, it's arguable that the structure is of limited historical interest in its own right. It's a relative newcomer -- built in 1893 -- and fairly pedestrian, having been built as a Salvation Army temple. It's ironic that after the tee-totalling Sally Ann vacated the place in 1965, it housed a succession of taverns, which is more in keeping with the heritage of the street. I'm not sure that's enough to save it, particularly if the building is in as much disrepair as it appears.
 
I agree that the building deserves to survive if only because so much of the fabric of that historic neighbourhood has been lost over the years. That said, it's arguable that the structure is of limited historical interest in its own right. It's a relative newcomer -- built in 1893 -- and fairly pedestrian, having been built as a Salvation Army temple. It's ironic that after the tee-totalling Sally Ann vacated the place in 1965, it housed a succession of taverns, which is more in keeping with the heritage of the street. I'm not sure that's enough to save it, particularly if the building is in as much disrepair as it appears.

I think the first sentence is accurate. But also, is it in disrepair? Obviously it needs some work, but I’ve never gotten the impression it’s falling apart. There was an issue with the brickwork on one corner coming loose last year, but masonry repairs are a pretty normal thing. I’d be very surprised to learn the building had some kind of terrible structural problems. It seems in fair condition.
 
Where should the new HRP HQ be built and what should happen to the the existing building ?
30 storeys would be the minimum at the present location
 
I agree that the building deserves to survive if only because so much of the fabric of that historic neighbourhood has been lost over the years. That said, it's arguable that the structure is of limited historical interest in its own right. It's a relative newcomer -- built in 1893 -- and fairly pedestrian, having been built as a Salvation Army temple. It's ironic that after the tee-totalling Sally Ann vacated the place in 1965, it housed a succession of taverns, which is more in keeping with the heritage of the street. I'm not sure that's enough to save it, particularly if the building is in as much disrepair as it appears.

It’s a decent example of a 132 year old masonry building in a prominent area of the city, that frankly adds a lot of character to the street that is mostly lacking. Even having lived here for a lifetime, I still get surprised that the people who make the rules still don’t seem to get that, or perhaps care. Making a few bucks always trumps (pardon the expression) preserving character and history.

FWIW, even if the building itself doesn’t have what is normally recognized as having significant history, the actual construction style and materials used is history in itself.
 
It’s a decent example of a 132 year old masonry building in a prominent area of the city, that frankly adds a lot of character to the street that is mostly lacking. Even having lived here for a lifetime, I still get surprised that the people who make the rules still don’t seem to get that, or perhaps care. Making a few bucks always trumps (pardon the expression) preserving character and history.

FWIW, even if the building itself doesn’t have what is normally recognized as having significant history, the actual construction style and materials used is history in itself.

Exactly. And 80 per cent of the site (the sports bar and Keg buildings) can be flattened to the ground and no one will care. I'd cheer that on; they're low-rise eyesores.

We're talking about preserving one small part of a large property parcel. There's only about five developable storeys above the Alehouse's existing two storeys anyway, occupying only a narrow sliver of the site.
 
The ale house is a building that Haritage advocates and the pro development crowd could both get behind to save. And all we hear is crickets…….l

You can still hear the crickets, but at least there's a little noise to compete with them. There needs to be more, though. Perhaps everyone reading this who believes the Alehouse building should not be demolished should sign the petition and send off a note to the mayor and councillor to let them know how you feel about it. Maybe they can be convinced that heritage and development can co-exist, and that they have the power to do something about it.

I think most people at SSP are pro-development, so why don't we attempt to prove it and help out in the cause. The heritage people are doing something already.

CBC article:
Heritage Trust aims to spare Halifax Alehouse building from demolition
The trust has launched a petition calling on Halifax Regional Municipality and the province to stop the demolition, strengthen protections for heritage buildings in the city and create more incentives to preserve the "historic fabric of our city."

The petition also calls on the Ramia Group to "do better." Lang said the heritage group plans to reach out to the company directly about their concerns. CBC News contacted the company on Wednesday about the petition but has not received a response.

In February 2020, Halifax staff recommended 1717 Brunswick St. be registered as a municipal heritage property, noting the architectural merit and integrity of the building designed by prominent architect Henry F. Busch, its history as a Salvation Army Citadel and temple after construction was completed in 1895, and its relationship to the surrounding area.

Following the Halifax Explosion, the report noted, the building was used to shelter and feed people left homeless by the disaster and also served as a logistics headquarters for relief efforts. Lang said after the Salvation Army left the property, it became home to a printing company and then a bar.

"This building has had so many uses. So there's so much to be inspired by this structure because of its rich history," Lang said.

She said the building is still in fairly good shape despite its age and would have had to pass building inspections recently since the Halifax Alehouse only closed in November 2024.

The petition, launched on Tuesday, had 763 signatures by Wednesday night.

Currently it has 1913 signatures.

Pics from the CBC article... in its original form:
1717-brunswick-street-salvation-army.jpg


Heck, it survived being painted green... surely it can survive development!
the-building-at-1717-brunswick-street-in-halifax-once-housed-atlantic-printing-ltd.jpg


From the Heritage Trust:
Take Action to Save 1717 Brunswick Street From Demolition!

Enough is Enough: Stop the Destruction of Halifax’s Built Heritage
Yet another important historic building is under threat of demolition in downtown Halifax, this time 1717 Brunswick Street, the former Halifax Alehouse.

The Ramia Group of Companies, which purchased the building in December 2024, has applied for a permit to demolish 1717 Brunswick Street, an architecturally and culturally significant part of this city’s built heritage.

Built in 1893, and designed by prominent architect Henry Busch, this attractive brick building was created to house Halifax’s first permanent Salvation Army Citadel temple. The building is one of the only remaining vestiges of the lost neighbourhood known as the “Upper Streets.” This colourful neighbourhood had a reputation of being rough and tumble due to the presence of a number of bars and brothels that attracted soldiers who were stationed nearby, as well as other patrons from across the city. At the same time, the Upper Streets was a welcoming and integrated neighbourhood, filled with working-class residents and newcomers from rural areas and other parts of the world. Demolishing this building would obliterate yet another piece of Halifax’s rich history at a time when we have already lost so much of our built heritage.

The residents of Halifax, and the millions of tourists who visit our historic city every year, value heritage buildings like 1717 Brunswick Street, and their presence provides economic and environmental benefits to the entire province. Truly progressive and successful cities are able to change and grow in ways that do not destroy the very qualities that make them special. We demand better for Halifax and from its leadership, property owners and developers.
 
Saving it is a no-brainer. They should consider putting up some money or create a funding campaign to buy it, as many of these HT people are quite well off.

The city might want to consider giving a height concession to the developer somewhere else (I assume they own other lots in the city that could benefit from height) to preserve it. That would be a win-win.

Even just saving the facade on both sides would be a win.
 
Saving it is a no-brainer. They should consider putting up some money or create a funding campaign to buy it, as many of these HT people are quite well off.

The city might want to consider giving a height concession to the developer somewhere else (I assume they own other lots in the city that could benefit from height) to preserve it. That would be a win-win.

Even just saving the facade on both sides would be a win.

Buying it would be a multi-million dollar expense, and Ramia would have to be a willing seller. More likely I think would be for Ramia to extract some kind of concessions/bonus from the city in exchange for preserving it in the development.
 
The city might want to consider giving a height concession to the developer somewhere else (I assume they own other lots in the city that could benefit from height) to preserve it. That would be a win-win.

I'm not sure that would be a good practice for HRM to get into. "Want extra height for your project? Buy up a valuable building and threaten to tear it down unless we give you extra height."
 
I'm not sure that would be a good practice for HRM to get into. "Want extra height for your project? Buy up a valuable building and threaten to tear it down unless we give you extra height."

Well, height limits are arbitrary/subjective anyway, so maybe this would prevent demolitions of heritage? (assuming preservation is the goal?)

It seems odd to me that people can also protest property they don't own over height issues when they aren't willing to put actual resources towards saving heritage in other cases.

We have different opinions on the flexibility of governance systems, just like that arbitrary work stoppage in Dartmouth that wasn't in anyone's best interests. Normative parameters are meant to be flexible.

Again, I'm providing ideas to help save this building. It will probably get torn down because people have rigid ways of thinking / aren't creative. No wonder this place is so backward.
 
I'm not sure that would be a good practice for HRM to get into. "Want extra height for your project? Buy up a valuable building and threaten to tear it down unless we give you extra height."

It’s not a good precedent but the developer holds all the cards in this case.
 
It seems pretty clear that the municipality should be expanding heritage registrations. Isn't the main problem that council has declined to pursue this? Maybe another issue is that the points system is not broad enough. Have the points been increased as buildings from a certain date have become older and rarer, or is the points system the same as it was 10-40 years ago? The Alehouse should be a registered heritage property.

The municipality should allow development of heritage properties but require that the owners maintain their character-defining elements. So building some extra floors on top is okay but stripping the building down is not okay.
 


Back
Top