Development Rumours


I was thinking, when looking at the sketch, that in a few decades people will be looking at these buildings the same way '80s buildings are looked upon now, with disdain.

Looking at DT Halifax the only '80s buildings I can think of off the top of my head are Purdys, 1801 Hollis and the Marriott Harbourfront. Of those only the latter does nothing for me. What disdainful buildings are you thinking of?
 
Looking at DT Halifax the only '80s buildings I can think of off the top of my head are Purdys, 1801 Hollis and the Marriott Harbourfront. Of those only the latter does nothing for me. What disdainful buildings are you thinking of?

I dunno, I don't have much love for any of those. Not ugly, just boring. The Marriott is probably the worst though.
 
Looking at DT Halifax the only '80s buildings I can think of off the top of my head are Purdys, 1801 Hollis and the Marriott Harbourfront. Of those only the latter does nothing for me. What disdainful buildings are you thinking of?

Only 3 buildings were built in the whole decade of the 1980s?

It was just a generalization, as styles never cut themselves off exactly at the advent and demise of a numerical decade. There was a lot of bland stuff with very little character and inherent cheapness built from the late seventies through, well, today actually... so take it from there.

Recently, there have been a lot of buildings following the cookie-cutter style that I outlined in my post above... that was my point, really.
 
That is ugly.
The height is good for the downtown area. I can't agree with it being an overdevelopment of the the lot considering its a block away from something of similar height and size.
Plus it's in the downtown, at 15 stories. The buildings down on Irishtown road will be bigger than this one

I think downtown Dartmouth would be a much more interesting place, and probably a better place for residents too, if it had more population density. If the old residential neighbourhoods are to be preserved, as a lot of residents seem to want, then higher density construction on infill sites like this one is the only viable compromise.

If downtown Dartmouth had another few thousand people there would be a market for a wider array of businesses and there would be more demand to improve transit and ferry services. We're already seeing the mix of businesses improve with King's Wharf; a small produce store is going to open up there this summer and I don't think the area has anything like that already.

A lot of people complain that downtown Dartmouth is just a shadow of what it was back in the 50's and 60's and the reason for that is mostly the low population density and low demand for local businesses.
 
I think downtown Dartmouth would be a much more interesting place, and probably a better place for residents too, if it had more population density. If the old residential neighbourhoods are to be preserved, as a lot of residents seem to want, then higher density construction on infill sites like this one is the only viable compromise.

If downtown Dartmouth had another few thousand people there would be a market for a wider array of businesses and there would be more demand to improve transit and ferry services. We're already seeing the mix of businesses improve with King's Wharf; a small produce store is going to open up there this summer and I don't think the area has anything like that already.

A lot of people complain that downtown Dartmouth is just a shadow of what it was back in the 50's and 60's and the reason for that is mostly the low population density and low demand for local businesses.

Basically agree, but I don't think it's a reason why we shouldn't expect mo' better architecture/design for larger structures such as the one illustrated in this thread (on the Halifax side too).

To give some context, what hurt DT Dartmouth most was suburban sprawl (as most urban cities in the '50s-'70s), including the advent of the shopping mall, and the acceptance of the longer commute as part of daily life. I recall a sharp decline in the downtown shopping area when Mic Mac Mall opened and a loss of the "small town feel" that the area had as the city expanded into areas like Forest Hills/Cole Harbour, etc.

In the early to mid 20th century, when my grandparents (and parents) lived there, the population was mostly concentrated in what is now considered the downtown area. Many families did not own a car, and many commuted to Halifax via the ferry service to work (and shop to a certain extent) there. The downtown area did contain enough support businesses so that a person could pretty much take care of their needs without having to leave the area (anecdotal information from what I've heard over the years).

That said, Dartmouth did have larger, more industrial employers such as the marine slips and Imperial Oil. But it was still for years considered a bedroom community to Halifax.

As the core downtown declined, it became more rundown and developed the reputation as being a bit of a rough area for awhile. However, in more recent decades downtown Dartmouth has been considered an attractive alternative to Halifax, mainly due to the ability to buy a nice, older home on a decent plot of land at a substantially lower price than Halifax. Thus I think that the residential areas are not dependent on local population density as much as we might think. However, I do agree that density will allow more businesses to be viable in the area. I doubt, however, that it will ever return to the status of a shopping destination as it once was, as the world around it has changed so much. But then again, who am I to say?

Re: produce. FWIW, there has been a weekly farmers' market in Alderney Landing for a number of years now.
 
@2286 Noggins Farms has produce 7 days/week in Alderney Landing. I went there yesterday to buy onions.
 
Yesterday I went for the SWITCH Dartmouth, it was great. The Sun Sun Café (been there as along as I can remember on Portland St), is being reno'ed. The Canteen (above the Two If By Sea) is apparently moving there. The building is a bit open right now, and looks to be quite old, with some type of old shed on the water side. Looks like a good spot for a side patio.
 
Yesterday I went for the SWITCH Dartmouth, it was great. The Sun Sun Café (been there as along as I can remember on Portland St), is being reno'ed. The Canteen (above the Two If By Sea) is apparently moving there. The building is a bit open right now, and looks to be quite old, with some type of old shed on the water side. Looks like a good spot for a side patio.

Looks like it was the "Harbor Cafe" around 1961:

https://novascotia.ca/archives/NSIS/archives.asp?ID=1696
 
Yesterday I went for the SWITCH Dartmouth, it was great. The Sun Sun Café (been there as along as I can remember on Portland St), is being reno'ed. The Canteen (above the Two If By Sea) is apparently moving there. The building is a bit open right now, and looks to be quite old, with some type of old shed on the water side. Looks like a good spot for a side patio.


Risky move. They have achieved success so far with a limited-hours offering of pricey takeaway food. The market for expensive sandwiches and soups in DT Dartmouth may not support an entire building unless they expand their offering/hours of operation or subdivide the space.
 
Risky move. They have achieved success so far with a limited-hours offering of pricey takeaway food. The market for expensive sandwiches and soups in DT Dartmouth may not support an entire building unless they expand their offering/hours of operation or subdivide the space.

I expect it won't be risky. Don't underestimate the hipster factor. They no doubt rent where they are now. If they reno the top two floors (which seems to be in process) they could get good rents for apartments which would take care of the mortgage for the building and cover the cost for the first floor. :cheers:
 
Amazing to see how popular British cars were here at that time.

Yeah, in that one photo there are at least 4.

They were cheap to buy and good on gas but didn't last very long, mainly due to rust issues and quality problems. By the early seventies they were pretty much displaced by Japanese imports (Toyota, Datsun mainly, who also had rust issues but had solid drivetrains), and the old mainstay, the Beetle. American companies tried to delve into the market with homegrown Pinto and Vega, but they had their problems too (exploding gas tanks and premature cylinder wear)...
 
Some scraps of info on what Dexel has planned for Barrington St. (and apparently Hollis/Bishop too!):

"Mr. Louie Lawen and Mr. Brent Robertson of Dexel Architecture presented to the Committee. They have plans to rehabilitate two registered municipal heritage properties at 1349-53 Barrington Street and 1333-35 Barrington Street. They will remove the building between these two heritage buildings and construct an appropriate infill building there. They want to keep the relevant heritage aspects of the two buildings. The current rules make rehabilitation very difficult. All of the brick and other elements such as windows will be removed and replaced on 1349-53 Barrington Street and the rear half of 1333-35 Barrington Street will be removed and replaced with a new structure to incorporate the heritage building into a larger development, which they would like to be 28 meters in height, in behind the heritage buildings. They are prepared to work with the HRM Planning Department and this Committee including any municipal financial incentives program.

They will demolish three buildings along Bishop Street at the corner of Hollis including 5134 Bishop Street, 5140 Bishop Street, 5144-46 Bishop Street and1363 Hollis Street. They wish to build a 37 meter building at this location. Dexel Architecture concluded their presentation and invited questions. They then left the meeting room."

Taken from: http://www.halifax.ca/boardscom/hac/documents/MeetingMinutesMay162016.pdf
 
Some scraps of info on what Dexel has planned for Barrington St. (and apparently Hollis/Bishop too!):

"Mr. Louie Lawen and Mr. Brent Robertson of Dexel Architecture presented to the Committee. They have plans to rehabilitate two registered municipal heritage properties at 1349-53 Barrington Street and 1333-35 Barrington Street. They will remove the building between these two heritage buildings and construct an appropriate infill building there. They want to keep the relevant heritage aspects of the two buildings. The current rules make rehabilitation very difficult. All of the brick and other elements such as windows will be removed and replaced on 1349-53 Barrington Street and the rear half of 1333-35 Barrington Street will be removed and replaced with a new structure to incorporate the heritage building into a larger development, which they would like to be 28 meters in height, in behind the heritage buildings. They are prepared to work with the HRM Planning Department and this Committee including any municipal financial incentives program.

They will demolish three buildings along Bishop Street at the corner of Hollis including 5134 Bishop Street, 5140 Bishop Street, 5144-46 Bishop Street and1363 Hollis Street. They wish to build a 37 meter building at this location. Dexel Architecture concluded their presentation and invited questions. They then left the meeting room."

Taken from: http://www.halifax.ca/boardscom/hac/documents/MeetingMinutesMay162016.pdf

did you catch the side discussion about Black Binney House?
Apparently someone wants to build a tower behind it between it and the Church.

the church is there, because the owner of the house at the time donated the land. Black Binney house was built to be an exclusive neighbor to the LT. Governor. (Whos front was originally Hollis St.)
 
The conservation district for this area can't come into effect soon enough. I have nothing positive to say about Dexel at this point.
 
did you catch the side discussion about Black Binney House?
Apparently someone wants to build a tower behind it between it and the Church.

the church is there, because the owner of the house at the time donated the land. Black Binney house was built to be an exclusive neighbor to the LT. Governor. (Whos front was originally Hollis St.)

My mum has always wanted to be able to go in and see the Black Binney house, as we are decedents of the original owners. It is certainly a well maintained building given its age, at least from the outside.
 


Back
Top