CPP ripoff in a recession


bornagainbiking

New member
CPP bosses to receive millions in bonuses
Updated Thu. May. 28 2009 5:57 PM ET

CTV.ca News Staff

The heads of the Canada Pension Plan are slated to take home millions in bonus payouts this year, even as the fund struggles and the economy slips deeper into recession.


According to the fund's annual report just released by the CPP Investment Board, David Denison, the president and CEO of the CPP, along with his top four executives, will take home a total $8.5 million in pay and bonuses for the 2009 fiscal year.


Additionally, the executives are due another $7 million in long-term awards that will be paid out over the next three fiscal years.


Denison earned a total of $2.9 million in the last fiscal year -- down 30 per cent from $4.2 million the prior year -- including a base salary of $490,000, an annual bonus of $735,000 and "long-term incentive plan" awards of $1.6 million.


He also earned $59,023 in pension contributions and $9,571 in other benefits, which the CPPIB said include life insurance, disability benefits, and health and dental plan costs.


The fund's top five executives -- including senior vice-presidents Mark Wiseman, Donald Raymond, Graeme Eadie and CFO Nicholas Zelenczuk -- earned a total of $8.5 million in 2009, down 31 per cent from $12.4 million in 2008.


The executives' annual bonuses and incentives are calculated not on annual returns, but on a rolling four-year average of the fund's performance.


Long-term incentive awards for the five named executives, that have not yet been paid out or vested, will total an additional $7,236,779. Those incentives will be paid out over the next three fiscal years ending in 2012.


The value of those long-term incentives is down 43.3 per cent from $12,755,461, the annual report stated.


Denison is also due an additional $1.2 million and Eadie, $530,964, to be paid out if they chose to retire.


The new figures come as the board, which invests billions of dollars not immediately needed to cover CPP benefits, reported that the CPP Fund shrank by $17.2 billion to $105.5 billion in the last fiscal year.


The fund's value dropped 18.6 per cent to end the 2009 fiscal year, the CPP investment board said in its annual report, which was released last week.


Political reaction


NDP Leader Jack Layton expressed outrage over the figures Thursday during question period in the House of Commons.


"The CPP Board is supposed to protect the savings of Canadians. This is money earned through hard work and they were counting on it for their retirement," Layton said.


"We have the prime minister essentially endorsing $17 million of Canadians' money going into the pockets of executives who just lost $24 billion. How can that make any sense whatsoever?"


Prime Minister Stephen Harper responded that the bonuses are determined by the CPP's board of directors, not his government.


"The board is responsible independently for remuneration for the management of the plan," Harper explained. "I noticed by the way, that the board did drop the total compensation for its executives by 31 per cent last year. But that is a board decision, not a government decision."


"This is a joint body of federal and provincial governments that is administered at arm's length and independent of politics," he added.


The CPP Fund's assets fell by $17.2 billion to $105.5 billion in the year ended March 31, because of steep stock-market losses, the board reported, amid "the worst global financial crisis since the Great Depression."


Denison acknowledged that the past year was a challenging year for the fund "and it was a challenging year for me personally, for all of us who are involved in managing the fund. :koko: :koko:


"We take the responsibility we have for managing the assets for 17 million Canadians very, very seriously."


In a conference call with reporters, CPP Investment Board Chair Bob Astley said the board remains confident in Denison and his team to lead the investment program, noting that the compensation the board offers its execs allow it to "compete for talent" in the private-sector world.


"We believe the compensation paid to our team this year properly reflected the value created over the past four years, as well as the obvious challenges faced by the CPP Fund - and all investors - in fiscal 2009," Astley said.
 
Well, they say if you compare the drop in the CPP to the drop in the rest of the market, the CPP did well, hence the bonuses.
 
How much do you think they should make?

How qualified do you think the people in charge of our pensions should be?
 
Competition

In the old days the expectation of the employer was a fair day's wage for a fair day's work.
Another private sector concept was if you MADE more money for your employer (sold the most cars, signed a big contract) you got a percentage or it would be a combo of like a wage and a commision sorta.
So with this train of thought the CPP board of govenors (self serving) have the nerve to vote a bonus. HEY you get a bonus (key word bonus look it up{extra})when you perform so if you lost this year NO bonus, or imagine a CUT. It is happening with the CAW, Tell that to the poor pensioner who lives month by month.
This is NOT the Boards money it is all Canadians money they were appointed to safeguard and administer fair and equally. If you vote yourself a BIG share that is like stealing but it's OK you and your cronies voted and said it's OK. Not the people of Canada.
How much should they get paid. let's see Monday to Friday 9-5 if you want, paid travel, benefits, pension (HUGE or vote one in), Nice office, and plenty of staff. No shift work, weekends or work on a holiday. Pretty safe compared to fire, police or military.
There are probably 100s of financial staff from plants and the auto industry that could do the job.
So for not as much as they do now.
Get real This is blatant theft or fraud. Or abuse at the highest level.
 
Last edited:
You may get what you pay for!

"I completely disagree. If you want people that can manage well, you have to pay them well."

Maybe you really agree. They got paid better than WELL and did we get value on the dollar? We got ripped off,
The reality of the matter is they did extremely poorly but it is a global issue also. However consider the times no time for bonuses especially BIG one on the public purse.
 
I agree that it probably wasn't the time for bonuses and I wouldn't have given them if I was in charge.
 
Silly me. I always thought that bonuses are supposed to be a "reward" of sorts for excelling and going over and above expectations, not an automatic entitlement for just having the job.
 
:previous: yup.

sort'a like -no, exactly like the tip at a restaurant.
 
Last edited:
More reaction

Backlash building to force CPP bosses to pay back bonuses


.
Government faces angry torrent after pension's dismal performance
May 30, 2009
RICHARD J. BRENNAN
OTTAWA BUREAU

OTTAWA – Public outrage is growing over the $7 million in bonuses paid to top executives of the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board despite losing $24 billion of taxpayers' money.
"We would fire them, no question in my mind," Diane Urquhart, a Mississauga financial analyst and one of several volunteer members on the United Church Pension Fund's investment committee, told the Star yesterday.
The church pension fund is one of the best run in Canada. Its investments lost 10.6 per cent of their value in the 2008-09 fiscal year, compared with 18.6 per cent for the Canadian Pension Plan.
The National Pensioners and Senior Citizens Federation are among those calling for the executives to pay back the money.
"We are angered by the news today that four top executives of the CPP Investment Board are receiving $1.1 (million) to $2.4 million of bonuses for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2009," Sheila Righi, the federation's second vice-president, said in a letter to federal Finance Minister Jim Flaherty.
"The CPP executives should pay back their fiscal 2009 bonuses."
The executives' total compensation was down about 30 per cent compared with the previous fiscal year.
In addition to the salaries and bonuses paid to the executives, the 15-member board of directors for the CPP fund receives almost $636,800 in remuneration annually.
The letter from the National Pensioners and Senior Citizens Federation contained seven points calling for greater transparency and policy changes, including that no bonuses should be paid in years where there are absolute losses in the CPP fund.
"This (the CPP Fund's) relative performance is hardly stellar and deserving of million-dollar-plus compensation for the CPP investment managers," Righi said in the letter.
CPP Investment Board chair Robert Astley, who receives an annual remuneration of $81,110, said in a letter to the Star that it is "misleading" to suggest the CPP fund's decline this year is due to bad investments.
"The primary factor affecting the fund's performance was the sharp decline in global capital markets during fiscal 2009. Like all investors, the CPP Fund was negatively impacted by the severe market turmoil but still matched the market-based benchmark return in one of the most trying years in the history of modern markets," he said.
Astley defended the compensation for its four top executives, saying that because the bonuses are based on a four-year rolling average they are actually being paid for past strong returns not one single year.
"This year's management compensation reflects the strong returns of 15.5 per cent in fiscal 2006 and 12.9 per cent in fiscal 2007, as well as the $5.3 billion in value-added returns above the market-based benchmark that our investment teams have generated over this period," he wrote.
New Democrat MP Jean Crowder (Nanaimo-Cowichan) points out that banking and corporate executives in the United States have been forced to pay back bonuses in the wake of the economic meltdown.
"So why not in Canada?" Crowder said.
"It's pretty tough to explain to workers, who've lost their jobs, why somebody who's managing their pension funds gets a bonus for doing a bad job. So I would say, `If you lose that kind of money, $24 billion, you need to have a penalty for it.'"
Conservative MP Ted Menzies told the Commons all federal agencies are expected to "do the best with taxpayers' money."
"The Canada Pension Plan Investment Board is an independent body, but it must be reasonable in its own compensation," said the parliamentary secretary to Flaherty.
Leo Kolivakis, a former senior investment analyst at the Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec and the Public Sector Pension Investment Board, said one of the reasons for the large loss is that operators of the $100 billion CPP fund take greater risks by investing in the volatile stock market.
"Ultimately a pension fund should be protecting the capital ... and limiting the downside risks," Kolivakis said.
"It is going to take them many years to reduce those losses."

:hell: :help:
 
In the old days the expectation of the employer was a fair day's wage for a fair day's work.
Another private sector concept was if you MADE more money for your employer (sold the most cars, signed a big contract) you got a percentage or it would be a combo of like a wage and a commision sorta.
So with this train of thought the CPP board of govenors (self serving) have the nerve to vote a bonus. HEY you get a bonus (key word bonus look it up{extra})when you perform so if you lost this year NO bonus, or imagine a CUT. It is happening with the CAW, Tell that to the poor pensioner who lives month by month.
This is NOT the Boards money it is all Canadians money they were appointed to safeguard and administer fair and equally. If you vote yourself a BIG share that is like stealing but it's OK you and your cronies voted and said it's OK. Not the people of Canada.
How much should they get paid. let's see Monday to Friday 9-5 if you want, paid travel, benefits, pension (HUGE or vote one in), Nice office, and plenty of staff. No shift work, weekends or work on a holiday. Pretty safe compared to fire, police or military.
There are probably 100s of financial staff from plants and the auto industry that could do the job.
So for not as much as they do now.
Get real This is blatant theft or fraud. Or abuse at the highest level.

What makes you think that?
 


Back
Top