• City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.

    City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.

    Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.

    The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.

    If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -
    report.gif
    in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.

Cities between regions

DBR96A

bnkhjsdlgj,sdgnsdkljvfjgl
To me, there are certain cities that are between regions, or that act as "gateway" cities from one region to another. Here are the cities I see as such...

PITTSBURGH: Northeast meets Midwest
WASHINGTON D.C.: Northeast meets South
LOUISVILLE: Midwest meets South
DENVER: Midwest meets West
DALLAS: South meets West
HOUSTON: South meets West
OKLAHOMA CITY: Midwest meets South meets West

Other cities I see with very slight influence from other regions are as follows...

ST. LOUIS: Midwestern city with a trace of Southern influence
KANSAS CITY: Midwestern city with a trace of Western influence
TULSA: Midwestern city with a trace of Southern and Western influence
NASHVILLE: Southern city with a trace of Midwestern influence
MEMPHIS: Southern city with a trace of Midwestern influence
LITTLE ROCK: Southern city with a trace of Midwestern influence

"Buffer zones" include...

- Western Pennsylvania
- Eastern Ohio
- Maryland
- Northern Virginia
- Southern West Virginia
- Kentucky
- Western and north-central Tennessee
- Extreme southern Illinois
- The southern third of Missouri
- The northern third of Arkansas
- Oklahoma
- Central Texas
- The western two-thirds of Kansas
- The western two-thirds of Nebraska
- The western two-thirds of the Dakotas
- Eastern Colorado
 
Buffalo and Rochester are definitely Northeast meets Midwest.

There's room for debate, but to me, Cleveland would also be in this category.
 
i don't know about houston being where the east meets the west but austin or san antonio perhaps.
 
New Haven, CT - looks very New England-y, has New England history, but commuter train to New York.

Where does southern Florida become South Florida? Orlando?

This is nitpicky, but Chicagoland straddles the Upper Midwest and the central Midwest. Lake County (IL) has the southernmost reaches of the northern lake country, whereas Will County or Kane County has a prairie landscape.

Interestingly, I've noticed that travelling west, New England ends right on the VT/NY border. Towns on either side look totally different.
 
Pittsburgh is the western frontier of the east coast. Houston however, is definitely southern. Denver is the start of the west coast though.
 
In Austin it's possible to find pine trees and cactus in the same metro. 21 miles east of Austin is Bastrop which sits slightly west of a patch of pine trees. These are known as the Lost Pines and you'll find two state parks there. Supposedly these were part of the same pine trees of East Texas, the very same ones that surround Houston 140 miles to the east. It's thought that a glacier sliced through Texas just east of the Lost Pines region and separated them forever from the pine trees of East Texas and farther to the east. They're the exact same species as those and grow wild there and no where else to the west near Austin. On Austin's west side and our western metro counties you can find cactus and almost desert like shrub and rocky terrain that feels more western or southwestern, though not exactly like Arizona. Sometimes parts of New Mexico remind me of the hilliest areas of Central Texas.

Besides the vegetation, topography wise Central Texas is divided. On the east side of the metro you have very gentle rolling hills. Really just coastal plain with some gentle rises. The elevation above sea level can be as low as 330 feet. To the west you have some hills which are quite large. You have small canyons, plateaus and hills. The elevation there ranges from 650 to 1,700 feet above sea level. The farther west you go the more extreme the topography gets of course. Some areas west of Austin reach over 2,000 feet in elevation. Honestly, if you drove into Austin from the west and then from the east with someone in the car that had never been to Austin, they probably wouldn't guess it's the same metro since the topography is so different.

San Antonio is even farther west than Austin is by about 30 miles. It may even be more pronounced there because to the west and northwest of San Antonio there are some really big hills and rugged areas. While to the south and southeast it can be downright flat. Just coastal plain.

Culturally Austin tends to be neither Southern or Western, it takes pieces of those but doesn't have a distinct feel of either of those. I guess stereotypically people would see it as "Western" since it's "Texan" but that isn't really a good fit. I can't remember the last time I saw someone with a cowboy hat on and southern accents sound funny. :)
 
Miami straddles the Caribbean and the US and in a broader sense is the gateway to the whole of Latin America for the world. It's definitely a border town.
 
At just over 6 million people, Dallas-Fort Worth is the largest metro area centrally located in the United States. Dallas is often said to be where the East ends & Fort Worth where the West begins.
 
I think the central parts of St. Louis are very eastern. Other parts are midwestern and the outer sections have a touch of southerness.
 
SJ wasn't always attached to the Bay Area. It used to be an isolated town whose "rival" city was Fresno. There were heated match-ups between the college football and minor league baseball teams. Now SJ's sports rivals are in Dallas, Los Angeles and the like. KNTV, the Bay Area NBC affiliate, used to broadcast south to Santa Cruz and Monterey instead of north to San Francisco and Oakland. It was just a second ABC affiliate for us caught in between. I think the Mercury News is still the "big" paper down there, even though it's trash.
 
Detroit - where Canada is south of the US.

Canadian media (CBC, CKLW, 89X) have a big influence over the area even if you never go to Canada, your 19th birthday is as big as your 21st, and the economy relies heavily on border trade.

Cincinnati is a fabulous example of North meets South - sometimes I feel the northern suburbs of Cincinnati are more southern than northern Kentucky.
 
There is nothing "midwestern" about any city in Tennessee or Arkansas. They're not even border states. Missouri and Kentucky, maybe.

Calgary is west coast meets prairie, sort of, though I'm not sure any of this works for Canada.
 
DALLAS: South meets West
HOUSTON: South meets West
OKLAHOMA CITY: Midwest meets South meets West

I'm not so sure. I lived in the Carolinas for a while.... BIG difference. Other than the occasional accent, there is not much southern culture in Texas. Aside from the general attitude of the people, I have seen none of the following signs of "southernness" in Texas.

The Bow Tie:
collections_bowties.jpg


The Sear Sucker suit:
seersucker_suit.jpg


The Boat Shoes: (Which I actually have from living in SC. They are pretty sweet.)
022406_boat_shoes.jpg
 
Miami straddles the Caribbean and the US and in a broader sense is the gateway to the whole of Latin America for the world. It's definitely a border town.

I agree. I'd say the same thing for San Francisco and the Orient, if not physically then as a gateway. Perhaps Vancouver as well.
Honolulu is also a gateway to the Orient and Oceana.
 
I think the central parts of St. Louis are very eastern. Other parts are midwestern and the outer sections have a touch of southerness.

Never been there but based on all the photos I've seen, that seems to be the best description of STL.
 
Pittsburgh is the western frontier of the east coast. Houston however, is definitely southern. Denver is the start of the west coast though.

I'd have to say Vegas is the eastern frontier of the west coast. Phoenix, SLC, and Denver are a different culture entirely.
 


Back
Top