Canada's Identity


This is more true than most people want to admit. Since the US has existed, as well as before that and one of the direct causes of its existence, Canada has specifically been "Not America".

1760's: Both British possessions, but Canada was French speaking, Catholic, and got along with the Natives for the most part. America was pretty much the opposite of all of those.

1780's: So many loyalists left the new USA (i.e. specifically want to be Not American) that Britain created a new province just for them. Treaty of Paris 1783, creation of Upper Canada in 1791. Ontario's existence is a direct cause-and-effect of people wanting to be "Not American".

1775, 1812: Actual warfare to prevent becoming America.

- Six Nations of the Grand River, the "Medecine Line", the Underground Railroad - people leavening America for Canada in order to have freedoms and rights they were denied in America.

All true, though out of necessity we obviously had to push and build the identity and nationhood beyond that binary relationship with our neighbours. And in retrospect should have tried a lot harder, as George Grant among others warned about in the 1960s.
 
This is more true than most people want to admit. Since the US has existed, as well as before that and one of the direct causes of its existence, Canada has specifically been "Not America".

1760's: Both British possessions, but Canada was French speaking, Catholic, and got along with the Natives for the most part. America was pretty much the opposite of all of those.

1780's: So many loyalists left the new USA (i.e. specifically want to be Not American) that Britain created a new province just for them. Treaty of Paris 1783, creation of Upper Canada in 1791. Ontario's existence is a direct cause-and-effect of people wanting to be "Not American".

1775, 1812: Actual warfare to prevent becoming America.

- Six Nations of the Grand River, the "Medecine Line", the Underground Railroad - people leavening America for Canada in order to have freedoms and rights they were denied in America.

Very true. Canada is "not America", and I am fine with that.

1780's: So many loyalists left the new USA (i.e. specifically want to be Not American) that Britain created a new province just for them. Treaty of Paris 1783, creation of Upper Canada in 1791. Ontario's existence is a direct cause-and-effect of people wanting to be "Not American".

Two new provinces actually - New Brunswick as well. Arriving Loyalists in the area wanted to govern themselves rather than be governed from distant Halifax. They essentially built Saint John and established a new capital and a new university in Fredericton (1785). UNB is the oldest English language university in Canada.

Like it or not, being "not America" is indeed one of our defining characteristics. The other two principle ones being the French fact in the country, and our ties to the monarchy. Other differences are mostly related to our national character.
 
I think "not the US" is certainly a part of it, But like most places our identity is also heavily shape by our geographic context and founding legacy. Our identity leans heavily on the themes of having large expanses of wilderness combined with low population density and on having colder, longer winters than most countries. We can see this in a lot of Canadian imagery including right down to the group of seven art.

And our identity is also heavily shaped by the tumultuous relationship between settlers and Indigenous peoples and by our complex feelings about immigration and diversity. The only real reason for the frequent comparison and contrast with the US is that it's larger and has a similar origin story based on Western European powers establishing a colonial presence from the east and spreading west with the most-spoken language in both being English. So we often have to draw a distinction there.
 
There isn't a universal identity, but that's fine. It's a federation, and works well enough.

Screenshot-20250110-124521.png
 
The "We're not Americans" SOUNDS like a jingle, but there's really more implied, when you consider what some of the Declaration of Independence stresses... namely the philosophy of self-reliance, independence and emphasis on PERSONAL achievements.

Canada, possibly due to it's more rugged terrain and sparse population, at least for it's first few centuries really REQUIRED a lot more of a community spirit. Cooperation before personal glory.

I think it expresses itself differently today... social programs, inclusiveness, politeness, enjoying nature... none of these are really part of the American DREAM, unless it serves an immediate purpose.

"In God We Trust" and "From Sea to Sea" don't have much in common.

"Play nice, follow the rules and get along" has often been an underlying vibe here. And that's not necessarily a bad thing.
 
The "We're not Americans" SOUNDS like a jingle, but there's really more implied, when you consider what some of the Declaration of Independence stresses... namely the philosophy of self-reliance, independence and emphasis on PERSONAL achievements.

Canada, possibly due to it's more rugged terrain and sparse population, at least for it's first few centuries really REQUIRED a lot more of a community spirit. Cooperation before personal glory.

I think it expresses itself differently today... social programs, inclusiveness, politeness, enjoying nature... none of these are really part of the American DREAM, unless it serves an immediate purpose.

"In God We Trust" and "From Sea to Sea" don't have much in common.

"Play nice, follow the rules and get along" has often been an underlying vibe here. And that's not necessarily a bad thing.

"Peace, order and good government" was actually the traditional counter-point to "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness".
 
COVID, Brexit, and Hydro Quebec have softened me. Also, I'm 43 now, best case scenario my life is half over. It's not really for me to decide NL's future anymore. That's for the youth.
 
Nothing wrong with "not-American" being a key part of our identity. That's very typical. Even the huge nation states have that to some extent and certainly being on the edge of super-power we are going to see that. We have a similar identity that developed both organically and from American influence.

There are a lot of parallels to Putin's claim about Ukraine in some of the 51st state rhetoric.
 
There are a lot of parallels to Putin's claim about Ukraine in some of the 51st state rhetoric.

Russian history is quite interesting. I do not profess to be any sort of an expert on it, but the Rus first started out in Kiev under Viking influences, followed by a diaspora and fragmentation. Ukrainians and Russians are cousins and have a generally mutually comprehensible language. In this sense, the current war can be considered a spat where big daddy Russia wants little brother Ukraine to return home, while Ukraine prefers to have his own apartment so he can keep on partying.

Lots of parallels there between Canada and the US. We're cousins too. We were thrown out of the house in 1783 and learned to live on our own. Now the USA wants family reunification. We like our independence and say not so fast..........
 
Russian history is quite interesting. I do not profess to be any sort of an expert on it, but the Rus first started out in Kiev under Viking influences, followed by a diaspora and fragmentation. Ukrainians and Russians are cousins and have a generally mutually comprehensible language. In this sense, the current war can be considered a spat where big daddy Russia wants little brother Ukraine to return home, while Ukraine prefers to have his own apartment so he can keep on partying.

Lots of parallels there between Canada and the US. We're cousins too. We were thrown out of the house in 1783 and learned to live on our own. Now the USA wants family reunification. We like our independence and say not so fast..........

I'd like to explore a bit more the idea that Canadians were thrown out of the American house after the Revolution.
 
Putting aside Quebec and French Canada, I'd say that English Canadians are held together by mostly shared values and a belief that "we are not American".

Within the larger English Canadian regions there is more of a cohesive identity.

For example, you know you're in Ontario when you drive through places that look like this, or this, or this, or this, or this.

This doesn't look like Western Canada, Quebec, Atlantic Canada, the Midwestern US or Upstate New York.

It's not pretty; I wish the iconic Ontario cityscape was something more desirable, like the standard Tuscan cityscape, but it is what it is.
 
Putting aside Quebec and French Canada, I'd say that English Canadians are held together by mostly shared values and a belief that "we are not American".

Within the larger English Canadian regions there is more of a cohesive identity.

For example, you know you're in Ontario when you drive through places that look like this, or this, or this, or this, or this.

This doesn't look like Western Canada, Quebec, Atlantic Canada, the Midwestern US or Upstate New York.

It's not pretty; I wish the iconic Ontario cityscape was something more desirable, like the standard Tuscan cityscape, but it is what it is.

I think you're being a bit uncharitable to your own province. Classic Ontario also looks like this:

https://www.google.ca/maps/@44.5898...try=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI1MDEwNy4wIKXMDSoASAFQAw==

Also, those ugly commercial boulevards can also be found almost identically in parts of Halifax, Edmonton and Winnipeg. (And to some degree in Quebec but with some slight differences and of course signs in French.)

And the prettier classic Ontario vernacular is something you can find in places like Winnipeg and Fredericton too.
 
I think you're being a bit uncharitable to your own province...
Also, those ugly commercial boulevards can also be found almost identically in parts of Halifax, Edmonton and Winnipeg.

But are they lined with slab highrises from the 1960s and 70s? That's very Ontario, and it can be found in cities big and small. Of course, the buildings are taller and more numerous in Toronto and Ottawa, but they exist even in small towns.
 
I'd like to explore a bit more the idea that Canadians were thrown out of the American house after the Revolution.

Yeah the family metaphor breaks down. More like the US left the house and we decided to stay there before eventually and gradually moving into the guest house. Even if the guest house is closer to the brother who moved out than the main house (UK).

The war of 1812 is the US trying to force us back into the fold. 30ish years later almost exactly as many years as Ukraine was free of Russia actually. I mean we were still British so it's pretty far from an exact analogy. Nevermind invasion was standard operating procedure at the time.
 
Ukrainians and Russians are cousins and have a generally mutually comprehensible language. In this sense, the current war can be considered a spat where big daddy Russia wants little brother Ukraine to return home, while Ukraine prefers to have his own apartment so he can keep on partying.
Kinda gross downplaying and simplification of Europe's biggest War since WW2

We're coming up on year 3 of Russia's War/Invasion of Ukraine. There's hundreds of thousands dead, wounded, rendered disabled/amputees on both sides with no end in sight.

The fight to keep Ukrainian sovereignty and "We are not Russian (despite commonalities and cross border family ties) and don't want to be part of Russia again" is strong.
 
I'd like to explore a bit more the idea that Canadians were thrown out of the American house after the Revolution.

You're aware of tarring and feathering, property confiscation, lynchings, forced migrations etc, right????

Some Loyalists were definitely shown the door. Other fled in panic. Some just felt alienated from the new regime. They were refugees one and all. They found a home north of the new border.
 


Back
Top