Big day for big developments


Haliguy

New member
Big day for big developments
Advisory committee to decide next step for pair of proposed downtown Halifax highrises
By AMY PUGSLEY FRASER City Hall Reporter
Mon. Apr 21 - 5:19 AM

The skyline of downtown Halifax could look a little different in the months ahead if two big developments going before a city hall advisory committee tonight get the go-ahead.

The projects still need to go before a public hearing. The developments include a 21-storey condo from Halkirk for the south side of their Brewery Market property and a 19-storey W.M. Fares group residential building slated for the corner of Brenton and South Park streets.

But approval at tonight’s meeting of the downtown Halifax planning advisory committee could get them to that step.

The committee assists council by reviewing projects to ensure they fit the downtown planning strategy, Coun. Dawn Sloane (Halifax Downtown) explained in an interview Sunday.

And although the city has drafted new rules for downtown development through its HRM By Design project, the area is still governed by the old guidelines until council approves and implements the new plan, Ms. Sloane said.

"We have to go by the old rules until we actually have the public hearing on HRM By Design," she explained.

The two projects are attracting a lot of feedback, the councillor said.

"As usual, when it comes to development in downtown Halifax, you hear for and against," she said.

Her comments echo public sentiment at separate meetings held last year to unveil both projects.

The Halkirk development, which will be situated just south of the com-pany’s recently completed Salter’s Gate hotel and condo project, drew split comments at a meeting last fall at city hall.

The $30-million development drew oohs and aahs for its design and architectural elements but heritage advocates said its location, across the street from historic Government House, was not the right place for a high tower.

Meanwhile, the meeting in December to publicize the W.M. Fares project took in similar comments about heritage and new design.

People living near the downtown corner said another high tower, like its Park Victoria neighbour across Brenton Place, would be detrimental to the neighbourhood.

That 22-storey building, erected in 1962, ruined the neighbourhood with its wind and shadows, said some downtown homeowners.

Cesar Saleh, an engineer with the Fares group, said the building is custom-designed for the site and includes stepped-up effects at the fifth, 13th and 19th storeys so the building gets narrower as it gets taller.

The building is also attracting heritage-related attention, Ms. Sloane said.

"I’m hearing that the building is close to Schmidtville, and there are some concerns," she said.

The area, bordered by Spring Garden Road, Dresden Row and Morris and Queen streets, forms an historic neighbourhood that dates from the late 1700s.

( [email protected])
 
I checked the comments after this article in the herald.. so far 3 in favour..1 against. Looks like my fellow forumers may be having their say :D

By the way, the negative comment was "build them in burnside" by billp. Of course both these are residential towers.. not sure about you guys, but I have no interest to LIVE in Burnside. Lol
 
I really like both towers. There's some question about how attractive the Brewery tower would be given Salter's Gate but the old designs I've seen look slightly better and have probably been revised.

The area around Bishop/Hollis/Lower Water is mostly nice now with the exception of the Southern end of the Brewery block, so I'm pretty eager to see this development go forward. I think the tower would help to tie in the downtown with the residential area to the South since it is significantly shorter than the Maritime Centre. The added retail and commercial space will complement Bishop's Landing nicely, and eventually with the Centennial development we should see a cohesive medium density residential district emerge out of what used to be parking lots.

Something else to keep in mind is that the developers have already cut down the height from 27 storeys. A 21 storey tower is already a compromise, although of course some will try to forget that they've already been given concessions...

As for South Park and Brenton, I am not very worried about it getting municipal approval. It's surrounded by other highrises and would be permitted under HRM by Design. It also looks like a high end building and includes some badly needed retail space. Of course, it could still be appealed to the URB, but I wouldn't be that surprised if it weren't.
 
Here's the Halkirk development site from HRM by Design:

original.jpg


South Park and Brenton, from the HRM report:

original.jpg
 
Anyone want to place their bets on which of these(or neither or both) will ultimately be built?

If I had to take a guess, I'd say the brewery development wont be, but the south park st tower will get through without a hitch.
 
Is the Keith Hall restoration still included in the Halkirk development?

Second question, what kind of timeframe are we looking at until construction starts if they get through this process?
 
Based on the last report I saw, the Keith Hall restoration is still included. They also plan to build a four storey building called Halkirk House between Keith Hall and Weir House. There are plans for another building on the former Longshoremen's site as third phase.

Keith Hall could be a really nice building. The restoration is very badly needed. I like the idea of filling the gap where that "farmer's market" gate is as well. In the 1860s this stretch of Hollis was an uninterrupted row of elaborate houses.

I think both developments have a pretty good chance of being built. Not sure how serious the "Schmidtville" comments are since they sound vague and the building itself isn't really even adjacent to the little neighbourhood. Most people I would imagine recognize that the area South of Spring Garden needs to be filled in so that it is similar to the North side, which has remained attractive despite intensive development in recent years.

The Halkirk building is a bit trickier because of Government House. Some people will definitely want to appeal, but then again the developers seem quite serious - this is their second attempt to develop the lot and they successfully completed Salter's Gate.
 
Is the Keith Hall restoration still included in the Halkirk development?

I sure hope so. It's so sad to see it covered up in scaffolding and tarps and plywood. Of course, they cut down from 27 to 21 stories... so they may be working with different financial projections now.

That's one point people often miss... i.e... when ROI goes down, other things go down with it. The first thing to go is probably design quality. So you know... congratulations... you got the "human scale" building you wanted... but it looks like a block of cheese. Of course... this is just a theory. I'm not a businessman or a developer... so I could just be talking s*it.
 
I sure hope so. It's so sad to see it covered up in scaffolding and tarps and plywood. Of course, they cut down from 27 to 21 stories... so they may be working with different financial projections now.

That's one point people often miss... i.e... when ROI goes down, other things go down with it. The first thing to go is probably design quality. So you know... congratulations... you got the "human scale" building you wanted... but it looks like a block of cheese. Of course... this is just a theory. I'm not a businessman or a developer... so I could just be talking s*it.

No, I think you got it about right. People forget that developers do have to make money and need the return on investment.
 
The South Park St proposal got through though not without some ridiculous obstructionism from Bev Miller. She is the chair of that committee too, which is totally absurd:

http://thechronicleherald.ca/Metro/1051248.html

The 66-metre proposed height for the South Park Street development was the biggest concern for Beverly Miller, acting chairwoman of the District 12 planning advisory committee. Ms. Miller was the only member to reject a staff recommendation

The Fares Group proposal does not meet municipal regulations that restrict building height to 14 metres at the site.

"I have trouble with staff recommending that because at the public information meeting (last year) there was considerable opposition from the people who live in Schmidtville area against a huge building going into their essentially low-rise neighbourhood," Ms. Miller said.

"This is a neighbourhood question and a neighbourhood preservation question and just what is suitable in a particular neighbourhood."

Schmidtville, bordered by Spring Garden Road, Dresden Row, Morris and Queen streets, forms an historic neighbourhood that dates from the late 1700s.

Other committee members did not support Ms. Miller’s motion to reject the proposal.


Meanwhile, the Halkirk proposal did not get dealt with last night -- they ran out of time. :rolleyes:
 
To say that the area is primarily a low rise community is one of the most absurd things I've ever heard. Outside of the downtown, its the most built up area of HRM. Is she blind??

But on a better note, I'm very glad to see the proposal make it through the committee.
 
The Halkirk delay is part of why these things take years. Because they ramble and then don't want to stay late they delay things by weeks at a time (this happens for each committee then consultations then council then maybe the URB ...). To be honest I don't even know why they have this committee when there are public consultations. Basically the PAC step seems to be councillors saying "well, let's see what the public says in the consultation" - fundamentally it seems wrong when they torpedo developments before hearing public input - plus Bev Miller complaining about how things are too tall and don't fit in with whatever picture of the area she's imagined.

Maybe PAC members should be given a short multiple choice quiz about facts surrounding each proposal and if they fail it they should not be allowed to speak. :rolleyes:

This site is: (a) surrounded only by families living in houses in a wonderful heritage community, (b) next to a 400+ unit, 22 storey building, (c) located in a critical watershed area that must be protected, (d) none of the above.

Anyway, pleasantly surprised to see that they're talking about moving the houses on the South Park site.
 
Moving the houses was an idea that I had earlier, is this actually being proposed?

I think it just makes sense, those houses can be used to fill in gaps in other places in the city that need authentic heritage homes to maintain the look.
 
Yes, it's being proposed and yes, it's a good idea. No idea where they'd put the houses or how much would actually be moved.

One interesting thing to note is that this is the kind of thing that only becomes affordable if you're building a 19 storey highrise. If these houses were being replaced by the supposedly ideal four storey building with 20 units there'd be no room in the budget for anything but demolition.

Those who are *truly* interested in preserving the city's neighbourhoods should be working with developers to use some of their profits for preservation. The HRM should have density bonus schemes for heritage preservation and investment in the public realm.
 
Good to hear things are happening with these two developments. I really like both of them.

The HRM by Design guidelines do have density bonuses that can allow a few more floors in most places. They are awarded through incorporation of low income housing, public realm improvements and heritage preservations measures.
 


Back
Top