Atlanta3000
New member
Guys, no. And the point wasn't to make Atlanta "look worse". The post was entirely neutral to positive and begging for construction photos, but of course this particular thread in general gets its panties in a wad over the smallest things. Some posters thought Atlanta was on the verge of needing to convert some single family neighborhoods to higher density as "space was running out" and "no more developable sites". Seattle officially is contemplating such rezoning, so the comparison was made because Seattle is at the opposite end of predominantly single family residential cities. It wasn't made to "make Atlanta look bad", it was only used to say, look, this appears to be the point at which such rezoning makes sense, and Atlanta is not close to there yet. Holy smokes you guys...just embarrassing.
Anyway, for facts, to clear the air:
http://www.cushmanwakefield.com/~/m...Atlanta_Americas_MarketBeat_Office_Q12015.pdf
http://www.cushmanwakefield.com/~/m...lliance_Marketbeat_Office_Suburban_Q12015.pdf
So Seattle is actually like 47 million sf in a more contiguous and confined area (with another 4 million UC) while Atlanta is like 32 million sf (with 0 sf UC until NCR pulls the trigger and starts on ~500k sf) spread between Downtown and Midtown. Realistically, Buckhead is equivalent to Bellevue in Seattle, which is certainly not part of Seattle's CBD and is a separate market. Because Atlanta is just that spread out with so many more sizable submarkets beyond the Perimeter, big real estate brokerages like Cushman Wakefield just consider Buckhead as part of CBD, which is where the 50 million sf comes from. But please, that is not "CBD" for all intents and purposes. That'd be like Century City and all points in between being considered downtown/CBD for LA.
The point still stands that in an area of Seattle that would be equivalent to Downtown up through Coke Building over into Midtown, there is about 150% the office space, and rising rapidly with new construction pushing to close to 200%. So my initial post was about dead on balls accurate for Atlanta and only slightly exaggerated Seattle.
In terms of hotel rooms, Seattle's CBD and Atlanta's CBD (not including Buckhead) have about 15K rooms each (which is what I said, and then you guys went ballistic on this point AND SAID THE SAME DAMN THING). Atlanta's downtown alone has 12K, I believe. So they are very equivalent in that respect (which is what I said...no need to come in with articles trying to then prove Metro Atlanta, in the guise of "Atlanta", has more hotel rooms than NYC - just another example of the ridiculousness of some of you posters). For the record, Chicago, SF, DC, and Boston each have 25K-50K rooms in their general CBD areas (or much smaller city limits with vast bulk right downtown). NYC has about 115K in its city limits (not metro) including a few recent hotel construction booms. And almost all of those are in Manhattan. Only in "Atlanta's world" does Atlanta have more hotel rooms. Why should it?
In terms of downtown residents, "official counts" are so arbitrary because definitions of downtown are so stretched, and lower density southern boom towns tend to stretch them the most as they try to push their "downtown rebirths", but DT Seattle is so far ahead of basically every city in America save for a few. In terms of downtown residents and downtown population, it's even ahead of San Francisco, unless you count like Tenderloin, SOMA, Chinatown, and North Beach "downtown", which I am not. So while you guys might want to find a local Atlanta boost count, the fact remains if Atlanta were close to or ahead of Seattle, it would be notable in this country for its downtown population and it's not. Midtown Atlanta still feels a little less "busy" and less populated than San Diego's, and about equivalent to Denver's. Both great cities on the rise, but not really yet all that notable for having a "downtown" population like Chicago has a downtown population or Center City Philly does. Seattle feels like it's closer to Chicago/Philly than Atlanta/Denver.
I don't want to sound like I'm bashing (bc I'm not), because the whole point was something different. Even in Seattle they aren't quite yet at the point of emergency, needing to absolutely rezone. There are still vacant lots and existing development sites that can be densified. But they are close enough where they are contemplating it and discussing it, since Seattle is another predominantly single family resident city. It's probably the most urban/dense predominantly single family resident city. Atlanta is probably still one of the least dense single family resident cities and has a longgg way to go before people will start and need to start contemplating opening up some single family neighborhoods to densification.
No need to get all up in arms, Seattle was only brought up since they are actually trying to rezone some single family areas into multifamily, so I thought that was what spurred the sentiment for Atlanta.
Atlanta has 93K hotels rooms, therefore I believe your number for hotel rooms in Downtown Atlanta are wildly inaccurate. Also, Buckhead is only 4 to 7 miles from Midtown Atlanta with no geographical obstruction. Bellevue is 12 miles from Seattle across lake Washington. Therefore, if you include Buckhead in Atlanta's CBD, the numbers are not that different except for new office construction. Not to mention, our taller buildings are much taller than Seattle's.
http://loyaltytraveler.boardingarea.com/2013/10/09/top-ten-u-s-cities-by-hotel-rooms/