ATLANTA | Development Thread V


Status
Not open for further replies.
I think that is for a variety of reasons. A lot of the easier lots to develop on have been bought, developed, or are in the process. Other lots are either not for sale currently or simply priced too high to make certain projects economically feasible. I also think Atlanta is in a unique situation compared to perhaps some of its peer cities where there aren't a lot of areas you can have high density urban infill. For example, you're not going to tear down Ansley Park, Midtown, Home Park, etc. which is where the "natural" development would spread. So this limits growth.

I wish I knew what you meant by "tear down Midtown" for high density infill. You are about 40 years too late for that because high density development spread to Midtown long ago. That's why all those high rise condos, high rise offices, and apartment complexes are there...
 
I wish I knew what you meant by "tear down Midtown" for high density infill. You are about 40 years too late for that because high density development spread to Midtown long ago. That's why all those high rise condos, high rise offices, and apartment complexes are there...

He means the single family home part of Midtown south of 10th and east of Piedmont. That would probably be a high density area especially with it's street grid and small street widths, but....it's protected because it's a historic area.

I think Home Park needs to be rebuilt with 6 story apartment buildings...I see nothing special about the neighborhood that warrants protecting it when it can be a high density neighborhood that has easy access to Atlantic Station, Midtown, and the Westside neigborhoods. In fact, right now, it's a high crime area.

Atlanta protects the single family home neighborhoods a little too much and in the end, it's going to drive neighborhood prices through the roof and make them very unaffordable because the limited amount of units in the city due to how much land single family homes actually take up compared to apartment blocks.
 
Aspire Waterworks update: Nearly what, a year in? It looks like they're still doing basic site work. I don't think it's stalled because there's still equipment there, so it must either have a ridiculously long schedule or something went wrong.

Good thing zoning doesn't dictate architectural styles.
I don't know why someone kept perpetuating this lie otherwise.

Of course zoning can dictate architectural styles. Savannah does it in their historic district.

I wish I knew what you meant by "tear down Midtown" for high density infill. You are about 40 years too late for that because high density development spread to Midtown long ago. That's why all those high rise condos, high rise offices, and apartment complexes are there...

Hate to speak for him but I asume he meant the neighborhood of Midtown--a.k.a. Historic Midtown--where the single family homes are. The area most people think of when they hear "Midtown" is actually several neighborhoods, only one of which is actually called Midtown. The neighborhood with the highrises is Midtown Core. Confused enough yet? :)
 
I guess I needed to be more specific, but yes, "Historic Midtown". The rich, single family neighborhoods on either side of Peachtree Street from Midtown to Buckhead, Ansley Park, & Historic Midtown limit the urban growth of Atlanta. I'm not implying this a good or bad thing, that is purely subjective, but I think it goes a long way in explaining Ant's initial question. These neighborhoods force dense development in a few nodes, driving up land prices, and limiting what is economically feasible on these sites. The places where there is a lot of available land for more urban growth all have their own challenges, so projects will need to be carefully vetted and thus won't come at such a rapid pace as the "easier" sites did.
 
I think Home Park needs to be rebuilt with 6 story apartment buildings...I see nothing special about the neighborhood that warrants protecting it when it can be a high density neighborhood that has easy access to Atlantic Station, Midtown, and the Westside neigborhoods. In fact, right now, it's a high crime area.

Atlanta protects the single family home neighborhoods a little too much and in the end, it's going to drive neighborhood prices through the roof and make them very unaffordable because the limited amount of units in the city due to how much land single family homes actually take up compared to apartment blocks.

Agree. Take a wrecking ball to Home Park--it contributes nothing to the city besides Antico Pizza and cheap apartments. Save the smattering of historic structures, redevelop the rest. No need to stop at 6 stories necessarily, though.
 
Agree. Take a wrecking ball to Home Park--it contributes nothing to the city besides Antico Pizza and cheap apartments. Save the smattering of historic structures, redevelop the rest. No need to stop at 6 stories necessarily, though.

I completely agree with the last part especially with its proximity to GT.
 
Actually the portion of Home Park north of 14th has been improving lately. A lot of it is still iffy though. If zoning allows it those parts will probably be developed eventually but it will be awhile with the lack of transit and the number of vacant/underdeveloped lots on the other side of the Connector.

Piedmont Park and MARTA have probably defined Midtown's development patterns more than anything.
 
Hate to speak for him but I asume he meant the neighborhood of Midtown--a.k.a. Historic Midtown--where the single family homes are. The area most people think of when they hear "Midtown" is actually several neighborhoods, only one of which is actually called Midtown. The neighborhood with the highrises is Midtown Core. Confused enough yet? :)

Wasn't a big portion of the highrise area in Midtown once single-family homes too?
 
Wasn't a big portion of the highrise area in Midtown once single-family homes too?

I believe by the time 1980 rolled around most of that was long-gone, and was replaced by a lot of lowrise buildings, surface lots, and blight.

Kind of amazing how far Midtown has come, actually.
 
Good thing zoning doesn't dictate architectural styles.
I don't know why someone kept perpetuating this lie otherwise.

The requirement was NOT a zoning requirement, it was a design requirement actually tied to the deed. It was self-imposed by the master developer of One Atlantic Center. A single owner had all four corners under control at one time and and master planned called for three shorter gothic revival towers and one tall one. The idea was that the composition would resembler a gothic cathedral.

I'd imagine all four current owners signed paperwork to remove the requirement.
 
I believe by the time 1980 rolled around most of that was long-gone, and was replaced by a lot of lowrise buildings, surface lots, and blight.

Kind of amazing how far Midtown has come, actually.

True, but even prior to that...commercial building encroached into residential areas just off Peachtree and completely altered the area. It's still happening on the edge of Historic Midtown along Piedmont. Not that it isn't a good thing, but it can happen so slowly that no one notices until the houses are gone.
 
The requirement was NOT a zoning requirement, it was a design requirement actually tied to the deed. It was self-imposed by the master developer of One Atlantic Center. A single owner had all four corners under control at one time and and master planned called for three shorter gothic revival towers and one tall one. The idea was that the composition would resembler a gothic cathedral.

I'd imagine all four current owners signed paperwork to remove the requirement.

I've seen the model for the master plan and knew the intent was to originally have 2 more "mini-me" buildings. But my point was that the idea floating about a "requirement" - even if it were in the deed from 30+ years ago - wasn't really a dead-set requirement but more of an intent/request when they were trying to build IBM's regional HQ in Midtown.
 
I'm glad Stubby was the only offshoot. Everything about it is cheap mimicry. Every little detail on stubby is a simplified cheaper variant of OAC's details.
 
This might be old news for some, but I noticed yesterday after exiting the Midtown Marta station that the garage at 33 Peachtree Place is officially open and being used.

The lot next door was empty this morning. Looks like work should start very soon on the second half of this lot.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Back
Top