A-town
Born and raised
Being naive is comical. My ex-girlfriend who is a lawyer here in the city, is from NY(Manhattan). She's between 25-35. Though I perso love floor to ceiling windows, she's prefers the opposite. She loves windows, but feels that walls gives a more high end look and feel. She's not a fan of all glass towers. There are plenty of people who have that same opinion.
As far as Sovereign, St. Regis, and the Mandarin, it is absurd to compare them. In real estate, you have to nderstand that the price point of The Mandarin and St. Regis will typically take much longer to sell. Also, the price point of Sovereign did drop, which opened the market to a lot more buyers. Keep in mind that the W Hotel Residences downtown which is a shiny glass tower, has had an extremely hard time trying to sell those units.
I can understand why your ex would feel that way. Most of the buildings in NY are traditional. But I think the 25-35 demographic in Atlanta is definitely leaning towards the glass towers.
I don't think it's absurd to compare these towers. St. Regis and Mandarin are more expensive than Sovereign in that they both start in the $2,000,000 range. But they all have several units that are priced the same. Not to mention Sovereign almost has as many units as the Mandarin and St. Regis combined and it still out sold them. And I don't recall Sovereign ever dropping it's prices. In fact they did the opposite, Sovereign was originally suppose to start at $500,000 but it was increased to a million. And the W had a hard time selling because of the neighborhood and the fact that a one bedroom was priced the same as a two bedroom in other parts of the city. So it wasn't the type of building that slowed sales, it was price and location.
Take a look at the site plan
http://livablebuckhead.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/1000-Park-Avenue-LBI-3-4-2015.pdf
I think they did the best they could considering the topology of the land, perserving the views for the 40 story condo beside it and limiting the shadows cast on the Million $ townhomes and single family homes across the street. But to argue that Skyhouse could teach this project a lesson, is down right stupidity. At least Wood Partners is putting the parking garage below grade to the physical structure and not an external parking deck (that always looks like shit). Which is how parking is done on higher-end projects.
No, it's stupid to ignore market trends and take what I said out of context.