This project is so terribly out of place, it hurts. However, in Downtown's case, anything built is a step forward. Not sure where y'all are seeing retail for this project because it seems there will be zero.
I've lived downtown for 7 years and I LOVE this project. IMO it's the most exciting project that is on the drawing board! Do I wish it was 80 stories - yes, do I wish it had retail - yes. But that area of downtown needs residential so bad, and the existing lots are so crappy looking (these aren't just bare surface lots, they are old shitty looking surface lots) that this can only be viewed as a win. If these sell out or does well it makes it possible to get the tower and grocery store we all want.
Something is never better than nothing. Shit begets shit. Sorry for the language Ladies!
Tell me why it makes sense for Post to build a 19 Story high-rise above 7 parking levels one block from single family houses in Buckhead (I live on Longleaf Drive), a 23 story high-rise in Midtown, but people are excited Post is proposing a 5 story development in a high-rise district in downtown Atlanta?
Atlanta3000, that original pre-recession Post proposal also included an aloft Hotel, which has now located across the street.
I'm sure if you wanted to be an equity partner with Post on this development, they may reconsider their plans. That's about the only way "expecting and demanding more" could be accomplished.
These are absolutely hideous, nasty surface lots this will replace. Bring it on - and when they rapidly fill up, the other blocks in the neighborhood can support higher and denser development.
With all do respect atlantaguy, I am resident of Atlanta, a taxpayer of the County of Fulton and someone that would fall into the top 5% of taxpayers in income and property taxes for this area. I believe I have earned the right to state an opinion without being an equity partner in this development....thank you very much!
Well, how nice for you!
Then just exactly how do you suggest that we "demand more"? I can certainly understand expecting more, but let's face facts. These nasty blocks are a drag on North Downtown/Allen Plaza.
I would much rather see this get built versus holding out for something 'better' that may be years away.
Interesting article on "Optimal Building Height" I came across recently.
I struggle to understand people's complaints. This project is eating up multiple blocks of surface street parking, bringing active uses to many of the roads (ground level entrances and what appears to be retail along COP Drive), and bringing 400+ residents downtown. Despite some remarks, this is not a "high rise" district nor is it filled with high density or demand (considering this is the first residential project downtown in how long, I think that goes without saying). The museums and attractions across the street are sprawling single story attractions, the condos on W. Peachtree are 7 stories tall, caddy-corner is a neighborhood mostly comprised of two to three story townhomes / apartments, there's a stand alone Waffle House down the road, a Best-Western Hotel closer to Peachtree that's 4 stories tall, and I could go on and on.
Most high rises are vertical cul-de-sacs, meaning they can be very harmful to the urban environment. Look at Post Alexander, which some of you seem to be lauding. It's an impersonal high rise, on top of a parking deck, that does nothing to activate the street. There's a reason Buckhead is so "dead" in regards to urban activity. It's because they're all about high rises and not about the urban environment and I find it amusing that so many that want a lively city would seek to mimic that. I understand towers are neat, but towers aren't the solution to everything. Look at a city like Paris. Would you argue that any of it's low rise residential buildings aren't good enough? No, it's a great city, precisely because it has tons of low rise residential. Atlanta's issue isn't space. We have tons of space and we need to fill so we don't have all these vacant lots and underused real estate to make neighborhoods more inviting and active. This is exactly what this development does.
I would take this over any of the other Post proposals that have been put forth so far. This is perfect for the area, despite some people's illusions.
The project is what it is and nothing is going to change it except for the people approving it or the people developing it.