ATL_J
New member
I agree, for the most part, but you speak from an architect's perspective, which no offense, is almost never realistic.
I speak from a construction and architectural perspective with a development education and while I under the gist of your points, and I understand the amenities argument, etc. you continue to equate quality design with price. That is wrong. I'm not implying we need an aggressive Gehry like structure to be "quality" design, I'm just asking for something not a garden-style apartment design with EIFS and faux-brick and stone.
"First of all there isn't a lot of room to be aggressive with design and materials..."
Assuming the owner allows, there is plenty of room to be "aggressive" with the design within budget limitations. That's the architect's job and that is not limited by monetary value. It's limited by creativity and working within budget constraints. What we have here is simply boring, uninspired design with poor material selection. The architect probably had a lot of experience doing generic apartment complexes, the developer wanted something like that, easy enough, they did that. This doesn't mean going in a different direction would have costs them anymore.
I understand you're not going to get "good materials", but again, good materials are subjective and don't drive design. Expensive materials = / = good design and good design can be achieved by being creative with what you have to work with. I also understand they have to include certain elements, like a parking deck, etc. That's not my complaint at all. I'm aware of where Atlanta is and what needs to be included to drive a development.