ATLANTA | Development Thread V


Status
Not open for further replies.
1. While it's true there are a lot of transplants in Atlanta, both the Braves and Falcons do fine (Braves attendance and Falcons attendance are generally average for the US)

2. What does the lack of MARTA connectivity to Turner field have to do with the future Falcon's stadium? The stadium will almost certainly be walking distance from several different MARTA stops.

3. Perhaps we should spend some money and help improve these neighborhoods then as part of any new stadium deal (this has been discussed quite a bit).

I'm not going to go ahead and rehash old things I've already said, but I would like to talk about your assumption that Atlanta could not support an MLS team.

1) Atlanta does decent enough in supporting those teams as Clexmond pointed out. It's not as a dire situation as you try to convey. The support for baseball, basketball or football has nothing to do with the support of soccer however. While transients bring preexisting loyalties from the established sport leagues, the MLS is fairly new and the majority of people do not have a preexisting loyalty to another MLS team.

2) The stadium will have access to MARTA.

3) The stadium would be downtown.

Thank you both. Anyone that thinks Atlanta doesn't support its teams (amidst decades of disappointments) apparently doesn't go to games: the Hawks game last night was packed, and that was against the Pacers of all teams. Also, pro sports belong downtown, not in the burbs, which would double the travel time for fans south and west of town. It's interesting how people in the burbs complain about the lack of transit near the sports venues, but then say the venues should be in the burbs...which have no MARTA rail. :shrug:
 
Sorry, but there's no way ATL can support an MLS team. Atlanta is barely supporting its existing professional teams (Hawks, Falcons, Braves) and has a history of average to poor game attendance. Look at all the forces to reckon with:
1) Atlanta is a very transient town. There are too many northern transplants that bring their team allegiances with them and could care less about the local sports scene.
2) Metro Atlanta is extremely spread out and car oriented, therefore getting to a game downtown is a major pain in the ass for sports fans. And where do the majority of Metro Atlanta residents live? Thats right, the suburbs. Only the most dedicated, die-hard fans will make the effort to go downtown to watch a game. It doesn't help either that the geniouses who planned the Olympic Stadium located it 1/2 mile away from the closest MARTA station. Turner Field is already far away from its fan base and in a bad part of town (see #3), so you'd think planners would at least put a MARTA station in the Turner Field plaza to give fans a break.
3) The powers that be will demand any future MLS or NFL stadium to be downtown - or in other words, as far away and as inaccessible a place as is physically possible for the vast majority of the fan base (who live in the suburbs). And that new sports venue will probably be in a shady neighborhood no less - and why wouldn't it? All the other venues are snuggled up next to shady neighborhoods (Vine City, Peoplestown anyone?). Walk just 3 blocks east of Turner Field on a Wednesday night after a poorly-attended game. Sports patrons shouldn't feel progressively more endangered the further they walk from the stadium, but thats the reality.

No, an MLS expansion in Atlanta is a horrible idea. Until transplants start adopting their local teams and stadiums are built where the fanbase is, Atlanta will never be a place where sports franchises thrive long term.

A terribly misinformed post overall...but if you're going to use a word like "geniuses" to make your shallow point then you should make sure you spell it correctly.
 
100 6th Street Site Work

Tree removal & demo is taking place this week... Things should really start moving once the new year rolls around. Regardless of the bland design, I'm very excited to see another tower going up here in Midtown!

C6CE2395-4A6F-4C7B-9FE1-C6EC53D12C2A-10882-0000124DF6BB8337.jpg


7C30168F-4D99-4700-B050-71CCFDCC15BD-10882-0000124DF2C5EDC6.jpg


10D491BD-4166-495E-AF33-A448E67DBCAB-10882-0000124DEC78FC96.jpg
 
Those pictures don't show the true beauty and grace of the massive concrete parking deck next to the building!

e8a294e4.jpg

That is absolutely awful! I guess the Midtown Alliance was asleep on this one. How could this come to be? I can see one possible way to mitigate such an affront: plant kudzu all around the garage's perimeter and let it take over. ;)


:(
 
Those pictures don't show the true beauty and grace of the massive concrete parking deck next to the building!

e8a294e4.jpg

I didn't realize how awful this deck was. How on Earth did this thing get approved? I though Midtown zoning regs wouldn't allow an enormous monstrosity like this.
 
By the way what is going on with Civil Rights Museum ??? are they doing anything ??

I'm personally over the Civil Rights Museum. The original design was beautiful and full of symbolism. The new design looks like an earth-pimple.

I understand the design was changed so that the museum could open debt-free, but I don't think a museum dedicated to civil rights, in the birthplace of civil rights is a place that should be done cheaply. In 10 years no one will say "Wow. They opened-debt free." But they will say "Man, this could have been so much better."
 
Thank you both. Anyone that thinks Atlanta doesn't support its teams (amidst decades of disappointments) apparently doesn't go to games: the Hawks game last night was packed, and that was against the Pacers of all teams. Also, pro sports belong downtown, not in the burbs, which would double the travel time for fans south and west of town. It's interesting how people in the burbs complain about the lack of transit near the sports venues, but then say the venues should be in the burbs...which have no MARTA rail. :shrug:
Hey I'm all for building MARTA into the suburbs. I voted for TSPLOST as most of you did and I wanted a light rail line in Cobb County (where I live). If a stadium was built closer to the fans then absolutely there should be a MARTA line serving it. Central Perimeter seems the logical choice for building a new Falcons or MLS stadium. Its centrally located, has excellent highway access, has a MARTA line, and is closer to the fan base. I read a while back that the center of population in Metro Atlanta is actually very close to where Perimeter Mall is (and has slowly creeped northward for the past several decades), so technically Perimeter Center is the current "center" of Atlanta as far as population goes. I don't think we should fight the growth trends and stubbornly locate a new stadium downtown. Atlanta is constantly evolving and changing. The location of the new stadium should reflect the growth vectors.

As for the Hawks, they are having an outstanding season thus far (1 game behind the Heat) so naturally fans will turn out in big numbers when the team is playing well. But what about average years? Have the Hawks (or any Atlanta professional team) historically had high attendance? No way. In fact Atlanta has a national reputation for average to poor game attendance. Talk to a Phillies fan about the Braves "high" attendance and they'll laugh at you. Philly sold out every home game for like 4 years straight. The Braves average about half of Turner Field every night despite having played excellent ball for the past 3 years. Thats not as bad as say Miami, but its not great and you shouldn't settle for that either.
 
Last edited:
1. While it's true there are a lot of transplants in Atlanta, both the Braves and Falcons do fine (Braves attendance and Falcons attendance are generally average for the US)

2. What does the lack of MARTA connectivity to Turner field have to do with the future Falcon's stadium? The stadium will almost certainly be walking distance from several different MARTA stops.

3. Perhaps we should spend some money and help improve these neighborhoods then as part of any new stadium deal (this has been discussed quite a bit).
1. For a town the size of Atlanta (9th largest MSA), average game attendance isn't good enough, but maybe I just have a higher standard than some. Thats not a knock to you, I just think we can do better.

2. Agreed. I just find it absurd that there is no MARTA access at Turner Field. The Falcons are selling out all of their games now mainly due to their success, but also in no small part to MARTA access. Its far easier to attend a Falcons game than a Braves game thanks to MARTA. The Braves almost never sell out games despite playing excellent ball and lack of MARTA connectivity plays into that.

3. I don't know if spending money on broken neighboorhoods will do much. Years of government assistance, wellfare, and subsidies have done nothing to help these neighboorhoods, and throwing additional money at them won't do much either. It would seem the single most beneficial thing for these neighborhoods is to tear down all the housing projects. The area around the former Techwood Homes is a vast improvement over what was there previously.
 
Last edited:
Hey I'm all for building MARTA into the suburbs. I voted for TSPLOST as most of you did and I wanted a light rail line in Cobb County (where I live). If a stadium was built closer to the fans then absolutely there should be a MARTA line serving it. Central Perimeter seems the logical choice for building a new Falcons or MLS stadium. Its centrally located, has excellent highway access, has a MARTA line, and is closer to the fan base. I read a while back that the center of population in Metro Atlanta is actually very close to where Perimeter Mall is (and has slowly creeped northward for the past several decades), so technically Perimeter Center is the current "center" of Atlanta as far as population goes. I don't think we should fight the growth trends and stubbornly locate a new stadium downtown. Atlanta is constantly evolving and changing. The location of the new stadium should reflect the growth vectors.

As for the Hawks, they are having an outstanding season thus far (1 game behind the Heat) so naturally fans will turn out in big numbers when the team is playing well. But what about average years? Have the Hawks (or any Atlanta professional team) historically had high attendance? No way. In fact Atlanta has a national reputation for average to poor game attendance. Talk to a Phillies fan about the Braves "high" attendance and they'll laugh at you. Philly sold out every home game for like 4 years straight. The Braves average about half of Turner Field every night despite having played excellent ball for the past 3 years. Thats not as bad as say Miami, but its not great and you shouldn't settle for that either.

Who cares about the Phillies? I personally don't base anything in Atlanta sports on what the Phillies are doing...how about you stop with the drivel so we can read about development rather than your misguided opinions about Atlanta sports?
 
Who cares about the Phillies? I personally don't base anything in Atlanta sports on what the Phillies are doing...how about you stop with the drivel so we can read about development rather than your misguided opinions about Atlanta sports?
This conversation originally was about where to put the Falcons stadium, which is pretty relevant to this board. And it has since expanded into why Atlanta sports attendance is yawn-worthy in general, which if you were following the conversation I was stating the case that attendance is only average partly due to where stadiums are located and how far away and inaccessible from the majority of the fanbase they are. I don't care if you agree with me or not but its still relevant to the board. I thought this was a board about discussion of development in Atlanta. But instead its a place where you'll get insulted if you don't share the prevailing opinion of the board. You would rather insult me than explain why you disagree, which contributes nothing to the conversation. I can tell when I'm not wanted so peace out. Don't waste your time responding because I'm gone.
 
This conversation originally was about where to put the Falcons stadium, which is pretty relevant to this board. And it has since expanded into why Atlanta sports attendance is yawn-worthy in general, which if you were following the conversation I was stating the case that attendance is only average partly due to where stadiums are located and how far away and inaccessible from the majority of the fanbase they are. I don't care if you agree with me or not but its still relevant to the board. I thought this was a board about discussion of development in Atlanta. But instead its a place where you'll get insulted if you don't share the prevailing opinion of the board. You would rather insult me than explain why you disagree, which contributes nothing to the conversation. I can tell when I'm not wanted so peace out. Don't waste your time responding because I'm gone.

It's just that your logic is not all that logical at times. It's as though you start with a point of view and then pick and choose issues to try to prove your point of view.

How many MLB stadiums have a heavy rail station within a couple of blocks? You make it seem like its common that many do. Does Philly's Citizen Bank Park? And if it does, is it near the convergence of two major interstates like Turner Field? Hell, how many MLB cities even have heavy rail? Turner Field is one of the biggest MLB stadiums in MLB - over 50k capacity. Do you take that in your conclusion about sellouts? So its not that surprising if Turner Field is not going to sell out as much as much 40k capacity stadium.

You suggest a football stadium in Perimeter area (which has arguably the worst traffic in the metro area) with less connectivity than Downtown. Miss an exit in the Perimeter area - you will have to go nearly to Cumberland, Roswell, Doraville, Tucker or Buckhead to get back to the area. Furthermore what are you gonna bulldoze in Perimeter to build a stadium?

Also, the housing projects around the Georgia Dome are already gone. And there has not been many years of government assistance in the area as you suggest. I see a lot of potential in Vine City, English Avenue neighborhoods near the Georgia Dome. Castleberry's potential is already being realized. Driving through Vine City/English Ave neighborhoods, you see what it once was - with corner stores, houses, schools and the tight blocks. Except for the lower socio-economic conditions, it really is not that much different than Grant Park, O4W, or even VaHi. If a neighborhood is asked to support a stadium that is being built with government assistance - I don't think its much to ask the government to assist that neighborhood's residents with nuisance such as tailgating, taking resident's parking, relieving themselves, trash, drunkiness, etc... I'm not necessarily a proponent of a new stadium in the area or in anywhere Downtown partly because of the impact that it has on residents but your logic is all over the place.
 
Again, from what I have heard there is a large announcement that will be made sometime in the next month or two regarding more intown retail. I already know the scoop so it is happening, but I can't give details. Don't expect Peachtree St announcement (so far as I know, but that would be even better), but the more we can pull away from the malls in Buckhead the better! Serious retailers new to the Atlanta market, too.

Simms, I can't get your teaser about an announcement for more in town retail out of my head! I understand why you can't give details, but can you give us any hints? Is this strictly a retail announcement or will it involve new construction?
 
Noticed this morning a construction permit on one of viewpoints vacant retail spaces. Maybe the future contruction of possibly two additional towers on that block is generating retail interest. :yes:
 
Ive never understood why they do this in Atlanta, Dallas, Houston, etc. They build good looking glass towers that at least it looks the architect tried and then next door they shit out a huge ugly parking garage.
 
Can we also mention the fact that the only neighborhoods that have seen appreciation over the past decade have been Virginia Highland, Grant Park, and East Lake? To me if there were any areas or neighborhoods to NOT throw any money at in the metro, they would all be suburban. The potential and upside in Atlanta are found in the central core.

In fact, there are reasons why there is almost no new housing and no new apartments being built outside of the perimeter, and one of those reasons is due to the undesirability of living so far from "the center" and fighting the traffic to get into "the center", which is not, nor will ever be Perimeter.
 
Can we also mention the fact that the only neighborhoods that have seen appreciation over the past decade have been Virginia Highland, Grant Park, and East Lake? To me if there were any areas or neighborhoods to NOT throw any money at in the metro, they would all be suburban. The potential and upside in Atlanta are found in the central core.

In fact, there are reasons why there is almost no new housing and no new apartments being built outside of the perimeter, and one of those reasons is due to the undesirability of living so far from "the center" and fighting the traffic to get into "the center", which is not, nor will ever be Perimeter.


Exactly, I live in Va Highland, and their are so many homes that are tearing down, remodeling, etc, it is astounding. This goes for Morningside, Ansley Park, Sherwood Forest, and Brookwood Hills. I am sure that their are others though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Back
Top