testarossa50
New member
The TSPLOST failing is a setback indeed. But seriously, let's not overreact. We actually have one of the best transit systems in the sunbelt.
I mean, where are they going to go instead? Nashville? Houston? Tampa? Those cities won't have transit like we do for decades if ever.
The main blow, as I see it, is a PR blow. We can go on and on about why this didn't pass, but let's take a moment to look at the plan's flaws. It ignored basically ALL of southern Gwinnett County. The Fayette, Douglas, and Rockdale lists were jokes. A huge chunk of the transit funding was pretty sketchy and weak. A mystery bus/rail line to Cumberland. A mystery bus/rail line down I-20. The Clifton Corridor project, which cost vast amounts despite low ridership projections, and wiggled awkwardly into Avondale Station--not a horrible project, but excellent fodder for conservatives to attack, and addresses a very small geographic area.
The TSPLOST was better than nothing. But it was pretty mediocre no matter how you cut it.
Looking at alternatives that we can actually push for, the Sierra Club/Tea Party shockingly have some good ideas in their counterproposal.
http://clatl.com/freshloaf/archives/2012/07/27/sierra-club-tea-party-agree-on-plan-b-if-t-splost-fails
Whether they actually believe in this stuff or were just bluffing to shoot the vote down, I'm not sure. But we need to start a new campaign to advocate for new solutions--solutions which DON'T have as their centerpiece a silly cop out that puts the entire matter on the backs of fickle voters. We need to make clear we haven't voted to do nothing; we've just voted not to do this particular TSPLOST.
The hotel/motel tax is so outrageous and hot button right now it's a good opportunity to argue the money ought to be leveraged towards transit instead. Conservatives don't seem to care that much either. But it's simply not enough money to make a big difference--a few tens of millions a year.
I mean, where are they going to go instead? Nashville? Houston? Tampa? Those cities won't have transit like we do for decades if ever.
The main blow, as I see it, is a PR blow. We can go on and on about why this didn't pass, but let's take a moment to look at the plan's flaws. It ignored basically ALL of southern Gwinnett County. The Fayette, Douglas, and Rockdale lists were jokes. A huge chunk of the transit funding was pretty sketchy and weak. A mystery bus/rail line to Cumberland. A mystery bus/rail line down I-20. The Clifton Corridor project, which cost vast amounts despite low ridership projections, and wiggled awkwardly into Avondale Station--not a horrible project, but excellent fodder for conservatives to attack, and addresses a very small geographic area.
The TSPLOST was better than nothing. But it was pretty mediocre no matter how you cut it.
Looking at alternatives that we can actually push for, the Sierra Club/Tea Party shockingly have some good ideas in their counterproposal.
http://clatl.com/freshloaf/archives/2012/07/27/sierra-club-tea-party-agree-on-plan-b-if-t-splost-fails
Whether they actually believe in this stuff or were just bluffing to shoot the vote down, I'm not sure. But we need to start a new campaign to advocate for new solutions--solutions which DON'T have as their centerpiece a silly cop out that puts the entire matter on the backs of fickle voters. We need to make clear we haven't voted to do nothing; we've just voted not to do this particular TSPLOST.
The hotel/motel tax is so outrageous and hot button right now it's a good opportunity to argue the money ought to be leveraged towards transit instead. Conservatives don't seem to care that much either. But it's simply not enough money to make a big difference--a few tens of millions a year.