mSeattle
Socialism 4 Extreme Rich?
SUMMARY: In 2010 the Assembly districts were redrawn so the majority of the seats are from the metro area. This takes power away from the traditionally dominant rural areas: Republicans. This shift to city living is what put transit on the ballot ASAP. If we say "NO" this year the pressure to do it ASAP will still be there and we'll get something much better next year. The Repubs in control wrote a regressive transit bill aimed to take power away from high-density areas and give it to low density areas. YES to density, NO to splost. Please take the time to read my coherent and logical argument before voting on Tuesday, thanks. I will explain Dashboard "grants" below.
FULL: Tsplost spent $10M on PR much of which went to spamming internet forums with pro-splost ideas, of which I concede there are many. This post is about me explaining why I, a progressive intellectual, am deciding to vote NO despite everyone else yelling YES. Here is my argument.
Dollars are fungible. One dollar you don't have to pay is "exceedingly similar to" an extra dollar that you do have. The Feds are about to indirectly give Atlanta a huge amount of money. By moving transit forward two years, that is two more years of taxes collected. That is two less years of overhead associated with the review. That is two years sooner that improvements of surrounding properties will become viable. This is a huge change in the economy of transit in Georgia. This is big money that I am talking about and is the mechanism through which bond offerings become viable. It's not simply speeding the process, it's creating two years of additional revenue.
This is the truth about TSPLOST: The metro area wants transit reform and the rest of the state doesn't. In the 2010 census the Assembly districts were redrawn and now a majority of the state legislators come from the metro area. Now transit is on the ballot. That's it, end of story. The presence of TSPLOST on the ballot is not about democrats and republicans. It is due to the redistricting of the Assembly. If we vote NO and ask for something better, we will get it because the reality of city living now dominates Georgia politics. This is new. That's why things are different now and traditional arguments are less relevant.
This is where the left/right thing comes into play: the Republicans control Georgia and they wrote a regressive republican transit bill. Yes: it is "something." It does contain many things that are great and will work. Despite the positives, I am against it because control of the T-splost funds is totally undemocratic. Whichever good-old-boy controls each county gets one vote regardless of how many people are in that county. Some counties have as much as 5x more people than others. Fulton gets two votes due its huge population; however, when Milton county is reformed (another Republican initiative pending) about a million historic Fulton residents are left with one vote. The people who know how transit should be done tend to live in Fulton county. We want our voice to count the most, not the least.
Look at how this ordeal mirrors the shift in the Assembly. The state is filling with city dwellers while the redundant rural areas see little growth and see their influence wane. Now tsplost is the Republican solution to transit. It farms power out of the dense areas and into the low density areas by removing the democratic element from the voting process. Transit is on the ballot because the regressivists in Georgia are losing power. If we vote NO, the facts that forced action this year will still be in place next year with even greater pressure.
The Republicans have offered us the worst possible deal they could get away with. We should not take the first offer we get. The Republican's hand was forced by the 2010 census, transit supporters have the power now. We need to demand an equitable solution not cheer for the scraps.
Question, would Clayton Co. be in the metro or outside of the metro? The reason I ask is that I know someone in Clayton Co. who had transportation problems trying to get to the north side of Atlanta when the bus service was cut. Towns that I saw in Clayton Co. seemed very low density. Is there fear that low density areas will go for more roads and less or no transit?