Isn't the rendering posted above (by Micropundit) Skyhouse? Unless they're being so lazy that they're building pretty much the exact same design just a few blocks away. Wouldn't put it past Novare.
(and I am upset about the land carve-out right on Peachtree).
I guess much of my strife is with 2 things - the overall market conditions and the fact that the garage does not allow for further development of the site nor does it adequately cover the Viewpoint podium (and I am upset about the land carve-out right on Peachtree).
:shrug:
^I have to disagree with those of you stating the economics aren't there. I'm not talking about putting the parking underground, I'm talking about hiding it, either in a podium or masking it by surrounding it with retail or residential entrances and covering it with a similar facade as the rest of the building. This has already worked well in Midtown. See Plaza Midtown, Viewpoint, Spire, Post Parkside, 1010, etc... we simply don't have to settle for this type of ginormous, detached, ugly, obvious parking deck that takes up three times as much land area as the building itself.
As for parking decks eventually being torn down and replaced with a building, it simply doesn't happen. Can anyone think of one instance of this occurring in Midtown? Or anywhere in Atlanta, for that matter? The only thing I can think of is the small parking deck at City Hall East that is currently being torn down as part of the conversion to Ponce City Market. If this deck gets built, we will be stuck with it for decades.
Let's pretend it adds $0.10 to rents (via 5% increase in construction costs). $1.85 to proforma is already pushing rents in Atlanta for "non-luxury" highrises (i.e. not Mezzo or 05 Buckhead). $1.95 might be beyond reach, and then leaves no room for rent growth and may result in concessions, taking down the net effective rent. This project is an investment, and will cost a good $200ish/SF to build with the deck to the side. Let's say gross revenue is about $20/SF (per annum) and expenses are at about $7/SF. Let's say interest on their construction loan brings that down by $9/SF on avg over the first 3 years ($50M loan, 5% int, 30 year amort, 250,000 SF - 800 SF avg unit size). That leaves them $4/SF per year to essentially distribute. They need strong occupancy of 95% or higher, really strong rent growth (investors often annualize prior 3 months of revenue over prior 12 months expenses for stabilized rental properties), and they need strong cap rates which will require Atlanta to remain a good multifamily market.
Pushing rents even $0.05/SF too high could be devastating to proforma as a project like this most likely depends on a strong reversion to attain a solid 15-20% IRR and a "profit" of at least 75% on top of their equity contribution (an equity multiple of at least 1.75).
I put together a completely juvenile proforma here -
Year 0 they put in $50/SF (20% LTC)
Year 1 they take back $4
Year 2 they take back $4.12 (let's pretend this figure grows 3% annually)
Year 3 $4.24
Year 4 $4.37
Year 5 $4.50 CF + ($13NOI*1.03^4/cap rate of 5.25%) = $280/SF - ~$194/SF loan paydown - net of $90.50
IRR = 18%
DCF yield capitalization at 7% discount = 22% CF and 78% reversion (very lopsided and reliant on reversion).
I am not versed in construction costs or financing buildings, and I don't really understand the specifics of what you're talking about at all. But I gather what you're saying is that for rental properties, it's not financially viable to build a podium garage. I'm sure this is mostly true.
But the fact is we've seen parking decks done well on properties here in Midtown. Even just recently, 77 12th street is rental, and it will have a podium. And I'm not talking only about podiums. Hell, I'd be happy if they'd at least clad this turd in glass so it's not as obvious. I can't imagine that would add too much to the cost. Or, why not wrap it in apartments on two or three sides, like almost every recent complex in the city has done?
The 77 12th St podium isn't exactly the most integrated setup I've seen.
From 2 sides, it's a pretty hideous deck in its own right. Dressing up the 12th st side is still just window dressing.
Who knows, maybe it's a smart hedge by Novare. If the rest of midtown infills, they are apartments so you can separate parking costs and reduce deck usage when a 3rd building is economically viable. It definitely would be here for decades (as should all structures where you've invested millions to build).
At least in the future if prevailing land prices/transit are solid enough, there's only a 4 story deck to knock down instead of a building w/ several floors of underutilized deck space integrated in.
:shrug:
Agreed, the parking deck is unfortunate; in years to come we can hope that they will be underground - currently the costs just don't justify it. Eventually it will be torn down and replaced with a high rise with built in parking.
See I'm just an entry level analyst and see numbers all day...it's great to hear input regarding cost effective ways to conceal a deck...like the ivy! ]
I'd really like for apartments to start breaking out the pricing of parking and rent. I seem to recall $50/mo being roughly the revenue needed to cover a parking deck's construction and operation--seems like a reasonable surcharge. At least throw a bone to the renters who don't need or want to drive, or only have 1 car for a 2/2.
Let's pretend it adds $0.10 to rents (via 5% increase in construction costs). $1.85 to proforma is already pushing rents in Atlanta for "non-luxury" highrises (i.e. not Mezzo or 05 Buckhead). $1.95 might be beyond reach, and then leaves no room for rent growth and may result in concessions, taking down the net effective rent. This project is an investment, and will cost a good $200ish/SF to build with the deck to the side. Let's say gross revenue is about $20/SF (per annum) and expenses are at about $7/SF. Let's say interest on their construction loan brings that down by $9/SF on avg over the first 3 years ($50M loan, 5% int, 30 year amort, 250,000 SF - 800 SF avg unit size). That leaves them $4/SF per year to essentially distribute. They need strong occupancy of 95% or higher, really strong rent growth (investors often annualize prior 3 months of revenue over prior 12 months expenses for stabilized rental properties), and they need strong cap rates which will require Atlanta to remain a good multifamily market.
Pushing rents even $0.05/SF too high could be devastating to proforma as a project like this most likely depends on a strong reversion to attain a solid 15-20% IRR and a "profit" of at least 75% on top of their equity contribution (an equity multiple of at least 1.75).
I put together a completely juvenile proforma here -
Year 0 they put in $50/SF (20% LTC)
Year 1 they take back $4
Year 2 they take back $4.12 (let's pretend this figure grows 3% annually)
Year 3 $4.24
Year 4 $4.37
Year 5 $4.50 CF + ($13NOI*1.03^4/cap rate of 5.25%) = $280/SF - ~$194/SF loan paydown - net of $90.50
IRR = 18%
DCF yield capitalization at 7% discount = 22% CF and 78% reversion (very lopsided and reliant on reversion)
I think these projects are risky as hell and in Atlanta they are always teetering on the edge of feasibility. A podium could be the tipping point.
Therefore I direct my anger elsewhere and hope that we solve our transit problem by expanding rail, and that we keep centralizing so that walking/biking is encouraged, and then parking may not be an issue any longer and higher rents north of $2/SF may become market-rate (thereby making high-rise living much more lender friendly and easier to justify).