gttx
Urban Explorer
As we all know, there is no dearth of skyscrapers in Atlanta. What there is a lack of, however, is urbanism. If you have ever been to Buckhead (which I assume you have), you would know skyscrapers are not a necessary cause, but a sufficient cause for urbanism. Conversly, if you've been to Tech Square, you would know that mid-rises can achieve urbanism just as easily, if not more easily. Cities like Savannah and Charleston have arguably some of the best urbanism in the US, yet there are no skyscrapers to speak of. Smaller buildings have several advantages over skyscrapers:
1. Skyscrapers cost more time and energy to build due to increased equipment costs. This leads to cutting corners on design and construction, which then leads to lesser quality. Mid-rises can be built for less capital, and of a greater quality.
2. Skyscrapers are basically vertical culs-de-sac, congesting the surrounding area with traffic rather than spreading it over a larger area.
3. Skyscrapers tend to raise the property value of everything around them, making it more prohibitive to build out.
4. Skyscrapers have a higher operating and maintenance cost than mid-rises.
5. They also require greater volumes of parking in surrounding area. Mid-rises can compensate for parking by surround the parking deck with liner buildings (a.k.a Houston Donuts).
6. Mid-rises can be spread across a greater area of land, contributing to the urbanity of the area.
While skyscrapers are nice for skyline shots, I would much rather a developer focus his efforts on building mid-rises to fill in empty spaces than showy skyscrapers, which we have enough of in Atlanta. Building four quality 5 story buildings can contribute much more to an area than one single mediocre 20 story building.
Can it be possible for a city to be done "developing" and focus on enhancing the public realm? I believe so.
Sorry, but I have to disagree here with you and with Terminus. None of these points actually makes any sense - sure, skyscrapers cost more and have higher maintenance costs, but they also bring in more revenue by virtue of having more potential space for lease. You have set up this dichotomy between midrise and highrise that ignores the actual facts of developing real estate, none of which cater to your utopian view of how Midtown "should" develop. In truth, what "should" be developed on those plots are buildings that are financially successful and fit with the city's long-term vision for the area, spelled out very clearly in Blueprint Midtown.
You are correct, however, in stating that tall buildings are not synonymous with urbanity. They are also not antithetical. Sure, we all love to throw around Paris and Rome as great examples of low- and mid-rise urbanism, but the truth is that these are not, have never, and will never be comparable to Atlanta. Neither, of course, will places like New York or Chicago. Atlanta has a very unique form that is somewhat new in planning history - and guiding that form in the coming years and decades will really determine what the city looks like long-term. But it will certainly not be either of the two poles, purely mid-rise construction and purely high-rise construction.
I also am sort of intrigued by your idea of "completing" Midtown (which I suppose you define as filling in all the empty lots). I think we all want to eventually see the city develop more, but just throwing in random crap and calling it "done" is the worst way I could think to do it. Instead, let it develop organically, over time, based on rational economic forces. That is how we will get what Midtown "should" look like - not by some utopian vision of urbanity founded on centuries-old ideas that are no longer applicable here.