Atlantan26
New member
The area directly west of 1010 Peachtree is where Phase 4 of the 12th & Midtown project will be located.
I cant wait for phase 3 to get started!
I cant wait for phase 3 to get started!
I wouldn't mind seeing something similar to Gramercy Park in that area (minus the private park part). 15-20 stories, with a pocket park on one block. Considering the location, I think their needs to be pretty significant density (and considering the proximity to MARTA, their can be) but a small park would be a nice asset.
Right, since the 'burbs or a Beltline were the only two choices possible.
Don't tell anyone but I used to live in the Seattle MSA and we had this very big body of water on one side and the mountains on the other and we still had, gasp, suburbs!
What in God's name do you mean by your post?
Im surprised that this forum is not heavily in favor of a very tall building with a parking structure. This would allow nice sidewalks all the way around the block and make Crescent St into a very nice canyon. If that lot could get the high quality street level tenants as 1010 that would be a foundation for extending Midtown's two-dimensionality. Does anyone think those four leases on Crescent would have all been signed in a less fabulous building? The strip from 1010 to One Atlantic Center is ready for some serious urbanity. It's so underdeveloped that 12th St could easily become a major cross street with big sidewalks and granite curbs.
Why build a very tall building when you can build multiple smaller buildings of greater quality across a larger area? You can have a sense of place and enclosure (what I think you're referring to with the term "canyon") just as easily as long as the buildings are tall enough (but not too tall) and meet the street. This would also fill all the empty spaces dotting Midtown and Downtown more quickly.
As we all know, there is no dearth of skyscrapers in Atlanta. What there is a lack of, however, is urbanism. If you have ever been to Buckhead (which I assume you have), you would know skyscrapers are not a necessary cause, but a sufficient cause for urbanism. Urbanism and skyscrapers do not go hand in hand. Conversly, if you've been to Tech Square, you would know that mid-rises can achieve urbanism just as easily, if not more easily. Cities like Savannah and Charleston have arguably some of the best urbanism in the US, yet there are no skyscrapers to speak of. Smaller buildings have several advantages over skyscrapers:
1. Skyscrapers cost more time and energy to build due to increased equipment costs. This leads to cutting corners on design and construction, which then leads to lesser quality. Mid-rises can be built for less capital, and therefore of a greater quality.
2. Skyscrapers are basically vertical culs-de-sac, congesting the surrounding area with traffic rather than spreading it over a larger area.
3. Skyscrapers tend to raise the property value of everything around them, making it more prohibitive to build out.
4. Skyscrapers have a higher operating and maintenance cost than mid-rises (especially if built at a poorer quality).
5. Skyscrapers require greater volumes of parking in surrounding area. Mid-rises can compensate for parking by surround the parking deck with liner buildings (a.k.a Houston Donuts).
6. Mid-rises can be spread across a greater area of land, contributing to the urbanity of the area.
While skyscrapers are nice for skyline shots, I would much rather a developer focus his efforts on building mid-rises to fill in empty spaces than showy skyscrapers, which we have enough of in Atlanta. Building four quality 5 story buildings can contribute much more to an area than one single mediocre 20 story building.
Can it be possible for a city to be done "developing" and focus on enhancing the public realm? I believe so.
Im not against short buildings. I am just against short buildings going in that lot. It is so prime and there are so many other empty lots for infill. Savannah and Charleston aren't very metropolitan, they're more like large towns and Atlanta shouldn't take too much from them. Theyre more colloquial than urban.
Im not against short buildings. I am just against short buildings going in that lot. It is so prime and there are so many other empty lots for infill. Savannah and Charleston aren't very metropolitan, they're more like large towns and Atlanta shouldn't take too much from them. Theyre more colloquial than urban.
3 to 7 stories is short? Seems pretty tall to me...
Midtown already has many buildings of this size, namely Midcity Lofts, Post Biltmore and Post Parkside, all high quality buildings. I love skyscrapers as much as the next person, but I don't think we should concentrate all of our efforts on filling Midtown with tall buildings. Maybe that parcel, but as a whole, Midtown should be filled with more modestly sized buildings as to make it a more complete community and be "done" developing quicker so we can move on.
As with Charleston and Savannah, they may be large towns, but they have much more concentrated urbanism than Atlanta does. You could call them complete communities. Large metro areas and urbanism are not mutually inclusive.
No offense but I think your opinion is going to be a bit in the minority around here.As we all know, there is no dearth of skyscrapers in Atlanta. What there is a lack of, however, is urbanism. If you have ever been to Buckhead (which I assume you have), you would know skyscrapers are not a necessary cause, but a sufficient cause for urbanism. Conversly, if you've been to Tech Square, you would know that mid-rises can achieve urbanism just as easily, if not more easily. Cities like Savannah and Charleston have arguably some of the best urbanism in the US, yet there are no skyscrapers to speak of. Smaller buildings have several advantages over skyscrapers:
1. Skyscrapers cost more time and energy to build due to increased equipment costs. This leads to cutting corners on design and construction, which then leads to lesser quality. Mid-rises can be built for less capital, and of a greater quality.
2. Skyscrapers are basically vertical culs-de-sac, congesting the surrounding area with traffic rather than spreading it over a larger area.
3. Skyscrapers tend to raise the property value of everything around them, making it more prohibitive to build out.
4. Skyscrapers have a higher operating and maintenance cost than mid-rises.
5. They also require greater volumes of parking in surrounding area. Mid-rises can compensate for parking by surround the parking deck with liner buildings (a.k.a Houston Donuts).
6. Mid-rises can be spread across a greater area of land, contributing to the urbanity of the area.
While skyscrapers are nice for skyline shots, I would much rather a developer focus his efforts on building mid-rises to fill in empty spaces than showy skyscrapers, which we have enough of in Atlanta. Building four quality 5 story buildings can contribute much more to an area than one single mediocre 20 story building.
Can it be possible for a city to be done "developing" and focus on enhancing the public realm? I believe so.
No offense but I think your opinion is going to be a bit in the minority around here.
Take a look at the name of the website in your browser address bar to figure out why. This isn't forum.midrisespage.com![]()
Savannah is a centuries old city built on a pretty rigid grid. That is about the only thing I think Atlanta could borrow from Savannah.
As far as that core Midtown area along 12th St, I think there should be skyscrapers. The midrises would be better off surrounding the tall core. Midtown already looks much like this. Midrises surrounding tall skyscrapers. That trend should continue rather than building a couple of seven story buildings in between skyscrapers.
Right now there are skyscrapers being built, but they're scattered between Midtown, Atlantic Station, Buckhead, and Downtown. I'd like to see the skyscrapers build in a central location rather than being spread all over the place.
As we all know, there is no dearth of skyscrapers in Atlanta. What there is a lack of, however, is urbanism. If you have ever been to Buckhead (which I assume you have), you would know skyscrapers are not a necessary cause, but a sufficient cause for urbanism. Conversly, if you've been to Tech Square, you would know that mid-rises can achieve urbanism just as easily, if not more easily. Cities like Savannah and Charleston have arguably some of the best urbanism in the US, yet there are no skyscrapers to speak of. Smaller buildings have several advantages over skyscrapers:
1. Skyscrapers cost more time and energy to build due to increased equipment costs. This leads to cutting corners on design and construction, which then leads to lesser quality. Mid-rises can be built for less capital, and of a greater quality.
2. Skyscrapers are basically vertical culs-de-sac, congesting the surrounding area with traffic rather than spreading it over a larger area.
3. Skyscrapers tend to raise the property value of everything around them, making it more prohibitive to build out.
4. Skyscrapers have a higher operating and maintenance cost than mid-rises.
5. They also require greater volumes of parking in surrounding area. Mid-rises can compensate for parking by surround the parking deck with liner buildings (a.k.a Houston Donuts).
6. Mid-rises can be spread across a greater area of land, contributing to the urbanity of the area.
While skyscrapers are nice for skyline shots, I would much rather a developer focus his efforts on building mid-rises to fill in empty spaces than showy skyscrapers, which we have enough of in Atlanta. Building four quality 5 story buildings can contribute much more to an area than one single mediocre 20 story building.
Can it be possible for a city to be done "developing" and focus on enhancing the public realm? I believe so.