scania
Active member
Oh please. I dislike this building because it's a mash-up of about 4 different architectural ideas, none of which emerge from any obvious function or unique situation of the building. A curvy atrium in the middle? Sure! Some random punch outs, sort of diagonal but sort of rectangular? All right! Blobs cantilevering out for no discernible reason? OK! Two giant (different) logos? This is fun!
Frankly I'm not sure why anyone on a forum dedicated to skyscrapers and urban development would ever come to the defense of John Portman. The damage he inflicted on the city fabric of Atlanta is unforgivable, even if he did have the occasional flash of brilliance with a tower.
The damage he's inflicted on the city fabric is unforgivable??? WOW, there's so much more than what he's done that affects the urbanity of the city. Atlanta could have 10 towers by him, or none by him, and the urbanity of Atlanta would still be the same. Atlanta does not have enough people to support all of the street level retail, that most of you tend to want. Also, some people can love skyscrapers as well as development at large and not care about it being walkable and close to public transportation. Some of you have the idea that in order to love skyscrapers and development, you must or should be all about your perception of being urban.