ATLANTA | Development Thread V


Status
Not open for further replies.
455 14th St render

67309_1413475446_page-3-medium.jpg


Pollack Shores is scheduled to close on the five-acre site for a 360-unit apartment complex at 455 14th St within 30 days.

http://www.bisnow.com/commercial-re...tments-for-georgia-tech-like-new-golf-course/
 
Just found out it's real after all, and it's typical Fuqua :(



Zoning meetings are imminent. Can someone please stop this man from cursing Atlanta with his garbage?

The hidden garage is welcome, but that's way too much surface parking and it looks like the retail fronts the parking rather than the street.

Edit: Courtesy of eRosewater on Curbed.

are you kidding me!? this is just a shame. look at that terrible little "single family" subdivision at the bottom left. the apartment on the bottom right is ok i guess.. but then we have a big surface parking lot where there should be park space or more density. Fuqua with more of the same just as expected. very reminicent of that Kroger proposal up near lindberg if i remember correctly. hopefully the Loring Heights folks can have some say in this but i doubt it

*the comments over at Curbed seem to be embracing this. i dont like it. but i dont actually see the above render posted there so maybe they arent seeing what this really is
http://atlanta.curbed.com/archives/...his-mixeduse-talents-to-the-westside.php#more
 
PremierAtlanta - I understand and appreciate your points. Let me give you my real world perspective: I live on Longleaf Drive in Buckhead, which is off of Phipps Blvd and behind the mall. The houses on my street go for $500 - 1.2. and we don't have sidewalks on either side of the street. Two years ago I was hit by a lady in a minivan walking my dogs. The dogs were not hurt, but I was. She never even stopped, but an onlooker got her license plate number. Therefore, if I had a choice of where I would walk my dogs, I would pick Atlantic Station over my neighborhood any day.

That is horrible. I am so sorry to read that you were hit and/or injured. What type of human being can hit someone and not stop immediately to offer assistance? Sidewalks are vital to the pedestrian experience. I hope the Buckhead CID addressed the lack of sidewalks in the area. I pray that you were able to recover fully from your injuries and that this "human" was prosecuted. Calling her a lady is way too kind.

Now to Atlantic Station: I'm not saying that Atlantic Station doesn't have any redeeming qualities. The development is nicely done. There are a fair amount of amenities to be enjoyed. My only issue would be the quality of schools in the area and large greenspace. Once your child reaches school age, it may be time to move on to "greener" pastures. That's why I said it would not be my first choice if I was house hunting (with family in mind) inside the city limits.
 
isnt that old as hell? im pretty sure the allen plaza stuff got put on indefinite hold. especially 50 allen plaza.. as much as i would love for it to be built

Have you ever seen #8 before? I never have, have you?

Search for it on Google. Nada. I got an email from someone I can not identify. Also, Allen Plaza site(s) were bought by Regent Partners.
 
What kills me about this (and many other Fuqua developments) is that it has all the pieces that the area can really benefit from, but they're assembled in a totally unbefitting way. It might be unrealistic to expect an all-residential idea to become mixed use or whatever, but how hard is it to just properly design what you already have? Surely there wouldn't be much additional cost in laying things out a little better, and even if there was, wouldn't it pay for itself by being more desireable? What's his MO here? After all the controversy, it can't be ignorance. Is he just a sociopath?

My only issue would be the quality of schools in the area and large greenspace.

There's already more greenspace there than any typical suburban yard can provide, but if that's not enough Piedmont Park is only a few minutes away.
 
Old! the W is already built and it looks nothing like that... The other (much older) render of allen plaza has this shown correctly.
I would love to see the 50 Allen Plaza proposal come back to life. I really like the design of that tower. It would be an incredible addition to the downtown skyline!
Does anyone know if 50 Allen Plaza could re-surface again in the future? A great design like that has to be built - IT HAS TO BE BUILT!!!
 
I would love to see the 50 Allen Plaza proposal come back to life. I really like the design of that tower. It would be an incredible addition to the downtown skyline!
Does anyone know if 50 Allen Plaza could re-surface again in the future? A great design like that has to be built - IT HAS TO BE BUILT!!!

Definitely not happening... it's long dead. That land was foreclosed and sold to Regent. Whatever ultimately ends up there will probably be nice given the prime location, but they've stated the design will be different.

http://www.bizjournals.com/atlanta/...s-buys-50-allen-plaza.html?full=true&page=all
 
Let me say a word in defense of Fuqua. I know you guys don't like his developments, I respect that, but let's look at the big picture here. Atlanta isn't San Francisco or Manhattan and in my opinion that's a good thing because those places are way over-gentrified. What is happening in SF and NY isn't sustainable. Atlanta has to provide deliverable product that fits the community needs. When there's an economic reset, and there will be sooner or later, SF and NY are toast. Meanwhile Atlanta enjoys steady, more-or-less sustainable growth because we're providing lots of housing and amenities for the other 99% of us, thanks to developers like Fuqua.
 
Let me say a word in defense of Fuqua. I know you guys don't like his developments, I respect that, but let's look at the big picture here. Atlanta isn't San Francisco or Manhattan and in my opinion that's a good thing because those places are way over-gentrified. What is happening in SF and NY isn't sustainable. Atlanta has to provide deliverable product that fits the community needs. When there's an economic reset, and there will be sooner or later, SF and NY are toast. Meanwhile Atlanta enjoys steady, more-or-less sustainable growth because we're providing lots of housing and amenities for the other 99% of us, thanks to developers like Fuqua.

You're right that Atlanta isn't Manhattan. My problem with Fuqua's developments isn't that they have cookie-cutter architecture or that they aren't dense enough; it's that their sites are badly designed. Fuqua still thinks it's 1995. Although he builds his developments in urban areas where cars are not the only way people get around, he still designs them as if absolutely everyone will be driving to them, and if a pedestrian should happen to wedge their way in every once in awhile, then yay for them :shrug:

If the site plan is accurate, pedestrians can only access the site in two places. That's appalling. Of course, since the center is just a giant parking lot with no footpaths, the retail isn't even easily accessible to the people who live inside of the thing. There isn't even a way to walk from the large retail space to the smaller ones without navigating what looks to be some kind of mutant six-way intersection.

If they made the retail more contiguous, added a pedestrian plaza to the middle of the parking lot, added street-side pedestrian access to the apartments, homes, and retail (similar to what was done in Lindbergh where each retail space has two entrances), and maybe (now I'm just dreaming) got rid of the fortress-like design of the subdivision and added some public greenspace, then the development would actually be pretty nice. None of that is outlandish, but if history is any indication, none of it will be done without a hell of a fight. I'm worried that Loring Heights doesn't have the resources to save that lot from Fuqua's suburban garbage.

For contrast: Even as poorly-designed as Atlantic Station's mall is (why in the world is State St. treated like a back alley?), it caters first and foremost to pedestrians. Cars are allowed in there by the thousands, but they're kept underground and out of sight. Did you know the BB&T building is actually sitting on a 5-6 story parking deck? Probably not... it's completely camouflaged from the outside. All that was done on a vacant brownfield site a good distance from the Midtown Mile (where everything was happening in the days Atlantic Station was built), and it never needed to be that way. They could have very easily built giant surface lots around a mall and made the whole thing car-oriented. Say what you will about the various architectural flaws of the thing, but they were very forward-thinking when they designed that site, and it's going to pay off as the density increases in the future. Fuqua is doing the opposite.
 
Let me say a word in defense of Fuqua. I know you guys don't like his developments, I respect that, but let's look at the big picture here. Atlanta isn't San Francisco or Manhattan and in my opinion that's a good thing because those places are way over-gentrified. What is happening in SF and NY isn't sustainable. Atlanta has to provide deliverable product that fits the community needs. When there's an economic reset, and there will be sooner or later, SF and NY are toast. Meanwhile Atlanta enjoys steady, more-or-less sustainable growth because we're providing lots of housing and amenities for the other 99% of us, thanks to developers like Fuqua.

i agree with you about the ridiculous gentrification in NYC and SF, but what do you mean when you say these cities are toast? elbourate, please.
 
Well, it's probably not appropriate for this message board to elaborate here, but let's say that in a world of 7 billion people facing shortages and given the high cost of living and income/wealth discrepancies apparent in showcase cities like NY, DC, SF, London, when there is a downturn there will be a reset. The players on top have used the system to build far too many advantages for themselves, the middle class is shrinking and the poor are expanding even though they are being given bread and TV and a false reality. Whenever it happened in history there was a revolution. Sooner or later you wouldn't want to be in those cities.
 
Let me say a word in defense of Fuqua. I know you guys don't like his developments, I respect that, but let's look at the big picture here. Atlanta isn't San Francisco or Manhattan and in my opinion that's a good thing because those places are way over-gentrified. What is happening in SF and NY isn't sustainable. Atlanta has to provide deliverable product that fits the community needs. When there's an economic reset, and there will be sooner or later, SF and NY are toast. Meanwhile Atlanta enjoys steady, more-or-less sustainable growth because we're providing lots of housing and amenities for the other 99% of us, thanks to developers like Fuqua.

Except SF right now is booming, enjoys a low unemployment rate, and a lot of fortunes from tourists around the world desiring to move and invest in the city along with a very wealthy population.

Meanwhile Atlanta has a striking 7.9% unemployment rate, struggling job market, and no one really has a desire to live in Atlanta around the world and has little foreign investment.

Don't compare Atlanta to SF. It does not compare. One is truly world class city. The other is a city that wishes it could be one.

I mean, just look on the expedia videos on youtube on both cities and look at the comments. SF is pretty much all positive comments. Atlanta is mixed between negative and somewhat positive comments.
 
Well, it's probably not appropriate for this message board to elaborate here, but let's say that in a world of 7 billion people facing shortages and given the high cost of living and income/wealth discrepancies apparent in showcase cities like NY, DC, SF, London, when there is a downturn there will be a reset. The players on top have used the system to build far too many advantages for themselves, the middle class is shrinking and the poor are expanding even though they are being given bread and TV and a false reality. Whenever it happened in history there was a revolution. Sooner or later you wouldn't want to be in those cities.

In the last study, Atlanta had a large income discrepancy...I think it was the highest barely inching above SF because of the very wealthy Buckhead to the north and very poor South Atlanta neighborhoods.

CityInequality2012.jpg





The gini coefficient is highest in Atlanta of all cities in the country.

http://www.bloomberg.com/visual-data/best-and-worst//most-income-inequality-us-cities

So what are you talking about exactly?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Back
Top