This is absolutely true. This can't be debated. If we want to host a Super Bowl, we need a new stadium, if we want to host non-friendly soccer matches, which plenty of people would love, we would need a new stadium because the Georgia Dome does not qualify. We lost out on the new major bowl between the champions of the Big 12 and SEC mainly because we don't have a new, shiny stadium. All the other events, Final Fours, will be tougher to lure with an outdated stadium, which the Georgia Dome is.
10-15 years is too late in my opinion. The stadium is already one of the oldest in the NFL and most of the ones older (such as Soldier Field, Arrowhead Stadium) have had massive renovations recently, which would be just as costly as building a new stadium from what has been released; or the team is currently in the process of getting a new stadium or subject to relocation rumors (Buffalo, Minnesota, San Diego, etc.).
And while all these things are nice, and I would love for all of them to be done, I don't think they would bring the same ROI that a stadium would.
That's your opinion, but its possible. St. Louis' Edward Jones Dome, Detroit's Ford Field, and Carolina's Bank of America Stadium all do a good job.
I've seen the studies, but all cases are different. The city isn't financing the entire stadium, only a portion, and many of the studies look at "where the money could go" in regards to money spent at the stadium. They look at it in a broad sense saying a person, instead of spending money at the Georgia Dome, could spend the money at a movie theater. Either way, the money is spent into the local economy, correct? But the movie theater isn't subsidized. However, that completely disregards Atlanta's situation. Most people coming to the stadium aren't choosing between spending their money at the stadium in Atlanta or some other business in Atlanta, but rather spending their money in Atlanta or spending their money in their suburban town. Not to mention all the events that we've both talked about that bring in people from out of town.
I wouldn't be crushed if the stadium wasn't built. It's just my opinion it would be a good thing and fortunately the city is committed to this. I understand where you're coming from and I am aware of all the "negatives", I just think the positives outweigh them.
Edit: And to touch on what Simms said, I'm not saying to host a Super Bowl is the reason to build a new stadium, but the Falcons are getting a new stadium. Do you want the stadium in Atlanta or somewhere else in the metro area?