Quote:
Originally Posted by taiwan ren
Impressive indeed! Who's going to pay for it? Or in the case of the Taoyuan lines - who's going to ride it? Like all plans, there will be lots of adjustments - especially once fiscal reality sets in.
Taoyuan
Can't see a need for the the red, orange, or brown line. To my mind, the area would be well served with a loop consisting of the TRA, airport, and green line. Five train links between Taoyuan and Taipei is delusional.
Keelung
One at grade LRV line would cover most of their needs. Anything beyond that is a waste of money.
Ilan
A direct train link is just too expensive. Never gonna happen!
Taipei
Not really convinced the Minsheng line is such a wise investment - I guess it depends on the future of songshan airport.
Thanks for sharing!
|
I agree that funding will be the most difficult obstacle to overcome with the new lines.
However, I won't be worried about the volume of passengers. There are more than 2 million people in Taoyuan, and increasing. There are about 500,000 people in Keelung. The 4 lines are short (<9km each), but can transport commuters to TRA stations. The light rails also have sightseeing values, which is important to Keelung development.
As for the direct train line between Taipei and Ilan, it may be a fantasy for now. However, many people fear that the capacity of Beiyi high way will be overloaded in less than 10 years, a direct train line is necessary for Ilan to serve as the new satellite city for Taipei Metro area. The central government may put money to it once it get passed the environmental evaluation committee, which for now is the barrier for the project, not actually the money.
Minsheng-Shijih line serves both Shijih (pop. >200,000) and Neihu, in which has traffic jam every single day. I'm not so sure about the Minsheng part, but it definitley can transport a lot of people from these two areas.
Bottom line is, yes, money will be a problem, but Taipei does need those lines. We've got the people, and we've got the needs. Plus I really hate scooters!