Thank you everyone for the great comments. This is exactly what I was wanting
Let me add another like/dislike about our current town, and let's see if sparks more feedback...
LIKE: Toronto is 2.5 hours away, giving decent access to "Broadway" shows, professional sports, and other unique experiences.
DISLIKE: The traffic jams to Toronto make the drive more like 3.5 hours, and snarled traffic everywhere sucks the enjoyment out of whatever thing you were going there to enjoy.
And based on the small tourist town my wife grew-up in...
LIKE: Tourists mean a more vibrant summer, and tourist attractions are fun for locals too.
DISLIKE: Prices are jacked-up to capture the tourist dollars, and higher prices are no fun for locals.