Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibba
The Peoria one looks slick. I like the (idea of the) board-formed concrete base. The corner-wrap windows could be really nice too (if I'm interpreting the elevation correctly). The "applied mullions" everywhere are concerning, but maybe these are more common than I know of and don't look that bad?
|
I've never heard the term "applied mullions." "Simulated divided lite" is the industry term for the muntin bars you see on most contemporary residential developments. They're pretty much standard at this point; true divided light is both very costly and very inefficient. IMO, the difference is noticeable. The latter has more depth while the former often really does look tacked on.
It's representative of the problem with historicism. Accurately replicating a past style makes little to no financial (not to mention environmental) sense in both the short run and the long run. When you try to approximate it you sacrifice certain details. One missing detail may not seem like a big deal. An accumulation of them is, and that gestalt plays a big role in the vague but unsettling difference the more discerning eye notices between historic architecture and historicist architecture. It's death by a thousand cuts.
Anyway, I agree with your assessment.
Quote:
Originally Posted by denizen467
^^ Is that the neo warehouse style?
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by SamInTheLoop
The 7-story one is mostly ye faux olde tyme urban warehouse reno design........looks like it may not be ugly, but still to me does not look like good design in the 21st century....
|
Accurate! It might be awesome if they salvaged a bunch of the material from a recent warehouse demolition. But I highly doubt that would happen.