Originally Posted by Illithid Dude
The irony is, for all the bitching we do about "shit boxes", they seem to have better pedestrian interactions than any of the high rises. Walking around South Park, the only places that don't feel actively hostile to pedestrians is where there has been a dense build up of seven story wood frames, which actually seem to be designed for people. The storefronts are smaller scale, with shading and ground-level architectural detailing. This is opposed to say, anything on Figueroa, which is incredibly wide, and the surrounding high rise development overbearing and oppressive. Honestly, I think the biggest issue downtown is how wide the streets are in South Park. I helped out with a fashion event at LA Live, and had to walk to the 7-11 on Olive to get Red Bulls. The experience was honestly horrible, with streets literally as wide as freeways and no shade. The high rises built seemed to have commercial space almost as an afterthought, with Apex not even having retail. From looking at the plans, it doesn't seem like LA Central or Circa are going to change anything. Sure, these towers look good from a distance, and help fill out our skyline, but when walking around they serve only to take up space, and do nothing to actually enhance the pedestrian atmosphere. And frankly, why should they? We talk about Chinese companies "saving" downtown, but they don't really care about downtown, just about providing investment opportunities for clients in China who may never even come to the US. The buildings are totally insular as well. A huge mall in LA Central (and I mean huge - the plans are ridiculous) and a huge mall in Metropolis. Every store that goes in these malls is going to be a store that doesn't face the street. What would you rather have? A thriving downtown street lined with high end stores, or a building that you drive in to that is filled with high end stores that just so happens to be downtown. Honestly, my whole experience downtown was very disheartening. The issue isn't just filling up downtown, but how downtown is filled up. To be frank, I'd almost go as far as to say that South Park is a lost cause, and is actually harmful to the vitality of the rest of downtown. Hopefully the historic core isn't relentlessly commercialized in the same way - which it looks like it won't be thank god.
|