Quote:
Originally Posted by biggus diggus
There's a lot of good to see, a lot of what is happening downtown is a result of asu's presence. The ASU athletic thingamabobber is actually open to ymca members and the students are walking all over the city making the whole area feel more vibrant.
Im not sure how you can be so delusional and fail to see all the good that has come from ASU downtown.
|
I've been told several times that only certain programs are open to YMCA members. Regardless, the historic post office within what was supposed to be a city civic space is inaccessible to the general public, as is the top floor of the A.E. Building during certain hours. ASU promised to integrate itself into the city and it has failed at doing that, plain and simple. The money provided to ASU in order to fast-track its construction was not petty change, so sorry if you don't like my criticism of their creation of an insular, lowrise, single-use educational district, but it isn't unwarranted.
I think the value of students on downtown is also overstated. They have had an impact surely, but why did it take a decade after its opening for there to be any large-scale investment from the private sector in the surrounding neighborhood? None of the adaptive reuse projects targeted students (the majority which are under 21) and there's only been one housing project aimed at this demo - Roosevelt Point. Where are the private housing projects being built in nearly every college city? Why hasn't ASU added to the residential base since the first dorms opened?
"This isn't NYC or Chicago" is a shitty argument. Phoenix's location doesn't necessitate shitty planning or design. They've created as many new parking lots as they have pretty midrises, and aside from 3 fast food joints at Walter Cronkite and Hsin Cafe + Starbucks at Taylor Place, have contributed nothing for downtown residents to use. The park was its one fabulous contribution when it had the potential to be surrounded by mixed income housing projects and the A.E. Building and Post Office were thought to be used as actual public spaces... with 1st Ave land banked, it's basically Hayden Lawn.
Yes, it's negative. But, this is a sub-section of a skyscraper forum that also discusses urban planning. Feel free to comment on how a 5-story recreation center in the heart of a downtown is great beyond "This isn't Chicago." My opinion is just as valid cheerleading of mediocrity.