| |
Posted May 25, 2010, 9:51 PM
|
|
Registered User
|
|
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 966
|
|
Quote:
Can Halifax council actually shrink itself? Let’s hope so
By PAUL SCHNEIDEREIT
Tue. May 25 - 4:53 AM
Is Halifax regional council too big, too small or — currently with 23 councillors and a mayor — just right as it is?
Well, as anyone who’s ever served on a committee well knows, the bigger the group, the longer — and not necessarily better — the process.
So I guess the fact council’s boundary review committee last week actually recommended that council should be trimmed to just 20 members, plus the mayor, qualifies as good news.
Still seems way too big, to me.
To get a sense of how Halifax compared to other jurisdictions, I did some calculations based on stats for the 20 biggest municipalities in Canada. (The ratios I calculated by dividing population by council size, as best I could determine it.)
Based on the 2006 census, Halifax was 13th on that list in terms of overall population — but tied (with Ottawa) at fifth for the biggest city council, while placing fourth in ratio of fewest residents per councillor.
HRM, as it’s properly called by everyone except, oh, those who live here, other Nova Scotians and the rest of Canada, had 372,679 residents in 2006.
That left it well behind places like Toronto and Montreal, of course, along with Calgary (988,193), Ottawa (812,129), Edmonton (730,372), Mississauga (668,549), Winnipeg (633,451), Vancouver (578,041), Hamilton (504,559), Quebec City (491,142), Brampton (433,806) and Surrey, B.C. (394,976), and just ahead of Laval (368,709), London (352,395) and Markham (261,573). When you looked at council sizes, however, Halifax shot up the chart.
Including mayors, the biggest municipal councils can be found in Montreal (with an astounding 66), Toronto (45), Quebec City (38), Longueil, Que. (27), Halifax and Ottawa (both 24), Laval, (22) and Gatineau, Que. (18).
(Yes, Quebec seems to be fertile ground for big city governments.)
Behind Halifax were bigger municipalities like Calgary (15), Edmonton (13), Mississauga (12), Winnipeg (16), Vancouver (11), Hamilton (16), Brampton (11) and Surrey (9).
London, just slightly smaller than Halifax, has a council of 15, including the mayor.
If you break down council sizes by population, only Longueil (8,494), Quebec City (12,924) and Gatineau (13,451) have fewer residents per council member, including mayors, than Halifax (15,528), at least among the 20 largest municipalities in Canada.
Municipalities that are similar to Halifax, population-wise, have bigger ratios: Brampton (39,437), Surrey (43,886), Laval (16,759) and London (23,493).
Now, some argue that because HRM is among the largest municipalities in Canada in land size, council here needs to be bigger.
There’s merit to that point, no question; but when Edmonton, with twice as many people as Halifax, can get by with almost half the size of council, I’d say the facts still favour cutting here.
Though I don’t think they went far enough — 15 would make sense — I’m shocked the review committee recommended cutting some colleagues’ jobs at all.
Odder still was hearing HRM’s man of mystery, otherwise known as Mayor Peter Kelly, last week say that most people he’s heard from like things the way they are.
In fact, some, he said, want an even bigger council, because it would be more "effective."
Yes, I know there were many times during those cat bylaw debates that I pondered how quickly the whole issue could have been decided if only we’d had a half-dozen more councillors queuing up to share their tales of local homes overrun with kittens.
Funny, though, that the mayor was singing a different tune just a few months ago.
Back in January, Kelly, who’s chairing the boundary review committee, said in an interview he’d noted "a public appetite" for a smaller council.
"We have heard those underpinnings to go in that direction," Kelly told Herald city hall reporter Michael Lightstone.
When it comes to our fence-sitting mayor, it doesn’t get much clearer than that, does it?
Council decides on this next month, so if you’ve got some underpinnings to pass along to your councillor on the subject, don’t be shy.
( [email protected])
|
A positive article in the Chronicle Herald about reducing council size.
|
|
|