Quote:
Originally Posted by wrendog
It's kind of a non story. The difference between #1 and #50 is only 8 points. Not a big deal.
|
Wrendog: I agree with you. Utah's #1 ranking on the Gallup "Happy" scale is probably a non-story, but for a different reason. The 8-point difference between first and last could mean a great deal, such as the difference between a 4.4 and a 5.2 sec's in the 40 yard dash...which is a HUGE difference.
Gallup is a very well respected polling organization, but what I object to in this poll, or any others like it, is what does the difference mean? What is the relevance? There is no context for the data.
Back in my old days working in drug development, we used to have lots of measures to assess the effectiveness of whether a new drug worked or not. But the only measures we cared about were those that had what we called "clinical relevance." In other words, do the measures reflect a true difference in the patients health or overall well-being?
So I disregard data like the stuff from the Gallup poll because it doesn't tell me if the people in Utah are truly better off than the people in West Virginia. Worse, these are self-reported data, meaning the pollster calls a selected sample and asks questions like: "Are you more optimistic today than you were last year?" or something like that. Self-reported data are notoriously inaccurate.
Much better comparative data would come from data that correlate with "happiness," such as suicide rates, divorce rates, alcohol and other substance abuse rates, based on the assumption that suicide, divorce, and substance abuse are inversely related to happiness. The data directly relate to the question.
For example, during last year's election, much was made of the corporate tax rate in the US as being 38%, which seems high when you compare it to the tax rates of other highly developed nations. It isn't. There are so many loopholes in US tax code that the effective corporate tax rate is more like 24%, which is near the bottom of highly developed countries. Given the mess that is going on now, it clearly looks like we got what we paid for...not much.