Quote:
Originally Posted by eman
Do other architects here agree with Bellamy that restrictive zoning is NOT a problem?
Architects competition is Home Depot. Long before any project gets near their desk Home Depot has been making bank keeping run down properties away from development. Restrictive zoning in OV and other neighbourhoods that only allows a single family home or 3 story walkup to become a 4 story with an elevator and parking means it's never going to happen as smart money will keep going into renovations.
30 years ago I lived on Bole Street, that house and 12 others on that street look almost identical despite cracked brick foundations. so the population of that street is stagnant and so are all the other streets between River and Stradbrook. Bole at River does have a beautiful 6 floor building(5468796 Architects I believe), but as its on River it should have been taller, but zoning probably maxed out at 6 right? Restrictive zoning also inflates the property values so even these run down old houses are costly to acquire. River at Nassau for example has 3 recent buildings, all 4 floors that easily could have been 10+ floors like 555 River right across the street.
Will Bole Street look the same in another 30 years? If the zoning stays the same,, yes. Stagnation is the zoning default.
|
The market dictates what developers are willing to build. Not zoning.
Can single family zoning be limiting in terms of its established parameters? Yes, it most certainly can. Its why many cities are moving away from this type of regulation.
However, if you think towers aren't being built because of zoning then you're really missing the mark....et.
Do you think a developer comes to Winnipeg with visions of 30 storey towers in O.V but scuttles off once they investigate the development parameters? No, not the case.
If a developer wants to build a tower in Winnipeg and has the financial backing to do so, they will. Full stop.
Never once have I worked with a developer who came to a community with ideals of project and then left because the zoning was an issue. They worked around, or within, the established regulations to see it to completion. It's what they do.