Quote:
Originally Posted by TheHonestMaple
It's just so bizarre and blatantly poor design, surely someone somewhere in the design team would have noticed. And surely anyone inspecting the work would also see that its going to lead to a mess. I just can't imagine it being left like this.
|
Same - at least we are equally aghast - but.. we sorta knew this was coming.. It's like someone tried to design it with no concept of traditional design based purely off visual aesthetic - there is a reason a lot was done the way it was originally - like someone said stone lintels are supposed to represent supporting a window - so why put a break in the middle - stone erodes - so why put a spout directly on top - and there is a thing called harmonious design - so why not properly size the stone and space it out appropriately? I just don't get it - they had one job, ONE JOB. Don't fuck it up! They failed.
I am not too TOO concerned about the uneven stone, at least that is a bit more reflective of how things might have ACTUALLY been built back in the day without precision cutting.
I mean it's still better than spandrel glass but god.. its just so cheap..
I think the problem is we have gotten used to the excellence of core urban, so our standards are higher - and while I sometimes feel core urban tries to play the safe side in visual aesthetic by sticking to simple stone carved shapes (probably cheaper to do, but it ain't no royal connaught cornices for example) I still feel when it comes to designing visually pleasing stuff, they know their shit.
Also for those who say craftsmanship is dead - you can LITERALLY feed a design into a 3d program and have a robotic arm carve the element into stone - or just 3d print it - that kinda stuff has never been easier technology wise. They replicated entire parts of destroyed architecture in europe doing this.
Sigh.. we need more specialists.