A lot of people either love or hate the Irvings. For me, it's more of a very frustrated respect. This is because they wield a great deal of power and influence, and while they have done a lot of good things (e.g. Centerbeam Place), at the same time they've often taken actions with vehemently anti-urban consequences that are hurting SJ.
To name just 3 examples:
-The creation and perpetuation of vacant lots in the Uptown. All the parking lots on the Imperial Theatre block are Irving-owned (either JDI or Cobalt Properties), as is basically every empty lot along Elliott Row (many of which were created when JDI acquired and demolished the buildings on those lots), as just two fairly egregious examples.
-The
recent demolition of two heritage mansions along Mount Pleasant Avenue, so there would be a larger undeveloped buffer around their own estate.
-Editorials and media coverage in the Telegraph-Journal that appeal to demeaning and demoralizing negativity far more often than they employ respectful and constructive criticism.
I don't wish to single out the Irvings on this: most powerful entities in NB, public and private, do things all the time without any thought about its impact on our urban fabric. Moosehead has been aggressively acquiring land and residential properties in the neighbourhoods around Main Street West, casting a shadow over this area's future potential. And I'm not even gonna get started about our provincial government, or the Port for that matter. This is why it's so frustrating to be an urbanist here: almost everyone, whether it's their intention or not, is working against us.