City prefers fitness centre for Storyeum site
VANCOUVER - City staff is recommending a proposed homeless shelter at the former Storyeum building in Gastown be rejected in favour of a fitness centre.
The Downtown Eastside Residents' Association suggested the failed Storyeum site at Water and Cordova streets be turned into a 24-hour shelter to house the downtown poor and get them off the streets.
But a staff report suggests this plan -- as well as a proposal by Xcalibur Bowling & Entertainment Ltd. to turn the site into a 48-lane bowling alley -- are too "expensive and impractical" and would not provide the necessary financial returns.
Instead, city staff is recommending council lease the 31,000-square-foot site to Eco Fitness Ltd. Partnership, which is expected to provide $750,000 revenue to the city each year for the first five years of the 10-year term.
DERA, by comparison, has cited the financial returns as "lessening the heavy financial demand on social and municipal services," while Xcalibur said its revenue would be about $600,000 a year.
"The design, zoning and built form condition of the premises would be prohibitive challenges to implementing the uses of a homeless shelter and bowling alley, respectively," the city report by John Breckner states.
The report will go to council next Tuesday for approval.
At least two councillors say they doubt the site, which is zoned commercial and was vacated by Storyeum in November 2006, is appropriate for a homeless shelter.
The city terminated the lease with Storyeum's parent company, Historical Xperiences, after it sought bankruptcy protection in August 2006 and became insolvent.
NPA Coun. Kim Capri said Wednesday she hadn't read the staff report but said there are a number of reasons why the city is reluctant to put a homeless shelter at the Gastown Parkade. She said most of them stem from concerns from neighbouring businesses, which argue they already have enough challenges to boost business and tourism and create economic vitality in the area.
As part of its proposal, Eco Fitness has said its 24-hour, seven-day-a-week facility will generate 25,000 member visits each month, increasing pedestrian traffic in the area.
Members of the Downtown Eastside Residents' Association couldn't be reached for comment Wednesday.
Vision Coun. Raymond Louie agreed the site is more appropriate for commercial uses. "It has been empty for a while and we [need] to ensure we realize some value for our citizens," he said.
He said there are better areas for a homeless shelter, such as closer to the Woodward's development, and said the provincial and federal governments have to step up in the battle against homelessness.
[email protected]
http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/...?id=4a8d7273-3489-42bd-8b76-c053dfcde0e6